< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·
|Feb-08-07|| ||notyetagm: <keypusher: I remember being very impressed by Botvinnik's notes to this game, particularly his demonstration that one weakness leads to another. As he explains, ...Nb6 is an error -- the knight winds up with no retreat from the square, and the queen and the other knight are tied down to its defense.>|
That's funny. I just won my Wednesday night league game by trapping a Black knight on h6 which had <NO RETREAT>.
|Jun-08-09|| ||ungeneral: Kxh5 24. Ng3+ Kh4 25. Qe4 1-0|
|Oct-02-09|| ||Ulhumbrus: On 23...Kxh5 24 Ng3+ (ungeneral) not only checks the black King but discovers as well an attack upon the square g6 (the square which the Black King has just left) from White's Queen, and so prevents Black's King from going back to g6.|
|Dec-03-10|| ||SoundWave: Herman Grooten gives a good explanation of this game in his book 'Chess Strategy for Club Players' pp. 275-278.|
|Jul-25-14|| ||Pakla: Botvinnik shows his strength|
|Jan-22-16|| ||thegoodanarchist: If you must play 22...Kxg6 you might as well resign!|
|Jan-22-16|| ||thegoodanarchist: Of course no one wants to play 23...Kxh5
24.Ng3+ Kh4 25.Qe4+ and mate next move.
|Jan-22-16|| ||Penguincw: The other Botvinnik vs. Mikhail games: http://www.chessgames.com/perl/ches....|
|Jan-22-16|| ||al wazir: I got 21. Nh4, but I didn't anticipate 21...Qe7. I thought black might respond 21...Rg8/Rf2 or 21...Nd5. Black is a ♙ up, so he can give back some material in return for security. He doesn't have to take the ♘ on g6 if his ♕ isn't on e7.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||agb2002: I know this game. No fun today.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||stst: One line:
.... other variations possible,.... bed time!
|Jan-22-16|| ||diagonalley: <stst> i went similarly to yourself and didn't consider 21.N-R4 :-(|
|Jan-22-16|| ||morfishine: I tried to win the Queen but it didn't work|
|Jan-22-16|| ||gofer: The start is simple...
<21 Neg5+ ...>
I can't see black allowing white to keep its knight so easily, so I would
guess the exchange happens immediately and be get a "knight-reloader", which
<21 ... hxg5>
<22 Nxg5+ ...>
Black cannot attempt to keep hold of Pg6, due to the mating threats on the h file.
The only option is to move Bg7 and that allows white the chance to play Qh4+, Qh7+
22 ... Kg6?!
<22 ... Kg8>
<23 Qxg6 Rf6>
<24 Qh7+ Kf8>
Now for the tricky bit we have only won two pawns for our knight, so we need
to make the most of flushing the king into the middle of the board.
On thought is to make Qa3 regret the day she went into the fray leaving her king so
unprotected with 25 Rc5! But I think that winning back the exchange or another pawn
beforehand is probably sensible...
<25 Qe4 ...>
click for larger view
Hmmm, more difficult than most Fridays...
Ahhh, that would be why!
|Jan-22-16|| ||wooden nickel: I love the follow-up 23.Bh5+! ... I was fooling around with 23.Nd6+.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||patzer2: My attempt at solving this Friday puzzle was 21. Nc5 . |
Deep Fritz 15 gives 21. Nc5 as a second best move, which gives White a lasting advantage and winning chances after 21. Nc5 a4 22. Ra1 axb3 23. Nxb3 Qe7 24. Rxa8 Nxa8 25. Bd3 Nc7 26. Bxg6+ Kh8 27. Bd2 Nd5 28. Qc1 Qf6 29. Bb1 Rf7 30. Re1 Nf4 31. Qc2 Nf8 32. Bxf4 Qxf4 33. Ne5 Bxe5 34. dxe5 Kg8 35. Nc5 b6 36. Ne4 Qxe5 37. Qxc6 Qc7 38. Rc1 Qxc6 39. Rxc6 Bb7 40. Rxb6 Rc7 41. f3 Nd7 42. Rb4 Bd5 43. Kf2 Kg7 44. Kg3
(+1.42 @ 22 depth, Deep Fritz 15).
The computer first choice is Botvinnik's 21. Nh4! Playing it out move by move with Deep Fritz 15 gives a best play continuation 21. Nh4 Rf5! 22.g4! (not 22. Nxf5? exf5 23. Nc5 Nd5 24. Ra1 Qb4 25. Bd2 Qxd4 26. Nxd7 Bxd7 27. Rxa5 Re8 28. Bc4 with much stiffer Black reistance) when play might continue 22... Rd5 (22... Rf7 23. Ra1 Qe7 24. Nxg6 Kxg6 25. Nd6+ Kf6 26. g5+ hxg5 27. Bh5 Nf8 28. Ne4+ Kf5 29. Nxg5+ Kf6 30. Nh7+ Nxh7 31. Qg6#) 23. Nc5 Nf8 24. Nxg6 Nxg6 25. h4 Nd7 26. h5 Ndf8 27. hxg6+ Kg8 28. Bc4 Qb4 29. f4 b6 30. Nd3 Qe7 31. Ne5 Bxe5 32. dxe5 Rxd1+ 33. Rxd1 Qh4 34. Qg2 Nxg6 35. Bd3 Kg7 36. Bf2 Nxf4 37. Bxh4 Nxg2 38. Kxg2 (+6.23 @ 20 depth, Deep Fritz 15).
For an improvement in Black's game, I'd start in the opening and replace the infrequently played 5...c6 with the much more popular move and computer choice 5...dxc4 = (0.11 @ 35 depth, Komodo 9.3) as in Navara vs A Giri, 2016.
Also, in place of 10...a5? allowing 11. Be3 , Deep Fritz 15 finds the Black improvement 10...e5! = when 11. a5? is met with 11...exd5 .
|Jan-22-16|| ||zb2cr: With respect to the follow-up moves shown grayed-out--I was reminded of the saying: "The laziest King flees wildly in the face of a double check." I think it was Tartakover who said that.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||LoveThatJoker: I didn't get it today.
|Jan-22-16|| ||kevin86: The focus square in g6. The king is chased into the open and put in danger.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||CanITakeThatBack: And if black’s next move was King x H5, then the continuation would be 24) Kg3+ Kh4 25) Qe4# right? |
Also was 21) Qe7 black's best move?
|Jan-22-16|| ||Marmot PFL: Not surprised that white wins with a combination as f5 looks very dubious when black has such poor development. Found the knight sac but then didn't see Bh5+ unfortunately.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||chrisowen: Nar h4 by wand harness if ive if brine passive vine I can ill affords an kip jack v rules it kinds iv vetter tu i na naturals rises and i nib pen blush an lush hollow and how blow hat vis h4 ran horse hob lob nob rob ow low bow now victor ravs undone rab bins rad hail ar backs it kinds iv vetter rinse vet h4 won bullshine vow rascal cradle vet an darks it kinds iv vet ow want aid lavish ar ha vine bons raids iv vetter drop ok v ogle fashion am vet vat wat tiff any glass eel wax a cut i curry favour v i nah foot iv as how blight erm merks it kinds iv vetter coup civic quell ja hatchet risen gaff fag flung gotcha fit vita da v an garages am vow vine git fin an goof inter glide invests example good wovern iv drip exchange off angled it alive no more bus again cable wires it over vide ogle fashion glocker gun cap again pin quip que accost ukelele mind dinks it kinds iv vetter bish horse hag h4 call glock g6 garages am jugged it kind o van v vetter ash h4 arm hoots g6 as wins h5 bishop ie bruv vine ye judge badge budge guy h4 ha ash on jeeps it overs v ogle fashion kin marks it kinds iv an vetter glide g6 garages win wait ogle vocals i vent again focus am revver danglers jas iv vim hip land lub bullshine rise now win rinses out fit give garcon cage v rules it alive is ha vim accost i cast caissa occular vote ve nemo bents nebulas tar good I cans cats classic i chaste cairns chassis load h5 ar win mate 4 vent fat chance maybe backs it kinds v vetter e7 i ment quarter backs it over i v ogle of fashion am foot ebony queens e7 ment quarter backs it kinds iv vetter glide boot buffet aids d5 delver equal am just again cab cable wire bus batch charybdis
mob bi modal agreement maybe bam h4 hash
bomb bum be my guest vote vine 4
bermuda triangle mib brooms weep an chimney am guy h4 jeeps it over v ogle am fashion gem goods kim of then jungle palm cone marks it kinds iv vetter ash b4 an a3 la nar kit dive again wait vim va va voom raise v rise now risen fit give glock gun cap again cog h4 cup first amp h4 catch g6 garages angles it alive no more fit give 4 horse quells am ja hatchet host light rule want alma at fort h5 mate at 4 vent hinch am lift winch eg win cascade cup i ogle nas eel three pin ar on i v ogle tan odd quell time tans l0 vim as hunt fan flood forces ar wax a cut i curry favour ive now lined it either bind eve good d5 and bad e7 riguer illa hi v check g6 and wig garages aid v do then math an da good 4 quell am quick question at a3 equal?
|Jan-22-16|| ||chrisowen: Tint as level and green gauge vent oh books nag it is ok vs hi v ogle of then h5 hand h4 horse add flow bawl then mob arm yin kevlar grip ok v ogled it alive no more vim revs am gem flows am floods pin has photon bet an bine wood cassia family inter glide rev eg etc able wire bus h4 joker card it edict vent devourer civic erm an iv robber ghost toot h5 mouth ala confide roof visions plinkers rule me did blip d5 it ie vine 4 horse b6 buffets around queens e7 ment quarter backs it kinds iv vetter bish h5 mates at 4 vent hinch am lift book call egs cleric hoot tint h5 an goods pin mummys here rams rinse vim call an get civic goot then famile cascader iv off good rev info choose book it kind v vetter et al rad i ogles it over eg i ment v an do vet civic for win bind chooses angle flight vetter bishop it alive no more bus tore vet mind votes bruv and do g6 as cad o delve infer tile ground glorify oh door as put inter glide tantric bad cutoff a7s point good delve and duos deems iv do i vet ash good act teet d5 horse b6 angle banals am flurry it alive no more gov as put invest again maid h5 mates at 4 vent hinch am lift an done vim again da horses wash an card it ardent vent again ar as low inter guilder devines again am cruise vent at i 21.Nc5 cradle guild off an i 21.Nh4 Qe7 dosh i rev douche bag i vent halls hails ha gen das boot hangs happy horde hocks vent back it kind v vetter as honour and hope at vent again bruv good hades hutch vim i hucks hulls hoots g6 garages am gangles right tickle then gauge hands hells bells inter glide example good pin eg liege nt often again ash i hoofs huggy buggy hints hello vent daccord bless again manage off rent ghosts at homes at v do me hymns hmmms bruv hints honks hippy horse hoots hatch huggy howls hairy manage took it divulge vim again balance bottles it ok vs ogle then am vide fashion ghost bruv h5 vent ghoul borough enough trough hang ha rink it alive no more vim again mates at 4 vent hinch am fat chance go bish henges am flight frought ovid er kips lung ash higgle hangglide higgle ja hatchets light jog hash length hung hues ar agog quip rough tough thought thang gush hug ghoul ash ghee oil good glad hush hash hinch gourd delve hag dug hid hood fan dangles it hind again an maneovre vantage off reenters am flung frag fog frigate vine mo vantage win fag v flood find fan do ford goof d5 gaff e7 guff gift gruff g6 garages rev under v is bish h5 mates at 4 vent hinch eg win fat chance to i 21...Nd5 point delver down probably avow apply an got plus 1 to advance ar wax a cut i curry favour i vent tilt d5s an go 22.Nxg6 Kxg6 mates again 4 vent hinch eg win fat change go at 22...Qd8 horse horde vim again hammer line clan invest aids g5 line wobble con eg liege nt often and vide lid big plus as how 23.Bh5+ i bet houses around mate van rev mates at 4 vent hinch eg win fat change go good an i mob momentum an yes maybe mind vote vim mystery plans mint vote vine gets bail link it kind v vetter 4 basic pad feel lines call i wag fit give clan gas hip cradle then h5 mates at 4 vent hinch eg win fat chance h7 monarch higgeldy piggeldy am what band finds land delver inducive gain flurry it ok vocal either vim binds i van tat rev h4 crab down eg liege nt often chases win am flurry it alive no more vapour trail g6 after bruv mid h4 bin harks it kind v vetter bish h5 mates vim at 4 vent hinch eg win fat change good build baby again rides g6 afar h5 it hives again am cruises win ash h4 cash horses wins labs wood forty: |
Apply inter glide horse vid h4 vain hinch eg win fat chance na boss pace man trap i na boss pace man trap i vote na boss pace man trap;
|Jan-22-16|| ||PJs Studio: Other than the fact every top GM knows this game by heart, I wonder how many of them would miss this combination? Maybe none, but my point is: Botvinnik is one of our greatest geniuses.|
|Jan-22-16|| ||PJs Studio: I'm a fairly good tactical player and I simply cannot look at this position the way he did. I'm in awe.|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·