|Sep-30-03|| ||Honza Cervenka: I would like to know where white lost the game. Geller's play since 25...Nd4! is stunning. After the 25th move of white I would have bet that white's attack on the queenside will carry a quick victory to Smyslov, but Geller demonstrated that the opposite was true. Very nice game. |
|Sep-30-03|| ||suenteus po 147: In my very humble and often uniformed position (Honza, you have always known better than I) it seems to me that Smyslov lost because he gradually gave up control of the white squares over the course of the game, allowing Geller to put irresistable pressure on g2 with his bishop and Queen. So I vote for 19. Qb2 as the point when Smyslov handed the game over to Geller. Not that I blame Smyslov; how could he know Geller would play 25...Nd4! ? |
|Sep-30-03|| ||drukenknight: what is his N doing on f3? Shouldnt he be hitting the Q w/ Nh4? It's not like that's the only N that can be used to block the diagonal.|
Hey wait a minute why does he want to put anybody on the white diagonal? Doesnt he want to advance the pawns on his K side?
|Sep-30-03|| ||Calli: Extremely double-edged position. 24.Bc5 weakens d4, enabling 25...Nd4!. But what else can White do? At first I thought 24.Ra3 Nxe3 25.Raxe3 held but then 25...Rf4! leads to 26.b5 Bc5.|
My suggestion is 24.Qb1. It appears defence is possible because the Queen exchange should Black move the knight. White also still has the b5 possibility. So <suenteus> maybe right that Qb2 is inaccurate, but White ,I think, can recover and save the game by moving the Q back to B1.
|Sep-30-03|| ||suenteus po 147: <drukenknight: Hey wait a minute why does he want to put anybody on the white diagonal? Doesnt he want to advance the pawns on his K side?>|
I think Symslov was trying to avoid destabilizing his kingside. A friend of mine (who beats me regularly at chess) suggested 20. g4 after black's knight move, but that gives up defense of the h3 pawn and allows a possible inroad for the queen, after 20...Bxf3 21. Nxf3 Qe4 22. Kg2 Nd5 etc. True, mate isn't as imminent, but it's still not a great situation for white afterward. But who knows? Smyslov might have turned this line into a win.
|Oct-01-03|| ||Calli: 20.g4 h5 looks bad. |
|Aug-15-10|| ||Xeroxx: My suggestion is 24.b5
|Aug-29-16|| ||NoraNora: 27. Qg4+ Qxg4 28. hxg4 Rc3 was better
Stokfish 6 - -0.80
click for larger view