< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·
|Dec-04-12|| ||Conrad93: Jim Bartle those games refer to the games themselves, not to the tournament. |
This is the tournament forum.
|Dec-04-12|| ||Fusilli: Taimanov vs Najdorf, 1953 must be my favorite game from this tournament. And it still has to be GOD... perhaps no one could come up with a good pun.|
|Dec-05-12|| ||Jim Bartle: Yes, Conrad, I was just pointing out there's been lots of interest. As phony benoni pointed out, the tournament page is new.|
|Dec-05-12|| ||Conrad93: What exactly motivated Bronstein to write a book on this tournament?|
Obviously it wasn't his success.
|Dec-05-12|| ||rilkefan: I've been playing over the games in Bronstein's book using a physical set in the hope of interesting my kids in the game.|
Thanks to those who set this page up, it's nice to have an easy way to look up commentary.
|Aug-21-13|| ||nescio: For years Bronstein's famous book (in a hardcover edition titled "The Chess Struggle in Praxis") was the only chess book I owned. Since then I have also read Euwe's excellent book on this tournament in Dutch. Not translated in English so far, but Euwe used a special language in his chess books with a limited vocubulary of only about a thousand words so that everybody can read it with a little effort.|
I heard there was still a third tournament book and it turned out to be completely different from the other two, but also the best of the lot. Najdorf evidently liked anlyzing as much as playing and sometimes he approached the quality of Boleslavsky or Keres in his annotations. It has now been translated in English: http://chess.about.com/od/chessbook...
|Aug-21-13|| ||Karpova: Najdorf, Miguel 'Zürich 1953 - 15 Contenders for the World Chess Championship', 2012, Milford CT USA|
Indeed an excellent book which by no means needs to hide itself from the other two classics on this tournament.
Sadly, the editing was done poorly and often* the game scores are partly incomplete. So I had to reconstruct some of the game scores myself (if only a few moves were missing, this is possible by looking at later moves or diagrams) but in some cases this was not possible with too many moves missing so I had to look it up elsewhere.
That's a serious objection, but apart from that the book is so outstanding that not even this can be considered a reason not to recommend it. You have a preface by Averbakh, biographhies of the players, Najdorf's great annotations and supplementary material by Taylor Kingston.
*I can't give numbers, but much too often for my taste as a game collection should be authoritative on the game scores in my opinion.
|Jan-29-14|| ||thomastonk: I just enjoyed this gallery: http://www.zurich-cc.com/photos1953..., though I had seen it some time before.|
|Mar-17-14|| ||WCC Editing Project: |
Both <Boleslavsky> and <Smyslov> were seeded directly into this tournament due to their results at the Budapest Candidates (1950): Boleslavsky 2d place, Smyslov 3d place.
<"3d place in the <<<Budapest 1950 Candidates Tournament>>> gave me the automatic right to a place in the next Candidates Tournament.">
-Vasily Smyslov, "Smyslov's 125 Selected Games" Ken Neat transl. (Cadogen 1983), p.125
|Mar-17-14|| ||perfidious: <thomastonk> Thanks for posting that excellent gallery!|
|Mar-17-14|| ||zanzibar: I've tried to identify all the people pictured in the group photograph (3/63).|
1. Petrosian 2. Kotov 3. Gligoric 4. Geller 5. Averbakh 6. Smyslov 7. Boleslavsky 8. Taimanov 9. Bronstein 10. Keres 11. Nadjorf
1. Dmitri Postnikof (USSR chess chief) 2. Szabo 3. Euwe 4. Folke Rogard (FIDE President) 5. Reshevsky 6. Stahlberg
There is likely a couple of mistakes. Corrections/affirmations appreciated.
|Mar-18-14|| ||ozmikey: <zanzibar> I think No.3 in the top row is Szabo, not Gligoric. In fact, I don't think anyone in the front row is a competitor at the event (it's clearly not the full photo).|
|Mar-18-14|| ||Olavi: <ozmikey: <zanzibar> I think No.3 in the top row is Szabo, not Gligoric. In fact> Correct. 2nd left seated is Ari Ilmakunnas.|
|Mar-18-14|| ||zanzibar: Thanks, <ozmikey> and <Olavi>. We'll hash it out. I had trouble with several of them. |
But all the fifteen participants are there according to the caption:
<< Folke Rogard, FIDE-President
Dmitri Postnikof (first row l), Folke Rogard (first row, 4th from left) and the 15 tournament participants >>
(That makes 3 certain identifications - since I'm only 100% sure I got Petrosian right!)
|Mar-21-14|| ||zanzibar: Here's my guess with the suggestion of Szabo. It's a bit like musical chairs, permutating the candidates around:|
1. Petrosian 2. Kotov 3. Szabo 4. Geller 5. Averbakh 6. Smyslov 7. Boleslavsky 8. Taimanov 9. Bronstein 10. Keres 11. Nadjorf
1. Dmitri Postnikof (USSR chess chief) 2. Stahlberg 3. Gligoric 4. Folke Rogard (FIDE President) 5. Reshevsky 6. Euwe
I think it's right, with a measure of uncertainty for the following 3 pairs:
Geller and Taimanov look very similar to me, but I think I got that right.
Gligoric's should have been easier to identify, but I thought his hair wasn't right. But given Szabo placement, where else can he be?
Strahlberg was unknown to me, and so difficult. Euwe apparently was a larger man than I originally thought.
|Jun-19-14|| ||offramp: <thomastonk: I just enjoyed this gallery: http://www.zurich-cc.com/photos1953..., though I had seen it some time before.>|
Thanks for that gallery!
In this picture, http://www.zurich-cc.com/img_zu/pla... Smyslov is holding one of those resiny fake-bronze trophies available at any cobbler/key-cutter for a tenner; in fact the man on the top of the trophy has a tennis racquet in his hand!
|Jun-19-14|| ||offramp: Some other great pictures!
Taimanov's trousers are the eighth wonder of the world! Undoubtedly he has a miniature version of UNIVAC sellotaped to his shins.
The players are standing along that thin harbour wall exactly according to their tournament standing!
http://www.zurich-cc.com/db_admin/i... I wonder what are the medals worn by Averbakh & Keres but not by Smyslov?
|Jun-19-14|| ||offramp: <offramp: Some other great pictures!
http://www.zurich-cc.com/db_admin/i... Taimanov's trousers are the eighth wonder of the world! Undoubtedly he has a miniature version of UNIVAC sellotaped to his shins.|
http://www.zurich-cc.com/db_admin/i... The players are standing along that thin harbour wall exactly according to their tournament standing!
http://www.zurich-cc.com/db_admin/i... I wonder what are the medals worn by Averbakh & Keres but not by Smyslov?>
Sorry - those links don't seem to work; but if you go through the pictures you'll see the ones I mean.
|Dec-01-15|| ||siggemannen: the photos are relocated to http://www.zurich-cc.com/zurich-195...|
nice ones, especially Geller looks pretty sharp =)
|Jan-06-18|| ||Marmot PFL: Two different tournaments for Euwe: +1 the first half and -6 in the second.|
|Jun-08-18|| ||OrangeTulip: Euwe scored 7.5 out of the first rounds. And than only 4 out of the last rounds.
What happened with him in this 1953 Canidates and the 1948 tournament? Poor health, poor condition, or?|
|Jun-08-18|| ||Howard: Age may very well have been a factor. He was almost certainly the oldest player in the event, at 51.|
|Jun-09-18|| ||HeMateMe: maybe the most famous tournament book ever.|
|Jun-09-18|| ||MissScarlett: <maybe the most famous tournament book ever.> #redundancy #ifnothingtosaysaynothing #jogon|
|Jun-09-18|| ||HeMateMe: are you and Harry still blowing people? I mean blowing kisses, as was described yesterday?|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·