|Oct-18-02|| ||refutor: From the tournament book by Wade
When asked if he would annotate the game, Bronstein replied "But it is impossible! You cannot make notes to such a game. You could make a whole book! It is not science; it is not mathematics; it is a chess gmae; we were playing chess. Neither of us knew what the next move was going to be. I cannot even tell you if I was winning. Such a game is played in the air."
What a game
|Oct-19-02|| ||Danilomagalhaes: 105 moves!! But for me, black is lost after the 51th move... |
|Oct-19-02|| ||Danilomagalhaes: If black plays right after the 51th move, he could win, but it would be hard |
|Feb-12-06|| ||Phony Benoni: I would put this up there with the Emanuel Lasker--Edward Lasker game from New York, 1924, as the greatest games lasting at least 100 moves.|
Panno seemed to be on the wrong end of a lot of strange games.
|Dec-08-06|| ||Gypsy: <Danilomagalhaes: 105 moves!! But for me, black is lost after the 51th move... > At Bronstein's offer, the game was played at one sitting (13 hours). Bronstein felt that he had a difficult win, but a win nonetheless. And he felt that adjourning the game and then finding the key to the position in an analysis would have been plain unsporting.|
|Dec-09-06|| ||Fisheremon: <Danilomagalhaes: 105 moves!! But for me, black is lost after the 51th move...> From 52nd move Panno made a wrong plan, so the first insignificant mistake was 52...Raa8 (52...Rd7 gives ) and 54...Rc8 was a blunder (better 52...Qd7).|
|Oct-18-07|| ||sanyas: Wow.... Just, Wow. WOWWWW. Ohhhkay. Whew. Whooah. This, now this is a chess game.|
|Oct-18-07|| ||keypusher: <Gypsy: <Danilomagalhaes: 105 moves!! But for me, black is lost after the 51th move... > At Bronstein's offer, the game was played at one sitting (13 hours). Bronstein felt that he had a difficult win, but a win nonetheless. And he felt that adjourning the game and then finding the key to the position in an analysis would have been plain unsporting.>|
Wow. Only Bronstein would do such a thing. Great story to go with a great game.
|Oct-18-07|| ||fm avari viraf: A great battle of wits & endurance. But in the end,it was my friend David who came out victorious knocking down [ Biblical Goliath ] Panno.|
|Mar-21-13|| ||FSR: <refutor: From the tournament book by Wade |
When asked if he would annotate the game, Bronstein replied "But it is impossible! You cannot make notes to such a game. You could make a whole book! It is not science; it is not mathematics; it is a chess game; we were playing chess. Neither of us knew what the next move was going to be. I cannot even tell you if I was winning. Such a game is played in the air.">
I read this too, then was surprised to see that Bronstein <did> annotate the game in <Chess Informant>.
|Jul-05-13|| ||Chessical: Bronstein plays sharply in the resumption. <48.Bxa6!?> which further opens up his K position in the face of both of Panno's rooks needed very accurate calculation to determine whether the passed <b> pawn would be sufficient compensation for the precarious shelter now left for his King. The whole game from now on demands exact calculation from both players as Bronstein's <b> pawn edges forward. |
<54...Rc8?> allows Bronstein to place a Rook on <c6> and recover an attacking initiative. <54...Qd7> would have been better.
Panno's <55...Kh6> avoids the loss of a Knight for a pawn after <55..Rd8> 56.b7 Bxb7 57.Qxb7 Ra7
<57.Nc6> appears very strong at first, but Black surprisingly can hold the position,
57...Qf7 58. Nxe5 Qe8 59. Rxf6 (59. Rc6 Re2) 59... Qxe5 60. Qd4 Qxd4 61. exd4 Bb5; instead <57.b7!> appears to win as Black's N and B cannot be simultaneously defended
<57.b7> 58.Rf1! Ng8 59. Rg1 Nf6 60.Nxb7
However, Black has a desparado line in this variation which would require nerves of steel for White to accept
<58...Bxd5!?> 59. exd5 Nxd5 60.Rxd5 Ra2+! 61.Kb3 Rb8 62.Qxb8 Qa3+
click for larger view
and White's King will escape to the K-side and victory.
<61.Rc7!?> the Rook does not have to leave the 6th rank <61.Nc5> Panno remains, however, the brink of defeat. He will not be able to stop the <b> pawn queening, and he will have a Bishop, Knight and two pawns for his own Queen. Fortunately for Panno, Bronstein then blunders away much of his advantage with <71.e4?>. <71.Rxg4> is a straightforward win. As the game goes the question is whether White now can to break through his opponent's shield of pieces.
<101....Re8?> allows White to finally penetrate Black's defences, <101...Bf5> would have maintained a desperate defence.
This game lasted over twelve hours.
|Jul-05-13|| ||Chessical: This is a great battle involving a pawn queened in front of Bronstein's King, and a long and desperate defence by pieces against a Queen without pawn support.|
White emerges from the opening with a small advantage in space. Black's position is cramped but solid and Panno needs to manoeuvre carefully to ensure that he is not reduced to passivity. <14...b5> is probably preferable to <14...g6>
Bronstein's 19th move 0-0-0 shows that he intends to play actively to win. There are dangers to going to the Q-side where Black already has the <c> file occupied with a Rook can play a5 to losen the pawn structure around White's King.
<25... a5!?> to sacrifice a pawn to weaken White's King's position is interesting and appears to give the initiative to Black <26. bxa5> Na6 27. Na2 Qc7 28. Nb4 Qc3+ 29.Ka2 Nxb4 30.axb4 Qxb4 31.Bxd2 Qxe4
click for larger view
Panno's actual move gives Bronstein has an easier game. It also was more accurate to play on his 26th move Nb6 and then White could not play 28.Qa6
<31...h5> is risky but Panno is in danger of going completely on the defensive. His Q-side opportunities of a few moves ago are gone, and Bronstein has the happy prospect of active play on both wings.
Towards the time control, Bronstein maybe under time pressure plays less incisively. <38.Rc6!> is very strong and probably winning. It is not even an exchange sac as Black has no room to manoeuvre to avoid returning the exchange. White is left with a mighty passed pawn on <c6>
<38. Rc6!> Bxc6? 39. dxc6 Rc7 40. Nxc7 Qxc7 41. b5; in this line Black has the clever intermezzo <38....Nxd5> intending to win back the Nb5, but after <39.Bxd5 Rxb5 40.Rxd6 White is winning.
By move 40, Bronstein has dissipated his advantage with Nc3, Ka2 and Nf3. Occupying the <g> file with a Rook would have been simple and strong, instead Bronstein has to give up his <h> pawn to avoid a three-fold repetition.
The resulting position is balanced, Bronstein has greater room for manoeuvre but Panno is now a pawn up.
|Feb-14-14|| ||Everett: < Bronstein felt that he had a difficult win, but a win nonetheless. And he felt that adjourning the game and then finding the key to the position in an analysis would have been plain unsporting.>|
The second half of this is Bronstein's love of playing, and hatred of homework. He was ever an OTB player.
|Dec-29-14|| ||perfidious: Had forgotten that this game was played in one go--unbelievable.|
|Dec-29-14|| ||Andrijadj: Boring Berlin :)|
|Dec-29-14|| ||perfidious: <Andrijadj: Boring Berlin :) >|
|Sep-05-15|| ||Everett: Thank you very much <Chessical>!|
|Sep-05-15|| ||Howard: Wait a minute! This whole game was played in one session?! |
Remind me to look at the tournament book, which I have at home.