< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 9 OF 9 ·
|May-25-17|| ||zanzibar: And, from ibid p405, we have Harding quoting Buckley's review of Blackburne's book, specifically commenting on Graham:|
<In the Birmingham Weekly Mercury, of 18 November 1899, Buckley first praised
the games, the collection of which "must be an endless pleasure to
amateurs of many succeeding generations."
Then he wrote:
The editor's work is less satisfactory, though Mr. P. Anderson Graham
has at least one requisite for the task. He possesses enthusiasm, and,
moreover, is a sincere admirer of his hero. But his biographical
sketch is lamentably incomplete and unsatisfactory, The sketch of the
history of blindfold chess is little more than a pretence, and both
sketches have the painful air of amateurishness which is the almost
invariable characteristic of chess lucubrations. We cannot but regret
that a subject so interesting should have been given to the world so
imperfectly. The opportunity was a great one. The record of
Blackburne's career presented incomparable opportunities; but the
editor has derived little of interest there from, and largely contents
himself with writing of the catalogue-type mingled with his own
inconclusive opinions and doubtful statements.
|May-27-17|| ||MissScarlett: Does Harding estimate how many simul exhibitions Blackburne gave over the years? The number of times one sees references to him in newspapers, one could be forgiven for thinking he played chess non-stop for 50 years. And yet there are less than a thousand of his games here. |
The only masters who come to mind who might challenge him on this front are Alekhine, Koltanowski and Marshall, but I can't speak about the Continental scene.
|May-27-17|| ||zanzibar: I'm not sure about general simuls, but for blindfolds, Harding gives a listing in his appendix V |
< ~2444 total (excluding just a few exceptions) W-L-D = 1552-202-660 >
Harding must give an estimate of Blackburne's total, but I couldn't readily find it.
|Jun-19-17|| ||zanzibar: Blackburne interview excerpt:
Edward Pindar (kibitz #12)
|Jun-26-17|| ||Tabanus: There is an excellent drawing (worthy of inclusion IMO) in the Illustrated London News, 8 Oct 1881.|
|Jun-27-17|| ||zanzibar: <Tab> is it online anywhere?|
Where did you see it?
If it's not available online can you mail me a scan? I could post it for you (well, for the www - whole wide world) if you'd like.
|Jun-27-17|| ||zanzibar: Ah, I see, he's got the "I just won Berlin" shine.|
|Jun-27-17|| ||zanzibar: I always thought this one was rather grand:
(Maybe it's the hat?)
|Jun-27-17|| ||Tabanus: <z> That's a good one too, but not the one I found in ILN, 8 Oct 1881 (via the steadily improving http://www.britishnewspaperarchive.... who are constantly adding new periodicals). Oh, please, don't have me go through the OneNote (or whatever it was) process again.|
|Jun-27-17|| ||zanzibar: What's the OneNote process?|
|Jun-27-17|| ||Tabanus: Nah it was something else. The process of taking a screenshot and then making it available on the web. I did it a year or three back, and you told me how.|
|Jun-27-17|| ||zanzibar: <Tab> I really can't imagine doing my research without being able to save snippets of text and pictures.|
Certainly for visuals/portraits out of the old magazines and newspapers.
Of course, most of them go into various folders for personal use - but very many make their way to both <CG> and Zanchess.
You should start your own blog - it could be in Norwegian and showcase your research/writing, in addition to being a launching-pad for <CG> contributions.
|Jul-03-17|| ||Tabanus: My website would go stale after some years.|
|Jul-17-17|| ||Sally Simpson: I was reading 'The Story of the Dundee Chess Club' by Peter Walsh.|
The famous story about Blackburne taking a drink en passant apparently took place in Dundee in 1911.
The piece on page 29 starts off with "The following true story illustrates the good fellowship between him [Blackburne] and the Dundee players."
It continues with Blackburne taking a drink by mistake and then being jokingly forgiven. Then comes the famous en passant quip. He is giving another drink and another then Blackburne leaves a piece en prise and resigns.
Blackburne liked Dundee. Between 1897 and 1911 he visited the club every year bar 1910 to play simuls and give a lecture.
|Jul-17-17|| ||zanzibar: <My website would go stale after some years.>|
Perhaps, but so does pretty much every website, though some might last as long as a good bottle of whiskey. The real idea is to get a framework out there which others will copy and propagate.
<jnpope>'s site is one I hope lasts a long, long time.
What happens to <Winter>'s site will be interesting. <CG> will be OK as long as Daniel is around I think, but it will always run the risk of going the way ChessCafe did.
|Jul-18-17|| ||MissScarlett: Glory is fleeting but obscurity is forever.|
|Jul-18-17|| ||zanzibar: Entropy wins in the end.|
|Feb-03-18|| ||zanzibar: <Blackburne was a stone worker>|
|Feb-08-18|| ||MissScarlett: <We're all indebted to Harding for his wonderful biography.>|
But not enough to buy a copy.
|Feb-08-18|| ||zanzibar: <<Missy> But not enough to buy a copy.>|
I know this is an attempt at a snarky-knock, but really, it's rather presumptuous of <Missy> to represent Dr. Harding.
The good doctor and I have a reciprocal relation - he's able to use my research, like the stone worker find.
But let's examine the role of <Missy> to complain about $$ or ¡ê¡ê ... given his complaining about <ChessBase> policies,
Nils Grandelius (kibitz #72)
or his outright solicitation of <CG> funding for personal gain,
Kibitzer's Café (kibitz #222074)
Santa Claus (kibitz #1881)
Karpov - Fischer World Championship Match (1975) (kibitz #3233)
or his unending reliance of <Tab> for genealogical research:
Biographer Bistro (kibitz #17487)
Biographer Bistro (kibitz #17238)
Biographer Bistro (kibitz #17059)
How could anyone think <MissS> was <Edward Winter> is a bit beyond me.
|Feb-09-18|| ||MissScarlett: <The good doctor and I have a reciprocal relation - he's able to use my research, like the stone worker find.>|
I saw this before and was going to let it pass, but isn't that my find?
Joseph Henry Blackburne (kibitz #182)
I don't know what your game is, but if you annoy me further I'm going to add you to my little black book just below <Edward Winter>.
|Feb-10-18|| ||zanzibar: <MissS> yes, I've updated my blog page to credit you making the find first.|
I really only recalled <offramp>'s promise to visit the site from that period of time - and just stumbled across the original article again when doing some research on another topic.
My page didn't really have me making an original find, and while I'd normally put your posts at the top of the page, I think it reads better as is (especially given the fun little drawing of Blackburn aside the article).
Your attribution is at the bottom, in plain-view. Still wondering if Harding ever came across it, and just deemed it not worthy of inclusion, or not creditable enough.
|Apr-12-18|| ||Joshka: This guy never played Morphy I don't believe, was it for the same reasons as Steinitz? Didn't get really good until he was in his 30's?? Any help appreciated!|
|Apr-12-18|| ||WorstPlayerEver: <Joshka>
Maybe Blackburne took up chess because of Morphy, I suppose. Because only after Morphy retired Blackburne became professionally interested in chess :)
|Apr-12-18|| ||Nosnibor: <Joshka> Blackburne was already in the world`s elite players in his late twenties finishing in third place at Baden-Baden in July 1870 beating Steinitz,De Vere,Paulsen,Winawer,etc. He was less than 18 when Morphy left England but there is no doubt that he was influenced by his blindfold play which he himself took up later.|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 9 OF 9 ·