< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·
|Oct-23-04|| ||mack: There's a lot to be said for Andrew Martin - in fact he holds the record for the greatest number of participants taken on in a simul. 320+ if I remember correctly. |
|Nov-06-05|| ||Chesschufty: I played in his world record 320+ so I know you're right. He is based in Sandhurst-England and has written many books and presented DVD's-I think he is also a commentator for Chessbase. His world record was recently beaten by Susan Polgar.|
|Nov-06-05|| ||cade: His record was beaten but Martin questions the legitimacy of that event.|
|Nov-06-05|| ||GBKnight: Some of these games are not Andrew Martin, the English player. For example, the game against Ulf Andersson at Montilla 1977 was Angel Martin Gonzalez, the Spanish player. Its obviously difficult when the same name crops up many times.
I believe Andrew is still playing and definitely does commentaries/lectures etc. His commentaries are one of the highlights at the annual British Championship.|
|Mar-02-06|| ||midknightblue: Andrew Martin Chess Academy went live 3/1/06!|
|Mar-02-06|| ||jamesmaskell: Yeah. I signed up for that last night then realised the costs involved.|
|Mar-02-06|| ||midknightblue: haha <james>. I haven't signed up yet either, much as I would like to support Martin, as i think he has a lot to offer, in general. It is just that the amount of money one can spend on chess is neverending (books, websites, tournaments, lessons). But it seems like an interesting site.|
|Mar-02-06|| ||jamesmaskell: It hasnt cost me anything to sign up but I wont be buying anything from the site. Just cant afford anything right now.|
|May-17-06|| ||BIDMONFA: Andrew D Martin|
MARTIN, Andrew D.
|Aug-22-06|| ||Kriegspiel: Martin needs to toot his own horn here, discretely but diligently, and get some wins uploaded. A record of 31.9% is not exactly awe-inspiring, and while an incomplete or highly selective database offering can bias one's record enormously, that is not always apparent to the average viewer; and since Martin makes his living as a commentator and analyst appealing to the sensibilities of the average viewer, this deserves consideration.|
Also, he needs to change his Chessbase.com Playchess Radio commentator photograph. I see it every week there, and every week he reminds me of a Star Wars publicity photo of Darth Maul caught in a "doh!" moment. I've seen some perfectly fine, up-to-date photos of him on the net, so why anyone would choose a head-shot that makes him look like a deer caught in headlights is beyond me.
|Aug-22-06|| ||ray keene: andy martin supervises chess at wellington college where-gratifyingly-it is soon to become part of the curriculum. andy has been most helpful in helping to sort out minor difficulties at the second half of the staunton memorial also being held at wellington college-possibly the most beautiful venue i have ever seen for a chess event!|
|Sep-03-06|| ||EmperorAtahualpa: <His record was beaten but Martin questions the legitimacy of that event.>|
<cade> Who broke it?
|Sep-03-06|| ||Albertan: <EmperorAtahualpa: His record was beaten but Martin questions the legitimacy of that event.
<cade> Who broke it?>|
Hi EmperorAtahualpa, GM Susan Polgar beat Martin's record.You can read about this at this link:
|Sep-04-06|| ||apawnandafool: the crux of the argument is whether non chessplayers count as opponents in simul record-breaking attempts. |
every single one of martin's opponents were chessclub members of a minimum playing ability, while polgar's attempt included scores of mall shoppers.
as an added complexity, guinness did not witness polgar's attempt. so is it really official?
a polgar vs. martin 2007 simultaneous simul is needed, winner-takes-all. where each battle the same number of opponents of equal-relative strengths, at the same time in the same auditorium.
|Aug-05-09|| ||generaldamage: I've read that he has also beat Spassky; here's the link: |
|May-15-10|| ||KarenBindash: I've got several of the ChessBase Fritz Trainer series of DVDs. Andrew Martin is probably their most prolific author. He has authored videos on the Spanish Exchange Variation, Trompowsky, King‘s Indian, Scandinavian (two editions), Budapest Gambit, Vienna, Ruy Lopez, Sicilian Dragon, Anti-Dutch, Leningrad Dutch, Evans Gambit, Modern Benoni, Queen’s Pawn Openings and Alekhine openings. |
What concerns me is a complete lack of Martin's objectivity in his videos (I've not seen them all, though I have three). His first DVD on the Scandinavian (Center Counter) gives you the impression black can hardly lose. Almost all games show a Black win, with not a single White victory. I've looked over some of the games with a chess engine and it is clear in many cases white has an advantage before blundering, so then black goes on to win. After seeing this video, and a few more like it, I will not be buying any more.
Andrew Martin considers himself an expert on the Scandinavian, but I was less than impressed with his DVD which covers the Pytel Variation (1. e4 d5 2.exd5 Qxd5 3.Nc3 Qd6). Objectively, the Scandinavian is not a particularly successful opening for black (Black wins 26.1%, whereas white wins 45.4%), but Martin gives a very different impression. The Pytel Variation is a bit better than some of the others, but black only wins 24.4% of the games, with 46.4% being white wins and 29.2% draws - statistics just taken from chessgames.com
The Chesbase DVD on the Sicilian Alapin (2.c3) by Sergei Tiviakov is excellent. I don't know why Chessbase did not get Tiviakov to author a DVD on the Pytel variation of the Scandinavian, as Tiviakov is a strong GM, who is arguably the leading expert on that opening.
Martin 's DVD on the Caro Kann suffers from the exact same problem.
In his favor, Martin speaks good English, does not mumble, is enthusiastic. But the lack of objectivity puts me off of him.
I can't help but draw an analogy between Andrew Martin's prolific authoring of chess DVDs and Eric Schiller of chess books. I'm not saying Martin's work deserves the two-worded review of a Schiller book by Tony Miles in Kingpin, but there is definitely a problem of high quantity but low quality. Martin is also a prolific author of chess books, so perhaps he does aim to publish more than Eric Schiller!
|May-18-10|| ||wordfunph: books authored by IM Andrew Martin..
+ King's Indian Battle Plans
+ Starting Out - The Sicilian Dragon
+ The Essential Center-Counter
+ The Hippopotamus Rises
more books to write...happy birthday!
|Aug-09-10|| ||OBIT: <Karen>I don't think it's a problem when an opening book shows a high percentage of wins in favor of the opening. Now, some books do take this to the extreme. For example, I can recall a book on the 1. e4 c5 2. f4 variation of the Sicilian where White wins every game! |
The high percentage of victories suggests a biased view of the opening, I suppose, but then the club level players who buy the book are generally most interested in how to win with it - games that demonstrate successful strategies have the most appeal to them. Sure, include some games to illustrate pitfalls to avoid, but keeping the focus on how to win with the opening makes sense, IMO.
|Jun-23-11|| ||Paint My Dragon: For all those looking for some free chess lessons, I can thoroughly recommend Andy's YouTube channel (YMChessMaster).|
|Jul-16-11|| ||Shams: I heartily second <Paint My Dragon>'s tip -- Martin's channel is great. If you like his clips, please show your appreciation in the comments.|
|Jan-05-12|| ||ChessMan94: Good commentary from Andrew Martin on the Ivanchuk-Caruana game. http://www.youtube.com/watch?featur...!|
|Jul-03-17|| ||PhilFeeley: So many games missing here. I'm watching some of Martin's early videos and he mentions many games from 1989-1995 that are not here. I wonder why they're not.|
|Jul-03-17|| ||Tabanus: <PhilFeeley> It's because you did not send them in to CG, and then waited 3 months.|
|Nov-30-17|| ||Domdaniel: <Karen Bindash> Those are valid points ... but I don't think that Andy Martin is in the same zone as Schiller, the object of the great Tony Miles' famously brief put-down. I played Miles (somehow drawing, to my own surprise) and I am still an admirer of his games.|
I also have a few books and DVDs by Martin, and I think he's good. Not, maybe, the strongest player or best analyst, but still very capable.
|Nov-30-17|| ||Domdaniel: Should opening books/DVDs be even-handed? I've also seen books where, eg, a line in the French is portrayed as winning several games, with no losses. This clearly bucks the statistics...|
And yet ... why does an opening primer have to follow the stats? It may be more important, in a Black defence, to demonstrate some of the ways Black can win. Of course White improvements should be given in the notes, but sometimes the important thing is to show Black's best lines.
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·