| Game |
| Result | Moves |
Year |
Event/Locale | Opening |
| 1. F Lida Garcia vs J Critelli |
| ½-½ | 26 |
2005 |
American Continental | A00 Uncommon Opening |
| 2. J Critelli vs L Lucena |
| 0-1 | 32 |
2005 |
American Continental | B00 Uncommon King's Pawn Opening |
| 3. C Goldwaser vs J Critelli |
| 1-0 | 51 |
2005 |
American Continental | E12 Queen's Indian |
| 4. J Critelli vs P A Ruiz Aguilar |
| 0-1 | 38 |
2005 |
American Continental | B41 Sicilian, Kan |
| 5. F Parrilli vs J Critelli |
| 1-0 | 26 |
2005 |
American Continental | B96 Sicilian, Najdorf |
| 6. J Critelli vs L Bruzon |
 | 0-1 | 51 |
2005 |
American Continental Championship | B41 Sicilian, Kan |
| 7. J Critelli vs G Echeguren |
| 1-0 | 84 |
2005 |
American Continental | C91 Ruy Lopez, Closed |
| 8. E Toniutti vs J Critelli |
| 0-1 | 36 |
2005 |
American Continental | E20 Nimzo-Indian |
| 9. J Critelli vs J Molina |
| 1-0 | 45 |
2005 |
American Continental | B12 Caro-Kann Defense |
| 10. B Finegold vs J Critelli |
| 1-0 | 38 |
2006 |
34th World Open | E30 Nimzo-Indian, Leningrad |
| 11. J Critelli vs A Castaneda |
| 1-0 | 22 |
2006 |
128th NY St Championship | B93 Sicilian, Najdorf, 6.f4 |
| 12. J Sarkar vs J Critelli |
| 0-1 | 39 |
2006 |
34th World Open | E32 Nimzo-Indian, Classical |
| 13. J Critelli vs M Panchanathan |
| 1-0 | 51 |
2006 |
34th World Open | C41 Philidor Defense |
| 14. J Critelli vs S Beaudoin |
| 1-0 | 42 |
2006 |
34th World Open | B06 Robatsch |
| 15. L Milman vs J Critelli |
| ½-½ | 33 |
2006 |
34th World Open | B92 Sicilian, Najdorf, Opocensky Variation |
| 16. A Simutowe vs J Critelli |
 | 0-1 | 29 |
2006 |
34th World Open | D37 Queen's Gambit Declined |
| 17. J Critelli vs T Taylor |
| 1-0 | 42 |
2006 |
34th World Open | B00 Uncommon King's Pawn Opening |
| 18. J Critelli vs Fedorowicz |
| ½-½ | 24 |
2006 |
34th World Open | B23 Sicilian, Closed |
| 19. M Gagunashvili vs J Critelli |
| ½-½ | 22 |
2007 |
World Open | E32 Nimzo-Indian, Classical |
| 20. A Shomoev vs J Critelli |
| 1-0 | 55 |
2007 |
Canadian Open | E15 Queen's Indian |
| 21. S Bercys vs J Critelli |
| 1-0 | 36 |
2007 |
World Open | E15 Queen's Indian |
| 22. J Critelli vs K Baxter |
| 1-0 | 27 |
2007 |
World Open | B72 Sicilian, Dragon |
| 23. J Critelli vs T Likavsky |
| 0-1 | 39 |
2007 |
Canadian Open | B63 Sicilian, Richter-Rauzer Attack |
| 24. J Critelli vs M Martinez |
| 0-1 | 33 |
2007 |
World Open | C91 Ruy Lopez, Closed |
| 25. S Erenburg vs J Critelli |
 | 1-0 | 33 |
2007 |
World Open | B90 Sicilian, Najdorf |