|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 3 OF 3 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
| Dec-31-07 | | MadBishop: The pun "Rage Against The Machine" is actually the name of a heavy/death metal band. |
|
| Dec-31-07 | | CapablancaFan: This is actually the 2nd time <chessgames> has used this pun. Lasker vs Capablanca, 1914 Regarding this game though, Deep Blue begins to go "wrong" IMO with 11...Nh5? A totally time wasting move that does nothing but result in the program spending more tempos moving it around everytime it's attacked. A better continuation was 11...Rc8! to shore up some strength on the semi-open c-file. Had Blue made this simple change, it would have changed the whole course of this game. The proof? Please look at the final position. |
|
| Dec-31-07 | | MostlyAverageJoe: This game is a testimony of how far the software & hardware have progressed since 1996. A mere 3 minutes/move analysis (averaging less time per move than would be available in a regulation game after getting out of the book) shows many improvements for the black (and very few for white). Here's what Hiarcs 11.2MP picked with 0.10 threshold for reported improvements:
13... Rc8 (+0.12, a 0.11 improvement)
15... dxc4 (+0.28, a 0.19 improvement) -- this move would've prevented the later lockup of black's DSB. 17.cxd5 (+0.50, a 0.33 improvement) -- the only move found where Hiarcs considers white to have lost some of the advantage. 19...Nf8 (+0.39, a 0.20 improvement)
Now Kasparov grinds out small improvements that do not register with the 0.10 threshold. 33...Re8 (+1.12, a 0.52 improvement)
There are more alleged inaccuracies after that, black's game deteriorates rapidly, and, by move 42, white's advantage is about (+4.25). I think that this deterioration could be caused by bad time management and the approaching time control, but this does not explain Deep Blue playing 40...bxc6 instead of Rxc6 (a 1.22 inaccuracy), or 41...Kh6 instead of Kg8 (a 0.71 inaccuracy). |
|
| Dec-31-07 | | amadeus: <MAJ: 17.cxd5 (+0.50, a 0.33 improvement) -- the only move found where Hiarcs considers white to have lost some of the advantage.> Rybka, at 15 ply, evals Nf3 as 2 centipawns better than cxd5. |
|
Dec-31-07
 | | fm avari viraf: Gary the great, systematically outplays Deep Blue as if the Computer went into Deep Sleep. Simply a wonderful game. |
|
Dec-31-07
 | | Jimfromprovidence: Has anyone evaluated 17... Bc7 for black instead of 17...Bb4? The bishop ends up there on move 21 anyway at the cost of several tempi of development. |
|
| Dec-31-07 | | MostlyAverageJoe: <amadeus: Rybka, at 15 ply, evals Nf3 as 2 centipawns better than cxd5> Give it 3 minutes on a fast CPU with dual core and it should get deeper than 15 plies. Hiarcs got to 18 plies in 3 minutes (after spending 3 minutes apiece on preceding moves, so it had some of the hash pre-computed). In any case, improvements for white are not that important here. It would be interesting to know what improvements would Rybka find for the black, and whether they correlate with those from Hiarcs. If you'd like to run such an experiment, make sure it does its analysis in forward scan mode, not backsliding -- the backslide does not simulate the conditions occurring during the game. |
|
| Dec-31-07 | | Sularus: Goodbye 2007. |
|
| Mar-28-08 | | just a kid: Rage against the Machine.Great band. |
|
| Apr-17-08 | | crafty: 30. b6 ♗d8 31. ♗c3 ♘c6 32. ♖ce1 ♔g8 33. ♕d2 ♗f6  (eval 1.24; depth 14 ply; 250M nodes) |
|
| Nov-26-08 | | Cactus: Deep Blue had No Shelter? |
|
| Nov-26-08 | | brucejavier: great game by the great garry! |
|
| Jan-10-09 | | WhiteRook48: and the trapped rook and bishop! Even computers would resign in this position! |
|
| Feb-02-11 | | hottyboy90: WhiteRook48 the computer did resign! |
|
| Feb-02-11 | | jmactas: Holy queenside congestion batman! |
|
| Mar-11-11 | | hottyboy90: Thats a very random comment! |
|
| May-15-14 | | talwnbe4: Amazing how like a computer Garry plays, isn't it ? Deep Blue analysed at 100 million positions a second, but today's software has much better pruning and time management. Fruit prefers 11..Nb4 over 11..Nh5.
15..dxc4?! 16. Ndxc4 Bb4 17. Bxg6 fxg6 18. Bc3 Nxe5 19. Nxe5 Ba3 20. Rc2 Bb5 21. Nc4 Bxc4 22. bxc4  1.09 Fruit 2.1
550,000 pos/second
15..Ngxe5 is what Fruit prefers instead of DB's 15..Rc8. Move 19 Fruit plays 19..Nge7 after 3 minutes, same as Deep Blue.
Fruit finds 33..Bb4 best too after 3 minutes.
Fruit considers 33.. Ne5 the best after 3 min 15 sec, same as DB. depth 17 ply, but really it isn't looking ahead 17 ply.
Fruit gives 22..Nf5 23. Re2 Re8 as preferable to 22..Re8 but evaluates this position as 0.70. You can see DB's position is already not good. Yeah, the blockage of blacks QB resulting in the rook also being locked up was horrible. |
|
Jun-05-14
 | | Zhbugnoimt: 20.Bxh7+! Was a very strong shot, and Kasparov would have played it had he been playing vs a human, but against deep blue... |
|
| Jun-05-14 | | goldenbear: <patzer2: Deep Blue's terrible 30...Bb8? adds new meaning to the term "bad bishop." Maybe here it's like saying "bad doggie" after your normally well behaved pet inexplicably chews up and destroys your good sofa.> It would have to "add new meaning", I guess, because Deep Blue has the "good bishop" and Kasparov has the "bad bishop"... |
|
| Aug-11-17 | | Toribio3: Beautiful game! Kasparov is the Superman. |
|
Aug-12-17
 | | HeMateMe: what's the finishing line? white moves his king out of the way, puts a Rook on the g file and plays g5 as a battering ram? |
|
Aug-13-17
 | | beatgiant: <HeMateMe>
Here's an example with your kingside attack plan: 43...Kg8 44. g4 hxg4 45. h5 gxh5 46. Qe3 Kf8 47. Qg5. I don't see how Black stops the mate threats, even with computer moves.Besides that, Black's pieces can hardly move, and White also threatens to lift the blockade on the b-pawn (with Qe7, or if Black's rook moves, with Qxc6). |
|
Aug-31-17
 | | thegoodanarchist: <HeMateMe: what's the finishing line? white moves his king out of the way, puts a Rook on the g file and plays g5 as a battering ram?> <Aug-13-17
Premium Chessgames Member beatgiant: <HeMateMe>
Here's an example with your kingside attack plan: 43...Kg8 44. g4 hxg4 45. h5 gxh5 46. Qe3 Kf8 47. Qg5. I don't see how Black stops the mate threats, even with computer moves.> With the Black king on h6, your 43...Kg8 is not a legal move. Monty Newborn, who wrote the book on this match (and computer chess development), gives the only move for Black as 43...Kh7, followed by 44 Qe7 Qxe7 45 Bxe7 Bxe5 (or 45...Re8) 46 b7 +- |
|
| Feb-14-20 | | yurikvelo: D=37, 6 645 MN
+2,57 33. ... f6 34.Qd2 Kh7 35.Bb2 Kg8
+3,34 33. ... Kf8 34.Ne1 f6 35.Nc2 e5
+3,60 33. ... Re8 34.Ne1 Rc8 35.Nc2 Qe8
+3,69 33. ... Kh7 34.Ne1 Re8 35.Nc2 Rd8
+3,77 33. ... Qd8 34.Ne1 Re8 35.Nc2 Nfe7
+3,87 33. ... Nh6 34.Ne1 f6 35.Nc2 Nf7
+3,88 33. ... Kg8 34.Ne1 Re8 35.Nc2 Rd8
+3,88 33. ... Qe8 34.Ne1 Kf8 35.Nc2 Kg8
+3,88 33. ... Qc8 34.Ne1 Rd7 35.Nc2 Rd8
+3,88 33. ... Kh8 34.Ne1 Re8 35.Nc2 Kg7
+3,88 33. ... Kf6 34.Ne1 Re8 35.Nc2 Kg7
+3,88 33. ... Kh6 34.Ne1 Kg7 35.Nc2 Re8
+5,76 33. ... Bf4 34.gxf4 Ree8 35.Kh1 Rh8
+6,50 33. ... Bxg3 34.fxg3 f6 35.Kh2 Kh7
+6,90 33. ... Nb4 34.Qxf5 Qxa4 35.Qg5 f6
+7,14 33. ... Ne5 34.dxe5 Qxa4 35.Nd4 Nxd4 <---- Deep Blue |
|
| Apr-23-20 | | yurikvelo: https://pastebin.com/8ER0359f
multiPV of DeepBlue mistakes
single decisive mistake (from holdable game to easy win for white) was 19. ... Nge7?? |
|
 |
|
|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 3 OF 3 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
Kibitzing
Annotations by 