< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
Oct-22-06 | | Morales: I am from Latin America and have read Calvo`s article. There is nothing racist in it. |
|
Oct-22-06
 | | fm avari viraf: Please keep aside dirtyyyyyyyyyyyy politics from this noble game of chess. But is it ever possible? Never. Can we eradicate virus from the globe completely? Not possible. So we must try to live with them & politics together. |
|
Oct-22-06
 | | al wazir: <Morales: There is nothing racist in it.> You're right. Here's the article: http://www.samsloan.com/one-brid.htm The only thing wrong with chess is chess politics. |
|
Aug-18-07
 | | Fusilli: <al wazir: <Morales: There is nothing racist in it.> You're right. Here's the article: http://www.samsloan.com/one-brid.ht...; Unbelievable! I just read it. It's true: there is absolutely nothing racist about it. What you can see instead is a man who was committed to removing Campomanes from the conduction of FIDE. His becoming "persona non grata" must have been simple retaliation. |
|
Oct-22-07 | | whiteshark: Quote of the Day from the Player of the Day:
<The greatest weapon of our enemies is that people will tire of fighting them. <<<<>>>>> --- Ricardo Calvo |
|
Oct-22-07 | | whiteshark: Calvo translated Emanuel Lasker's philosophical writing "Kampf" i.e. "struggle" into Spanish: <Lucha> If you are interested in it, the Spanish version has the ISBN 84-932593-0-6 or you can order the German version directly via the Lasker Society. to view it: http://www.lasker-gesellschaft.de/p...
(scroll down) |
|
May-20-08
 | | keypusher: Here's another link to the article: the ones below seem to be broken. http://www.anusha.com/one-brid.htm
|
|
Sep-04-08 | | ToTheDeath: What a bizarre and shameful action, trying to destroy a man for an <opinion>. Calvo had a biting wit as this excerpt from his article "On the Nature of FIDE Legitimacy" (http://www.goddesschess.com/chessto...) shows: <FIDE declared me "persona non grata" in 1987. The committee endorsing this decision was headed by USCF representative Arnold Denker [...] Anyway, I want to say a nice word about Denker´s play. When he obtained a certain notoriety by losing a match against a computer, I never believed that Denker could have been bribed. On the contrary, I have reasons to believe that bribes may have played a role in other victories of machine versus man. In the case of Grandmaster Emeritus Denker, I am sure that the machine was much stronger.> Ouch! |
|
Sep-30-08 | | whiteshark: Quote of the Day:
<The greatest weapon of our enemies is that people will tire of fighting them. <<<<<>>>>>> --- Ricardo Calvo
... you've lost already before
... fear is a bad adviser
... tired? |
|
Oct-22-10 | | Oceanlake: I remember that there was a cloud over FIDE during those times. The charge of racism is unsupported by this article. |
|
Dec-08-11 | | Olavi: Calvo beat Campomanes in a pretty game at the 1966 Havanna olympiad. It can be found in other online databases. |
|
Mar-08-12 | | whiteshark: Quote of the Day:
<The greatest weapon of our enemies is that people will tire of fighting them. <<<<>>>>> ~ Ricardo Calvo
or as Sun Tzu put it some 2,500 year ago: "
The best victory is
when the opponent surrenders of its own accord
before there are any actual hostilities...
It is best to win without fighting." |
|
Oct-26-12 | | Karpova: Edward Winter discussing the matter in his feature article <Ricardo Calvo: 'Persona non Grata'> from 1988: http://www.chesshistory.com/winter/... That's what Arnold Denker said about it: <Let me also commend you on your report on the Calvo matter, which I found to be the fairest and most objective I have seen so far. I say this in spite of the fact that some of your conclusions differ from mine.> |
|
Sep-24-16
 | | saffuna: Unless it happened twice, the time Calvo was punched was at Linares in 1992, by a Uruguayan chess writer offended at an article claiming a South American writer was "corrupting" young players. |
|
May-17-22 | | Z free or die: In the Bio...
<In 1987, Dr. Calvo was wrongly condemned by FIDE and declared persona non grata by a vote of 72-1.> I don't agree with the characterization <"wrongly">. This doesn't seem to be a universally held opinion on the matter, at least on a cursory look. And only citing Calvo's rebuttal is insufficient. I don't see the wiki article condemning FIDE's decision as being <wrong> either. Wiki's treatment is far superior. |
|
May-17-22 | | Petrosianic: <Wiki's treatment is far superior.> I'll take Phrases I've Never Heard Before for $500, Alex. Actually, Wiki's treatment isn't really better. They say Calvo was censured for "a racial attack", but don't bother to point out that no such attack actually occurred. They also reproduce quotes saying it's wrong to ban players for their ideas, without bothering to point out that Calvo wasn't banned from play, only censured. But the bio here is unclear at best. It states specifically that Calvo was wrongly condemned, but doesn't bother to say why it was wrong, or what it actually was, beyond "a racial attack", which it obviously wasn't. So, was Calvo wrongly condemned? Well, the racial claim is bogus, but he might arguably have been guilty of the same thing Karjakin was banned for: Bringing chess into disrepute. Calvo's article wasn't about race, but it did make chess politicians look pretty dirty. Deservedly so, to be sure, but that may not be a valid defense. |
|
May-18-22
 | | perfidious: Campomanes was an abomination and prostituted himself before the world; for writing as he did, while his language was, perhaps, intemperate, I do not believe Dr Calvo should have been PNG'd. |
|
May-18-22 | | Z free or die: <I'll take Phrases I've Never Heard Before for $500, Alex. Actually, Wiki's treatment isn't really better.> A cute turn of the phrase, to be sure. But...
<""a racial attack", but don't bother to point out that no such attack actually occurred. > ...
< beyond "a racial attack"> Was it or wasn't it?
Doesn't matter, FIDE termed it so, and it's not <CG>'s role to say if it was or wasn't. <CG> should stick to the facts, and just report FIDE's action, and rationale. Like Wiki does.
(And if a defender of Calvo the action as wrongful, then <CG> can put that in the bio, with references.) |
|
May-18-22
 | | perfidious: <zed....Doesn't matter, FIDE termed it so, and it's not <CG>'s role to say if it was or wasn't. <CG> should stick to the facts, and just report FIDE's action, and rationale. Like Wiki does....>
A clear-cut view with which I agree, though I was criticised for this some years ago by the late webmaster, who made a remark to the effect that my posts had all the excitement of a weather report. Did not feel it was my place to insert my views, but merely to report what had gone. |
|
May-18-22 | | Petrosianic: <CG should stick to the facts, and just report FIDE's action, and rationale. Like Wiki does.>
Except that Wiki didn't either. Again, they implied that Calvo was banned from play (untrue), and give the impression that a racial attack actually occurred (also clearly untrue). |
|
May-20-22 | | Z free or die: I don't really have a dog in this, as I didn't remember, or perhaps know, any of this controversy before <stonehenge> pointed it out. My impressions were quickly formed from a cursory reading of both <CG> and <wiki> from a neutral standpoint. It was clear that <CG> took a strong unsupported opinion with little or no context. I certainly didn't feel <wiki> did so, but I will go back and reread it at some point. I ought to read Winter's treatment as well. |
|
Apr-21-23 | | GonzaloCalvoPerez: My name is Gonzalo Calvo Pérez. I am Ricardo Calvo's son. There are a number of things that have to be said here, in order to honour truth and the legacy of my father: 1- There is obviously not a hint of racism in the article by my late father, as anyone can check, which proves the corrupt behaviour of FIDE, and the illegitimacy of the declaration of persona non grata. In this point I would be happier if the present FIDE responsibles were brave enough to acknowledge this, and to restore his public image, and therefore FIDE's honour. 2- My father always fought against corruption, both in chess and in medicine, as well as in politics (in the 80s he was not only the delegate of Kasparov for Spain and South America, but also the responsible of the international section of the spanish journal El Independiente), and there is an important information that should be known. My father, as medical doctor and chess expert, conducted the first real-time medical survey of chess players. He was the first person to scientifically measure the extreme levels of stress in the human body while playing chess. I know he made a film documentary on this, that received an international prize, in Switzerland, I think. -If anyone knows how to find a copy of it, and publish it in YouTube, it would be cool!- Also, before passing, he suggested that during Cold War doping with amphetamines was common at top-level competition, that it was implemented by political decisions, and that he had direct evidence and knowledge of it. This is obviously the main reason why he was, and still is, attacked by FIDE and others, even after almost 20 years of his passing. The context of Cold War, and the career of Bobby Fischer, among others, must be relativised under this light. Other games with societal/political relevance, such as football/soccer, are also clearly corrupted by doping, and we never have notice of any scandal about it, which is a clear indicator of a wider conspiracy, as anyone can understand. 3- The greatest discovery my father made, and he should be recognized for it, was that modern chess was invented in medieval Valencia. He dedicated the last decades of his life to perform what has probably been the deepest research ever made not only on the History of chess, but also on other aspects of the pure game itself, including complex geometrical studies on the abstract movements of the pieces, etc.. 4- As a medical doctor, when he worked in the spanish Ministry of Health (Ministerio de Sanidad), he was responsible for prohibiting a list of more than 300 medicines. These medicines were proven more harmful than beneficial to patients. Of course, the powerful international pharmaceutical lobby never forgot it. And linked to that corrupt lobby are/were other corrupt institutions, including the CIA, the KGB, and, of course, the FIDE. As we say in Spain: Truth hurts, but it does not offend. A final truth that should be mentioned more often is that chess itself also has downsides. It develops intelligence, but it does it towards a mentality of war. Therefore, it harms the minds of players, just as war does. War between human beings is the greatest of all evils, so it should avoided. Games of collaboration exist. Why not play them more instead? |
|
Mar-27-24 | | Messiah: <GonzaloCalvoPerez> Thank you for the information. |
|
Jul-30-24 | | FM David H. Levin: The bio says, "played for Spain in the Olympiads of 1966, 1968, 1972 and 1974." But according to the <CG> database, Calvo also played in the Olympiads of 1970 and 1978. |
|
Jul-30-24
 | | perfidious: <FM DHL>, according to Olimpbase, Calvo played in five Olympiads: 1966-70, 1974 and 1978, and I shall edit the bio to that effect. |
|
 |
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
|
|
|