chessgames.com
Members · Prefs · Collections · Openings · Endgames · Sacrifices · History · Search Kibitzing · Kibitzer's Café · Chessforums · Tournament Index · Players · Kibitzing

 
Chessgames.com User Profile
zanshin
Member since May-03-07
Free chess engines or GUIs:
http://www.chesslogik.com/
http://www.cruxis.com/chess/houdini...
http://freechess.50webs.com/engines...
http://www.superchessengine.com/
http://www.superchessengine.com/che...
http://www.playwitharena.com/
http://homepages.tesco.net/henry.ab...
http://www.rybkachess.com/index.php...

Chess programming:
http://www.frayn.net/beowulf/index....
http://u.cs.biu.ac.il/~davoudo/tuto...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolot
http://chessprogramming.wikispaces....
http://members.home.nl/matador/ches...
http://www.pdf-search-engine.com/ch... http://www.gamedev.net/reference/pr... http://www.maths.nott.ac.uk/persona...

Alpha-beta pruning
http://www.cs.ucla.edu/~rosen/161/n... http://www.ocf.berkeley.edu/~yosenl...

Human GMs analyze schematically by formulating plans or objectives, then calculating the means to achieve them. Engines analyze as many positions as possible and play the move or line that returned the best numerical evaluation. In the position below from Short vs Timman, 1991


click for larger view

Engines cannot see the strategy of mating with the King (starting with <31.Kh2>) until deep into the line or unless sliding back from the won position (Rybka 3 [+3.43] d=23 31.Ne1)(Modern Chess Analysis by Robin Smith 2004; Gambit Publications, London).

From <How to Use Computers to Improve your Chess by Christian Kongsted http://www.gambitbooks.com/books/co...) >

The horizon effect prevents engines from realizing that the Black Bishop will be pinned permanently after <32...Rxa2?>, thus salvaging a draw for Anand after <33.Rdd2> (From Anand - Fritz 6, 1999 zanshin chessforum).


click for larger view

Rybka 3: [-1.35] d=26 32...Rxa2 (1:07.46) 543881kN

<Types of positions misevaluated by engines, excerpts from Modern Chess Analysis by Robin Smith>

<1. exchange sacrifices> - Engines have difficulties evaluating material loss for positional considerations. In Kasparov vs Shirov, 1994


click for larger view

Kasparov played <17.Rxb7!> dominating the light squares, especially d5. (See John Nunn's comments quoted on the gamepage)

<2. box canyons> - ie forced lines. The term is taken from canyons in the American southwest where floods have carved out a single path forward. Engine evals may be quite different at the entrance and exit of a box canyon. In Nunn vs Van der Wiel, 1982, Nunn played <29.e5?!> entering a box canyon until move 40 that he felt was won (and too many plies away for engines to analyze). Engines prefer <29.Rc1> or <29.Rxg8>.

<3. Prisons> - trap a piece, requiring a sacrifice to escape. From Timman vs P Nikolic, 1987, engines will want to play <24.Be2?> likely leading to a draw (Rybka 3 [+0.68] d=23 24.Be2).


click for larger view

Timman played <24. Ra6! Nxa6 25. bxa6 Rd7 26. Kf1 Ra7 27.Bb7>


click for larger view

imprisoning the Rook and winning the game.

<4. King drift> refers to gradual movement of pawns and pieces towards the King. Engines often do not sense the danger before it is too late. In Smirin vs Shredder, 2002, Shredder allows King drift by weak moves in the opening.

<5. material imbalances> Positions with significant material imbalances are difficult for engines to evaluate (eg where one side has sacrificed material for a positional bind). In the position below from Junior 8 - Hiarcs 8 2003, different engines evaluated the position as +2.5 to slight advantage to Black.


click for larger view

White probably has the advantage and eventually won. Positions like this are good candidates for engine matches.

<6. quiet positions> When short term tactical gain is clear, engines are very purposeful. However, they can struggle in positions where there are no clear short term objectives. In R Knaak vs Geller, 1982, White needs to re-position his Bishop to b3, Rook b1 to d1, Knight to f4 all with pressure on d5. All engines tested preferred <22.h6?> (Rybka 3 [+0.69] d=19 22.h6)


click for larger view

<7. fortresses> - are formations that prevent forces from breaking in. This technique is usually found in the endgame to hold a draw under material disadvantage. Black has played <45...Qb6?!> in A Petrosian vs L Hazai, 1970


click for larger view

Engines cannot resist taking the Queen with high material gain. (Rybka 3 [+6.76] d=22 46.Nxb6 (0:08.56) 41463kN) However, the resulting fortress is a draw. This game was featured as a GOTD (April 19, 2009). A possible win for White is given in the CG game page. See also: zanshin chessforum

<8. passed pawns> - Engines love passed pawns, especially advanced ones. In Abreu - Perez (1999), the following position is evaluated at between +2 to +2.5 by several engines (Rybka 3 [+1.41] d=17 1.Re1). However, the position is drawn because the pawns cannot Queen.


click for larger view

<9. perpetual check> Whereas draws by repetition can be detected easily, perpetual checks are difficult for engines because one side can salvage a draw despite severe material disadvantage. At move 55 in Korchnoi vs G Rechlis, 1988, the game was drawn in the position below:


click for larger view

Despite the large advantage given to White by engines (Rybka 3 [+7.25] d=19 55...Kh2), the game is a draw by perpetual check.

Another example based on J. H. Donner (2006) "The King" (white to move):


click for larger view

Rybka finds the right move (5.Nh6!), but the evaluation is incorrect (-4.35 d=22 5.Nh6). The game is a draw by perpetual check along the g-file. (http://www.chessbase.com/newsdetail...)

<10. quirks in engine design> Based on a puzzle from http://susanpolgar.blogspot.com/ (8 July 2009). In the position below, White wins by under-promoting the pawn to Bishop. Fritz and Fruit (but not Crafty) both find the solution. Rybka 3 does not because under-promotion to Bishop is not included in Rybka analysis (http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybka...)


click for larger view

Fritz 10: 2.h8B (5.55) Depth: 23/41 00:04:44 709mN, tb=336

Fruit: [+5.04] d=27 1.h8B Qb8 2.Be5 Qc7 3.Nd6 Kg5 4.Ne4 Kh4 5.Bg3 Qxg3 6.Nxg3 Kg5 7.Nf1 Kf4 8.Kg2 h4 9.Nh2 Ke4 10.Nf3 Kf5 11.Nxh4 Kf4 12.Nf3 Ke4 13.h4 Kf5 14.Kg3 Kf6 15.Kf4 Kg7 16.Kxe3 Kg6 17.Ke4 Kh5 (0:00.31) 56559kN

Crafty: [+7.58] d=21 1.h8Q Qxh8 2.Nxh8 Kg5 3.Nf7 Kf6 4.Nd6 Ke5 5.Nc8 Kd5 6.Ne7 Kc4 7.Nf5 Kxb5 (0:00.49) 132436kN

Rybka 3: [+0.00] d=27 1.h8Q Qb8 2.Qe5 Qd6 3.Nxd6 (0:02.13) 27379kN

(see also: zanshin chessforum)

Another well documented bug in Rybka 3 is the absence of 'wrong-colored bishop' knowledge that was removed from Rybka 2 (but is supposed to be returned in Rybka 4; see http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybka...):

In the position below, Rybka 3 cannot find the tablebase draw 1... Bh3! 2.gxh3 Kh6 3.h4 Kg7, whereas Fruit finds it immediately.


click for larger view

(Rybka 3: [+5.12] d=27 3...Kh4 4.Ke2 (0:04.06) 69612kN); Fruit 2.3 [+0.00] d=12 3...Bh3 4.Kf2 Bxg2 5.Bxg2 Kg6 6.Ke3 Kg7 (0:00.00) 175kN)

Update: Rybka 4 finds it immediately: [+0.00] d=12 1...Bh3 2.Kf2 Bxg2 3.h4 Kf6 4.Bxg2 Kg7 5.Ke3 Kg6 6.Kf3 Kg7 7.Kg3 Kh8 (0:00:01) 36kN

Rybka 3 also suffers from the "Blind Bishop" bug, ie a pawn is about to Queen, but the opposing King can cover the Queening square and the Bishop cannot. The position below is drawn (either side to move), but Rybka 3 gives a high numerical evaluation:


click for larger view

Tablebase draw; Firebird 1.2 ([+0.05] d=34 1.Bf8 Kb8 2.Bg7 Ka8 3.Kc7 Ka7 4.Bh8 Kxa6 5.Kc6 ...); Rybka 3 ( [+6.08] d=19 1.Ka5 (0:13.57) 355388kN)

Update: Rybka 4 evaluates correctly even at low ply: [+0.00] d=30 34.Bc5 Kb8 (0:00:00) 1kN

<11. zugzwang positions> Engines are poor at handling positions where an advantage is conveyed by <not> moving (because of "null move heuristic"). In the position below, engines cannot find the winning line (<1.Qc8!> Kg8 2.Bc7 Qxc8 3.gxf7+ Kh8 4.Be5 Qc5 5.Bb2 Nc7 6.Ba1 a4 7.Bb2 a3 8.Ba1 a2 9.Bb2 a1Q 10.Bxa1 Qe5+ 11.Bxe5 Nd5+ 12.Kg5+ Nf6 13.Bxf6#):


click for larger view

[+0.17] d=23 1.Qc5 Kg8 2.gxh7 Kh8 3.Be7 Qb8 4.Qg5 Qb2 5.Kxf7 Qb3 6.Kf8 Qb8 7.Bd8 Qb4 8.Kf7 Qb7 9.Kf6 Qc6 10.Ke7 Qb7 11.Kd6 Qb4 12.Ke5 (0:12.03) 132204kN (Rybka 3)

(See http://rybkaforum.net/cgi-bin/rybka...)

>> Click here to see zanshin's game collections.

   zanshin has kibitzed 10152 times to chessgames   [less...]
   Aug-06-10 Iskubadayb chessforum (replies)
 
zanshin: Timeout muna ako <iskuba> - paki-check yung email mo.
 
   Aug-06-10 Kramnik vs Anand, 2008 (replies)
 
zanshin: <dzechiel: Wow. Not even close. I never considered the key move. I'm still stunned.> My analysis is similar to <dzechiel>. I guess I am improving ;-)
 
   Aug-05-10 M Sebag vs Zhu Chen, 2010 (replies)
 
zanshin: <BobCrisp> In your line, Rybka 4 goes with <50...Kf5> and neither side makes progress. The evals flat line at -2.31 meaning Black has an advantage. However, the fact that the evals don't increase for Black indicate material advantage that cannot be converted into a win. ...
 
   Aug-05-10 hms123 chessforum (replies)
 
zanshin: Poor <benjinathan> - not even allowed to protest in peace. If you were a mean SOB, people would leave you alone. Unfortunately, you are well-liked.
 
   Aug-05-10 Annie K. chessforum (replies)
 
zanshin: <you don't agree with Deffi?> I didn't get <OD>'s comment, but now I do ;-) I agree with her too.
 
   Aug-05-10 chancho chessforum (replies)
 
...
 
   Aug-05-10 Geller vs Bronstein, 1956
 
zanshin: Here's the game score from chess365.com. There are some differences in the moves. [Event "Candidates Tournament"] [Date "1956.??.??"] [White "Geller, Efim P"] [Black "Bronstein, David I"] [Result "1/2-1/2"] [WhiteElo "0"] [BlackElo "0"] 1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 g6 3. Nc3 ...
 
   Aug-04-10 D Grant vs J Tambini, 2010
 
zanshin: Were these guys in a hurry to go somewhere? ;-) There is still a lot of play in the position. Move 27 for White: [DIAGRAM] [+1.05] d=21 27.Nf5 f6 28.Rac1 Rxc1 29.Rxc1 Nf8 30.Qf1 Qb8 31.Rc3 Ng6 32.Qc1 Kf7 33.Be3 Rh8 34.Kh2 Rd8 35.Kg2 Re8 36.Rc2 Qb7 37.Nxe7 (0:04:34) 42256kN (Rybka ...
 
   Aug-04-10 T Reich vs A Kabatianski, 2008 (replies)
 
zanshin: <Check It Out: I initially looked at 55. Bxg6 hxg6 56. h6 but that just fails to 56...Kg8> <CIO> That's what I looked at too. <RandomVisitor: looks like 55.hxg6+ is also a solution.> In my Rybka 4 run, even when 55.hxg6+ was played first, Ba6 was still the key ...
 
   Aug-04-10 Battle of the Brains 3, 2009 (replies)
 
zanshin: <ronpaz1: after 21. Bd3 Bg4 22. Qg2 Bf5 23. Qc2 Bxd3 24. Qxd3 Bb4 does the engines give reasonable alternative to 25.e4?> <ronpaz1> After <21. Bd3 Bg4 22. Qg2 Bf5 23. Qc2 Bxd3 24. Qxd3 Bb4> Rybka 4 set to exclude <25.e4>: [DIAGRAM] [-0.43] d=20 25.Kd1 Rc8 ...
 
   Aug-03-10 The Chess Express chessforum (replies)
   Aug-03-10 H G Lachmann vs A Speer, 1961 (replies)
   Aug-03-10 Maczuski vs Kolisch, 1864 (replies)
   Aug-01-10 Jon Ludvig Hammer (replies)
   Jul-31-10 Wesley So (replies)
   Jul-30-10 A Slavin vs Adams, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-30-10 Spassky vs Korchnoi, 1955 (replies)
   Jul-30-10 A Stefanova vs Kosteniuk, 2004
   Jul-30-10 Zsuzsa Polgar (replies)
   Jul-29-10 Dzindzichashvili vs E Torre, 1977
   Jul-29-10 R Eames vs Adams, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-29-10 British Championship (2010) (replies)
   Jul-29-10 Kibitzer's Café (replies)
   Jul-29-10 kutztown46 chessforum (replies)
   Jul-28-10 A Giri vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-27-10 Fabiano Caruana (replies)
   Jul-26-10 Rybka (Computer) (replies)
   Jul-26-10 W So vs Ngoc Truongson Nguyen, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-26-10 E Iturrizaga vs V Kulakov, 2008 (replies)
   Jul-26-10 Biel Chess Festival (2010) (replies)
   Jul-25-10 OhioChessFan chessforum (replies)
   Jul-25-10 Loewenthal vs Szen, 1842 (replies)
   Jul-25-10 A Volokitin vs Rublevsky, 2004 (replies)
   Jul-25-10 Check It Out chessforum (replies)
   Jul-25-10 Open Defence chessforum (replies)
   Jul-24-10 D Howell vs M Vachier-Lagrave, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-24-10 S Estremera Panos vs L Cisneros, 1991 (replies)
   Jul-24-10 Caruana vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-23-10 Gruenfeld vs Marshall, 1925
   Jul-23-10 A Riazantsev vs Ni Hua, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-22-10 Tomashevsky vs Negi, 2010
   Jul-22-10 W So vs Negi, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-22-10 D Andreikin vs D Howell, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-22-10 Negi vs Caruana, 2010
   Jul-22-10 zanshin chessforum (replies)
   Jul-22-10 Spassky vs Fischer, 1972 (replies)
   Jul-21-10 Alekhine vs Flohr, 1936 (replies)
   Jul-21-10 M Rodshtein vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-21-10 D Howell vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-21-10 J Berkvens vs V Mikhalevski, 2000 (replies)
   Jul-20-10 A Giri vs D Andreikin, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-20-10 W So vs M Vachier-Lagrave, 2010
   Jul-19-10 USA Women Championship (2010) (replies)
   Jul-19-10 10th International Computer Tournament (2010) (replies)
   Jul-18-10 Le Quang Liem vs Ponomariov, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-18-10 S Hosea vs R Stanculescu, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-18-10 V Sokolov vs Rusnikov, 1966 (replies)
   Jul-17-10 Psakhis vs V Malaniuk, 1987 (replies)
   Jul-17-10 wordfunph chessforum (replies)
   Jul-17-10 WannaBe chessforum (replies)
   Jul-16-10 Timman vs J M Bellon Lopez, 1978
   Jul-16-10 M Pavlovic vs Razuvaev, 1991 (replies)
   Jul-16-10 D Byrne vs Fischer, 1956 (replies)
   Jul-16-10 Patriot chessforum (replies)
   Jul-16-10 O de la Riva Aguado vs Ermenkov, 2008 (replies)
   Jul-16-10 Kasparov vs Karpov, 2002 (replies)
   Jul-16-10 D Moody vs D Helf, 1976 (replies)
   Jul-15-10 Dortmund (2010) (replies)
   Jul-14-10 Greco vs NN, 1590 (replies)
   Jul-14-10 Carlsen vs Bareev, 2005
   Jul-14-10 P Deshmukh vs B Thipsay, 2008 (replies)
   Jul-13-10 B H Wood vs R Broadbent, 1946
   Jul-12-10 Stripunsky vs Van Wely, 2010
   Jul-12-10 NN vs Blackburne, 1871 (replies)
   Jul-11-10 K Spraggett vs D Boileau, 1973 (replies)
   Jul-11-10 Salov vs Karpov, 1994 (replies)
   Jul-10-10 Dzindzichashvili vs Ljubojevic, 1985 (replies)
   Jul-09-10 Phony Benoni chessforum (replies)
   Jul-07-10 Ehlvest vs M Paragua, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-06-10 Lenderman vs M Paragua, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-06-10 Julio Bolbochan vs A Rocha, 1966 (replies)
   Jul-06-10 rinus chessforum (replies)
   Jul-06-10 Almond vs The Baron, 2010
   Jul-06-10 Spark vs Almond, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-06-10 Kasparov vs The World, 1999 (replies)
   Jul-05-10 I Nepomniachtchi vs Ivanchuk, 2010 (replies)
   Jul-05-10 G Degrave vs D Dupuis, 2003 (replies)
   Jul-04-10 Judit Polgar vs Kasparov, 1996 (replies)
   Jul-04-10 Leko vs Ivanchuk, 2008 (replies)
   Jul-03-10 Gligoric vs Fischer, 1992 (replies)
   Jul-03-10 Anand vs Kasimdzhanov, 2005 (replies)
   Jul-02-10 Mecking vs Kaplan, 1972
   Jul-02-10 crafty chessforum (replies)
   Jul-01-10 K Rogoff vs Timman, 1971 (replies)
   Jul-01-10 Winter chessforum (replies)
   Jul-01-10 RandomVisitor chessforum (replies)
   Jun-22-10 M Oren vs I Dyner, 1952 (replies)
   Jun-22-10 N Yaremko vs D Recuero Guerra, 2006 (replies)
   Jun-22-10 ChessBookForum chessforum (replies)
   Jun-21-10 pulsar chessforum (replies)
   Jun-19-10 Short vs E Alekseev, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-19-10 E Torre vs Vaganian, 1984
   Jun-18-10 Short vs Ivanchuk, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-16-10 A Giri vs B Bok, 2010
   Jun-16-10 Joker vs Deep Sjeng, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-16-10 Sutovsky vs Jobava, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-16-10 J B Bednarski vs Podgaets, 1972 (replies)
   Jun-14-10 Spark vs Joker, 2010
   Jun-14-10 The King vs Rybka, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-14-10 Deep Junior vs Redqueen, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-14-10 Redqueen vs Almond, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-14-10 Rybka vs Deep Sjeng, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-14-10 E Ghaem Maghami vs Karpov, 2009 (replies)
   Jun-13-10 B Pantebre Martinez vs E Paoli, 1976 (replies)
   Jun-12-10 Redqueen (Computer)
   Jun-12-10 Rybka vs Pandix, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-11-10 J Dueball vs E Gereben, 1972 (replies)
   Jun-10-10 N Lortkipanidze vs M Ragger, 2008 (replies)
   Jun-10-10 T Turgut vs H Tiemann, 2009 (replies)
   Jun-09-10 A Riazantsev vs I Sokolov, 2010 (replies)
   Jun-08-10 Shabalov vs Saidy, 2003 (replies)
   Jun-07-10 Chessgames Bookie chessforum (replies)
   Jun-07-10 I Nepomniachtchi vs Zhou Jianchao, 2009 (replies)
   Jun-06-10 Kosteniuk vs Y Dembo, 2005 (replies)
   Jun-05-10 NakoSonorense chessforum (replies)
   Jun-01-10 Eugenio Torre (replies)
   May-31-10 Rogelio Antonio Jr (replies)
   May-29-10 Kasparov vs N McDonald, 1986 (replies)
   May-28-10 A E Post vs Nimzowitsch, 1905 (replies)
   May-27-10 Jayson Gonzales (replies)
   May-25-10 three martlets chessforum (replies)
   May-25-10 W So vs Thanh Son Nguyen, 2010 (replies)
   May-24-10 J A Congdon vs E Delmar, 1880 (replies)
   May-20-10 Tal vs K Grigorian, 1982 (replies)
   May-19-10 Velimirovic vs Csom, 1974 (replies)
   May-18-10 A Gibaud vs F Lazard, 1924 (replies)
   May-17-10 W Hook vs E Bernal, 1985 (replies)
   May-12-10 Topalov vs Anand, 2010 (replies)
   May-12-10 A Bannik vs Y Nikolaevsky, 1958 (replies)
   May-11-10 Viswanathan Anand (replies)
   May-11-10 Anand - Topalov World Chess Championship (2010) (replies)
   May-11-10 Robatsch vs Bisguier, 1961 (replies)
   May-10-10 Andre Lilienthal (replies)
   May-10-10 Morphy vs Schrufer, 1859 (replies)
   May-07-10 V L Wahltuch vs Capablanca, 1922 (replies)
   May-06-10 benjinathan chessforum (replies)
   May-06-10 Anand vs Topalov, 2010 (replies)
   May-04-10 Nf3em chessforum (replies)
   May-04-10 Gavrikov vs Gelfand, 1995 (replies)
   May-04-10 Topalov vs Anand, 2010 (replies)
   May-04-10 bang chessforum (replies)
   Apr-29-10 Yury Shulman (replies)
   Apr-28-10 Anand vs Topalov, 2010 (replies)
   Apr-27-10 Fischer vs Petrosian, 1971 (replies)
   Apr-27-10 Shaobin vs Koneru, 2005 (replies)
   Apr-26-10 R C Balinas vs Gligoric, 1975 (replies)
   Apr-26-10 V Vepkhvishvili vs Z Rukhadze, 1965 (replies)
   Apr-23-10 S Bernstein vs Dake, 1936 (replies)
   Apr-22-10 Bologan vs Tomashevsky, 2010 (replies)
   Apr-19-10 H Hallmann vs W Schneider, 1931 (replies)
   Apr-18-10 P Vianna vs D Hua, 2010 (replies)
   Apr-14-10 J Kleiman vs M Paragua, 2010 (replies)
   Apr-09-10 ahmadov chessforum (replies)
   Mar-27-10 Vasily Smyslov (replies)
   Mar-27-10 Elena Tairova (replies)
   Mar-26-10 Honza Cervenka chessforum (replies)
   Mar-24-10 SugarDom chessforum (replies)
   Mar-24-10 YouRang chessforum (replies)
   Mar-21-10 L Baze vs T Palmer, 2004 (replies)
   Mar-21-10 epistle chessforum (replies)
   Mar-17-10 Napoleon Bonaparte vs The Turk, 1809 (replies)
   Mar-16-10 Robin01 chessforum (replies)
   Mar-13-10 ragdeam chessforum (replies)
   Mar-12-10 Ivanchuk vs Shirov, 1996 (replies)
   Mar-09-10 Fischer vs R Cardoso, 1957 (replies)
   Mar-08-10 dzechiel chessforum (replies)
   Mar-08-10 E Torre vs R Meulders, 1987 (replies)
   Mar-07-10 N Radev vs Pribyl, 1971 (replies)
   Mar-05-10 obientag chessforum (replies)
   Mar-05-10 Brzozka vs Bronstein, 1963 (replies)
   Mar-04-10 L Gutman vs M Knezevic, 1984 (replies)
   Mar-04-10 T O'Neil vs H Devoille, 2010
   Feb-27-10 Judit Polgar vs Kaidanov, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-26-10 Kaidanov vs Judit Polgar, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-26-10 Judit Polgar vs Kaidanov, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-24-10 Kaidanov vs Judit Polgar, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-24-10 Topalov vs Gelfand, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-24-10 Grischuk vs Topalov, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-23-10 E Bernal vs DeFirmian, 1984
   Feb-20-10 mysql chessforum (replies)
   Feb-19-10 chessgames.com chessforum (replies)
   Feb-19-10 Topalov vs Vallejo-Pons, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-19-10 keypusher chessforum (replies)
   Feb-18-10 Topalov vs Grischuk, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-18-10 S Zhigalko vs D Obolenskikh, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-17-10 Larsen vs Miles, 1979 (replies)
   Feb-16-10 Albertan chessforum (replies)
   Feb-16-10 W So vs Zhou Jianchao, 2010
   Feb-15-10 A Iljushin vs D Laylo, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-15-10 gropek chessforum (replies)
   Feb-15-10 Eduardo Bernal (replies)
   Feb-15-10 A Timofeev vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-14-10 W So vs A Pashikian, 2010
   Feb-13-10 H Melkumyan vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-12-10 S Hosea vs P A Fontaine, 2009 (replies)
   Feb-11-10 Topalov vs Kasparov, 1996 (replies)
   Feb-11-10 Ngoc Truongson Nguyen vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-10-10 E Safarli vs D Laylo, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-10-10 R Vazquez Igarza vs Shabalov, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-10-10 T Kosintseva vs S Volkov, 2010
   Feb-10-10 W So vs D Bocharov, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-08-10 D Andreikin vs A Bezgodov, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-07-10 Russian Grandmasters chessforum (replies)
   Feb-05-10 F Amonatov vs E Gorovykh, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-05-10 Capablanca vs D Marotti, 1922 (replies)
   Feb-04-10 Sutovsky vs L Pantsulaia, 2008 (replies)
   Feb-03-10 timhortons chessforum (replies)
   Feb-03-10 Anish Giri (replies)
   Feb-02-10 W So vs A Muzychuk, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-01-10 Short vs J Smeets, 2010 (replies)
   Feb-01-10 S Plukkel vs Li Chao, 2010
   Jan-31-10 Frits Bakkes
   Jan-31-10 S Plukkel vs G Thomassen, 2001
   Jan-29-10 whatthefat chessforum (replies)
   Jan-29-10 W So vs A Giri, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-29-10 T Nyback vs W So, 2010
   Jan-28-10 M Muzychuk vs S Plukkel, 2010
   Jan-27-10 Corus (B Group) (2010) (replies)
   Jan-27-10 A Muzychuk vs A Giri, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-26-10 Li Chao vs Robson, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-26-10 W So vs Sutovsky, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-26-10 Kramnik vs Ivanchuk, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-25-10 alexrawlings chessforum (replies)
   Jan-25-10 D Vocaturo vs Robson, 2010
   Jan-25-10 Ni Hua vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-24-10 W So vs D Reinderman, 2010
   Jan-23-10 D Howell vs T Nyback, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-23-10 Nakamura vs Shirov, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-23-10 Short vs Kramnik, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-23-10 Shirov vs Carlsen, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-22-10 Ni Hua vs A Muzychuk, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-22-10 Shirov vs J Smeets, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-22-10 Nisipeanu vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-22-10 T Nyback vs A Giri, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-21-10 M Muzychuk vs S Swaminathan, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-21-10 Shirov vs Short, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-21-10 Nakamura vs Carlsen, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-21-10 Van Wely vs Shirov, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-20-10 D Monokroussos vs L Barcarola, 1999 (replies)
   Jan-19-10 Negi vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-19-10 A Greenfeld vs J Redmond, 2008 (replies)
   Jan-19-10 A Muzychuk vs Harikrishna, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-19-10 W So vs Akobian, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-18-10 A Giri vs D Reinderman, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-18-10 Tiviakov vs Shirov, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-18-10 H H Cole vs A W W Tulip, 1946 (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Portisch vs DeFirmian, 1989 (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Negi vs A Muzychuk, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Polugaevsky vs E Torre, 1981 (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Nisipeanu vs A Giri, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Carlsen vs J Smeets, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Domdaniel chessforum (replies)
   Jan-17-10 Sutovsky vs D Reinderman, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-16-10 Naiditsch vs W So, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-16-10 A Muzychuk vs Akobian, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-14-10 Tolush vs Matulovic, 1965
   Jan-14-10 K Cedikova vs A Stojanovic, 2009 (replies)
   Jan-14-10 A Shmit vs Tal, 1971 (replies)
   Jan-14-10 iron maiden chessforum (replies)
   Jan-13-10 Najdorf vs E Torre, 1976 (replies)
   Jan-13-10 HIARCS vs Homer, 2007 (replies)
   Jan-12-10 Aronian vs Nakamura, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-12-10 E Torre vs M Firdaus, 2000
   Jan-12-10 E Torre vs Portisch, 1974 (replies)
   Jan-12-10 World Team Championship (2010) (replies)
   Jan-12-10 Domenico Lorenzo Ponziani (replies)
   Jan-12-10 D Good vs Pelletier, 2009
   Jan-12-10 Motylev vs B Ivanovic, 2000 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 S Williams vs A D Green, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 G Milos vs Mamedyarov, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 Kramnik vs Leko, 1997 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 Tal vs E Torre, 1973 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 J Klovans vs Tal, 1952
   Jan-11-10 The Turk vs NN, 1770 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 Spielmann vs R Wahle, 1926 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 Spassky vs Fischer, 1972 (replies)
   Jan-11-10 Huzman vs Khmelnitsky, 1989 (replies)
   Jan-10-10 A Fier vs H Banikas, 2010
   Jan-10-10 Benko vs Suttles, 1964 (replies)
   Jan-10-10 B Esen vs N Vitiugov, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-10-10 Fischer vs Spassky, 1972 (replies)
   Jan-09-10 Nimzowitsch vs Rubinstein, 1926 (replies)
   Jan-08-10 Dolmatov vs Gulko, 1985 (replies)
   Jan-08-10 Wittek vs Bird, 1882
   Jan-08-10 notyetagm chessforum (replies)
   Jan-08-10 achieve chessforum (replies)
   Jan-07-10 C Lutz vs J Balcerak, 2000 (replies)
   Jan-07-10 C Philippe vs I Snape, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-07-10 jessicafischerqueen chessforum (replies)
   Jan-07-10 amadeus chessforum (replies)
   Jan-06-10 Nakamura vs Sasikiran, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-06-10 Spike vs Rybka, 2005
   Jan-06-10 E Tate vs S Sulskis, 2001 (replies)
   Jan-06-10 malthrope chessforum (replies)
   Jan-05-10 Homer vs Buzz, 2007 (replies)
   Jan-05-10 Zappa vs Rybka, 2008
   Jan-05-10 tpstar chessforum (replies)
   Jan-05-10 D Vocaturo vs S Brunello, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-05-10 Falkbeer vs NN, 1847 (replies)
   Jan-04-10 Saemisch vs Nimzowitsch, 1923 (replies)
   Jan-04-10 SirChrislov chessforum (replies)
   Jan-04-10 Red October chessforum (replies)
   Jan-04-10 Christian G Jaime (replies)
   Jan-04-10 Najdorf vs Fischer, 1959 (replies)
   Jan-04-10 Chigorin vs Winawer, 1897
   Jan-04-10 Greco vs NN, 1620 (replies)
   Jan-03-10 ashalpha chessforum (replies)
   Jan-03-10 Chigorin vs Steinitz, 1892 (replies)
   Jan-03-10 G Marco vs Gunsberg, 1901 (replies)
   Jan-03-10 Bologan vs Z Almasi, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-03-10 S Brunello vs Kamsky, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-03-10 Rozentalis vs R Wojtaszek, 2010 (replies)
   Jan-03-10 M Admiraal vs P Ypma, 2009
   Jan-02-10 Shredder vs Rybka, 2006
   Jan-02-10 Rybka vs Ehlvest, 2007
   Jan-02-10 Tal vs Myagmarsuren, 1974 (replies)
   Jan-02-10 Spassky vs Sajtar, 1953
   Jan-02-10 Granda Zuniga vs J Soto, 2002 (replies)
   Jan-02-10 R Hopton vs F Eastwood, 1860 (replies)
   Jan-02-10 Mecking vs Najdorf, 1969 (replies)
   Jan-02-10 Dolmatov vs Browne, 1990 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 Alan Benson (replies)
   Jan-01-10 Smyslov vs Keres, 1953 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 Flohr vs Fine, 1935 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 G Barcza vs Stoltz, 1942 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 R van Kampen vs Timman, 2009 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 Spassky vs M Bieler, 2009 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 V Gagarin vs P Jaracz, 2001
   Jan-01-10 C Berczes vs M Lokander, 2009 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 Deep Sjeng vs micro-Max, 2007 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 B Kreiman vs Kaidanov, 1994 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 Fischer vs A Benson, 1964 (replies)
   Jan-01-10 brankat chessforum (replies)
   Dec-31-09 A Chernin vs Van der Wiel, 1997 (replies)
   Dec-31-09 V Georgiev vs M Sebag, 2008 (replies)
   Dec-31-09 Bologan vs Caruana, 2009 (replies)
   Dec-31-09 WinKing chessforum (replies)
   Dec-31-09 D Lawson vs Deep Thought, 1988 (replies)
   Dec-31-09 K Urban vs S Gross, 1989 (replies)
   Dec-31-09 Efimenko vs J Arizmendi Martinez, 2006 (replies)
   Dec-31-09 Mohishunder vs Cochrane, 1860 (replies)
   Dec-30-09 Vasik G Rajlich (replies)
   Dec-29-09 G Bordonada vs F J Sanz Alonso, 1974 (replies)
   Dec-29-09 G Bordonada vs J Adamski, 1978 (replies)
   Dec-29-09 C E A Dupre vs Carlos Torre, 1927 (replies)
   Dec-28-09 E Torre vs N Fairclough, 1990 (replies)
   Dec-28-09 Morphy vs Maurian, 1855 (replies)
   Dec-28-09 Morphy vs T Knight, 1856 (replies)
   Dec-28-09 M Manakova vs V Gunina, 2009 (replies)
   Dec-28-09 S Sjugirov vs A Riazantsev, 2009
   Dec-28-09 Carlsen vs Ivanchuk, 2009
   Dec-28-09 Robatsch vs Jansa, 1974 (replies)
   Dec-24-09 Fusilli chessforum (replies)
   Dec-24-09 Steinitz / Hirschfeld / Mason vs Zukertort / Bird / Hoffer, 1880 (replies)
   Dec-24-09 Fine vs Flohr, 1938 (replies)
   Dec-23-09 CRISMELDRE chessforum (replies)
   Dec-23-09 ILikeFruits chessforum (replies)
   Dec-23-09 Timman vs Lahno, 2009 (replies)
   Dec-23-09 Carlsen vs McShane, 2009 (replies)
   Dec-23-09 Christiansen vs L C Gilden, 1976 (replies)
   Dec-23-09 Anthony Makinano
   Dec-23-09 E Senador vs A Makinano, 2007 (replies)
   Dec-23-09 Miles vs M Nedobora, 1994 (replies)
   Dec-23-09 T Sachdev vs I Berzina, 2008
   Dec-22-09 J Watkins vs H Ramezani, 1994 (replies)
   Dec-22-09 Short vs Timman, 1991 (replies)
   Dec-22-09 dunkenchess chessforum (replies)
   Dec-22-09 Russian Championship Superfinal (2009) (replies)
   Dec-22-09 Raymond Keene (replies)
   Dec-22-09 A P Law vs E Torre, 1977 (replies)
   Dec-22-09 E Torre vs C Hon, 1978 (replies)
   Dec-22-09 Napoli Costa vs Corso, 1980
   Dec-22-09 N Dobrev vs Nijboer, 2009
   Dec-22-09 J Bethmann vs P Leisebein, 1990 (replies)
   Dec-22-09 Capablanca vs G A Thomas, 1919 (replies)
   Dec-22-09 Adianto vs R Antonio, 1993 (replies)
   Dec-21-09 chesstoplay chessforum (replies)
   Dec-21-09 Santa Claus (replies)
   Dec-21-09 P Delekta vs Geller, 1992 (replies)
   Dec-21-09 E Torre vs Fedorowicz, 1991
   Dec-21-09 Anderssen vs Kieseritzky, 1851 (replies)
   Dec-21-09 Gipslis vs Ulibin, 1988 (replies)
   Dec-20-09 Eljanov vs Mamedyarov, 2008 (replies)
   Dec-20-09 Spassky vs Tal, 1958 (replies)
   Dec-20-09 dotsamoht chessforum (replies)
   Dec-20-09 Kasparov vs Karpov, 1985 (replies)
   Dec-20-09 K Poschauko vs J H Donner, 1952
   Dec-19-09 Kramnik vs Deep Fritz, 2002 (replies)
   Dec-19-09 F Hedke vs M Otte, 2007
   Dec-19-09 Z Rahman vs T Toh, 1994
(replies) indicates a reply to the comment.

You are not logged in to chessgames.com.
If you need an account, register now;
it's quick, anonymous, and free!
If you already have an account, click here to sign-in.

View another user profile:
  


home | about | login | logout | F.A.Q. | your profile | preferences | Premium Membership | Kibitzer's Café | Biographer's Bistro | new kibitzing | chessforums | Tournament Index | Player Directory | World Chess Championships | Opening Explorer | Guess the Move | Game Collections | ChessBookie Game | Chessgames Challenge | Store | privacy notice | advertising | contact us
Copyright 2001-2014, Chessgames Services LLC
Web design & database development by 20/20 Technologies