chessgames.com
Members · Prefs · Laboratory · Collections · Openings · Endgames · Sacrifices · History · Search Kibitzing · Kibitzer's Café · Chessforums · Tournament Index · Players · Kibitzing

Tenis Melngailis
  
Number of games in database: 7
Years covered: 1936 to 1939
Overall record: +2 -4 =1 (35.7%)*
   * Overall winning percentage = (wins+draws/2) / total games.

Most played openings
C01 French, Exchange (2 games)
A14 English (2 games)


Search Sacrifice Explorer for Tenis Melngailis
Search Google for Tenis Melngailis


TENIS MELNGAILIS
(born Dec-13-1912, died 1980, 67 years old) Latvia

[what is this?]

Tenis Melngailis was born on December 13th, 1912 in Tashkent, Uzbekistan and died on December 8th in Riga, Latvia.1 He was the son of Emilis Melngailis , who was best known as a folk music composer and Latvian folklorist.2 His father also achieved a 1st category chess rank, and competed in the 1932 Latvian Championship.3 At age 24, Tenis Melngailis earned a spot on the Latvian team at the <1936 Munich Unofficial Chess Olympiad>, scoring +4-5=1 on first reserve board.4

"From 1942 to 1945 Tenis Melngailis was the Chairman of the Latvian Chess Association." Val Zemitis, "Encyclopedia of Latvian Chess Players Vol.II 1900-2000" p.M54"

Photo of young Tenis Melngailis with his father, Emilis Melngailis https://i.imgur.com/jNyUJGP.jpg

Photo of the Latvian Olympic team (1939)- From left to right: Front- F. Apsenieks, V. Petrov, Milda Laubert and T. Melngailis. Behind - M. Feigin and L. Endzelins: https://i.imgur.com/VMQKdLH.jpg

Photo of the crosstable from the <Riga Championship 1935-1936>, showing both Tenis and his father Emilis Melngailis: https://i.imgur.com/IehGFbz.jpg

Game Collection: Tenis Melngailis Life and Games

Notes

1 Jeremy Gaige, "Chess Personalia- A Biobibliography" (McFarland, 2005), p.278

2 Latvian Wikipedia entry: Wikipedia article: Emilis Melngailis

3 "Val Zemitis, 'Encyclopedia of Latvian Chess Players Vol.II 1900-2000' pp.M-53 - M54"; 'Sahs' April 1974, pp.18-19"

4 Olimpbase http://www.olimpbase.org/1936x/1936...

Last updated: 2018-09-29 15:52:52

 page 1 of 1; 7 games  PGN Download 
Game  ResultMoves YearEvent/LocaleOpening
1. T Melngailis vs B Sundberg  0-1381936Munich OlympiadA14 English
2. H Carlos vs T Melngailis  1-0341936Munich OlympiadC01 French, Exchange
3. T Melngailis vs Bogoljubov  0-1681939Kemeri (Latvia)A21 English
4. T Melngailis vs Flohr  0-1331939Kemeri (Latvia)A09 Reti Opening
5. N B Rometti vs T Melngailis  ½-½371939Buenos Aires ol-8 pr BC07 French, Tarrasch
6. L Zavala vs T Melngailis  0-1361939Buenos Aires ol-8 pr BC01 French, Exchange
7. T Melngailis vs E Reed Valenzuela  1-0661939Buenos Aires ol (Men) f-AA14 English
  REFINE SEARCH:   White wins (1-0) | Black wins (0-1) | Draws (1/2-1/2) | Melngailis wins | Melngailis loses  

Kibitzer's Corner
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·  Later Kibitzing>
Sep-22-18  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen> Re the two following posts from the Vladimir Petrov page:

<Sep-21-18 chesshistoryinterest: Further evidence that the Melngailis that competed at Kemeri-Riga 1939 was Tenis: The top 3 in each group in the 1938/9 Latvian Championship Congress qualified for the Final at Kemeri-Riga, as we saw earlier. And the Melngailis that got second in Group 2 was Tenis ("Stasti un Romani", Page 12). http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Re Tenis Melngailis biography, I found the following events he played in up to 1945, in addition to those listed: Riga Ch. 1934. Latvia-Lithuania matches 1934 & 1935 & 1936.
Riga Ch. 1936.
Training tournament, Riga, 1937.
Latvia-Estonia matches 1938 & 1939.
SELL student Olympiads 1938 & 1939.
Latvian Championship Congress, Riga 1938/9, Group 2. Olympiad Selection tournament, Liepaja, 1939. Training tournament, Riga 1940.
Riga Ch. 1943.
Vainode, 1943.
I have not done a thorough look, so there may be one or two others, as well as internal Latvian/Riga team events.

In general, any 'Melngailis' in an event from 1934 where there is only one seems to be Tenis. Emilis seems to be inactive, or nearly so, after about 1936.

Sep-21-18
Premium Chessgames Member jessicafischerqueen: <chesshistoryinterest> Thanks again!

<Re Tenis Melngailis biography, I found the following events he played in up to 1945, in addition to those listed: Riga Ch. 1934. Latvia-Lithuania matches 1934 & 1935 & 1936. Riga Ch. 1936.
Training tournament, Riga, 1937.
Latvia-Estonia matches 1938 & 1939.
SELL student Olympiads 1938 & 1939.
Latvian Championship Congress, Riga 1938/9, Group 2. Olympiad Selection tournament, Liepaja, 1939. Training tournament, Riga 1940. Riga Ch. 1943.
Vainode, 1943.
I have not done a thorough look, so there may be one or two others, as well as internal Latvian/Riga team events.>

This information is from <Di Felice>? I have the relevant <Di Felice> volumes, but if any of the items on your list are from other sources, I would need to know those sources (with page numbers) in order to add the events to Game Collection: Tenis Melngailis Life and Games . I just now read your post, so I have not had a chance to check yet. I believe the documentation for some of those events must already be listed in some of the entries in Game Collection: Vladimirs Petrovs Tournaments/Matches 1923-1942 ?

I suggest that we should move discussion of <Tenis Melngailis> over to Tenis Melngailis ?>

I went through Di Felice up to 1945 for both Tenis and Emilis [as Di Felice often has Emilis instead of Tenis] Melngailis to see what he had. Also <Hemy's> material. Plus I found a few of my own. The documentation for some of these events will undoubtedly be in <Game Collection: Vladimirs Petrovs Tournaments/Matches 1923-1942>. I haven't checked whether the items I will give in my next post exactly match these, but what I have done is ensured the items I give identify Tenis as the Melngailis in them.

I will give them in the next post.

Sep-22-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<chesshistoryinterest> Sounds good, thank you very much.

Please remember to list source names, dates with page numbers in future posts, because without that documentation I can't add the new information to bios or games collections eh?

Sep-22-18  chesshistoryinterest: <jessicafischerqueen> Will do.

I have gone right through Di Felice, etc. to the end now.

Let's see how we go:

Latvia-Lithuania match, 3-4 March, 1934, Kaunas: "Centra Balss", 9 March 1934, Page 6.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Riga Championship 1934:
"Atputa", 8 June 1934, Page 29.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Latvia-Lithuania match, 17-18 March 1935, Riga:
"Krustamikla,Sahs,Bridzs", 23 March 1935, Page 11.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Riga Championship, 20 October 1935 - 23 February 1936: "Sporta Pasaule", 2 March 1936, Page 6.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Latvia-Lithuania match, 28-29 March 1936, Kaunas: "Krusta-mikla,Sahs,Bridzs", 11 April 1936, Page 12.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Will continue next post.

Sep-22-18  chesshistoryinterest: [continuing]

Training tournament, Riga, 26 September - circa 15 December 1937: "Saha Maksla", 25 December 1937, Page 11.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Latvia-Estonia match, Tallinn, 7-8 March 1938:
"Krusta-mikla,Sachs,Bridzs", 19 March 1938, Page 11.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

(also drawn game Sepp-Melngailis from this match: "Saha Maksla", 25 March 1938, Page 9.)

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

2nd SELL student Olympiad, Tartu, 25-27 March 1938: "Rits", 19 March 1938, Page 4.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Latvian Championship Congress, Group 2, Riga, 24 December 1938 - 1 January 1939: "Stasti un Romani", 7 January 1939, Page 12.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

3rd SELL student Olympiad, Helsinki, 19-21 February 1939: "Stasti un Romani", 4 March 1939, Page 23.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Latvia-Estonia match, Riga, 24-26 February 1939: "Stasti un Romani", 4 March 1939, Page 23.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Will continue next post.

Sep-22-18  chesshistoryinterest: [continuing]

1939 Olympiad Selection tournament, Liepaja, 22 April - circa 1 June 1939: "Stasti un Romani", 23 June 1939, Page 23.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Training tournament, Riga, 6 October-30 December 1940: "Sarkanais Sports", 1 January 1941, Page 4.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Riga Championship, 28 February - circa 26 March 1943: "Sporta Pasaule", 29 March 1943, Page 4. (Couldn't find a crosstable on Periodika.lv for this one. Possibly one on the European Library? [I'm not having much success when I try to search that site.])

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Vainode, 3-9 October 1943:
"Sporta Pasaule", 18 October 1943, Page 4.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Will continue next post.

Sep-22-18  chesshistoryinterest: [continuing]

Riga Championship, January 1946:
"Fiziska Kultura", 1 February 1946 (cannot find crosstable on Periodika.lv. Nor do Rusbase have it; nor is it in Di Felice. Jeremy Gaige in "Chess Tournaments: A Checklist" indicated he had it, so it must exist somewhere!).

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Riga Championship, 17 January-15 March 1947 (dates according to Gaige): Rusbase under "National Tournaments" chapter.
[after 1946, Periodika.lv will let you do a search, but won't allow you access to the newspaper item itself. Why is this?] (The Rusbase item only lists some of the competitors [including T. Melngailis] and their scores, but doesn't have a crosstable. Nor does Di Felice. Jeremy Gaige in "Chess Tournaments: A Checklist" indicated he had it, so it must exist somewhere!)

http://al20102007.narod.ru/nat_tour...

Latvian Championship, Riga, 27 March-30 April 1947: Rusbase under "Championships of Republics" chapter.

http://al20102007.narod.ru/ch_repub...

Quarterfinal of USSR Championship, Yaroslavl, 1948: Rusbase under "Championships of USSR" chapter.

http://al20102007.narod.ru/ch_urs/1...

Will continue next post.

Sep-22-18  chesshistoryinterest: [continuing]

That's all I found for now. Would probably pay to check that I've got everything correct.

The above documentation, plus what you have already found, would indicate that Di Felice wrongly has "Emilis Melngailis" instead of "Tenis Melngailis" for the following events in his "Chess Results":

Olympiad 1936.
Latvia-Estonia 1938.
Latvia-Estonia 1939.
Kemeri-Riga 1939.
Olympiad 1939.
Latvian Championship, Riga, 1947.
Latvian Championship, Riga 1948.
Quarterfinal of USSR Championship, Yaroslavl, 1948.

To finish up, I found a crosstable for Kemeri-Riga 1939 that has "T. Melngailis" in it. So that should confirm that one absolutely.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Sep-23-18  chesshistoryinterest: Latvia-Lithuania match, 17-18 March 1935, Riga: I accidentally posted a different table from what I meant to post. The one that identifies Tenis Malngailis is:
"Rigasche Rundschau", 19 March 1935, Page 6.

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

Sep-25-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  hemy: <Riga 1935-1936 (20 October 1935-23 February 1936) Riga Championship. <Petrovs finished 1st> over F. Apsenieks, M. Feigins, T. Bergs and others.>

1. V. Petrov 14/17
2. F. Apšenieks — 12.5/17
3. M. Feigins 12/17

9-10. T. Melngailis and K. Ozols 9/17

[Event "Riga championship"]
[Site "Riga"]
[Date "1935.12.01"]
[Round "8"]
[White "Stabiņš, A"]
[Black "Melngailis, Tenis"]
[Result "0-1"]
[ECO "E34"]
[PlyCount "48"]
[Source "'Krustamīkla. Šahs. Bridžs', January 11, 1936, p. 12; 'Aizsargs', January 15, 1936, p. 78"]

1. d4 Nf6 2. c4 e6 3. Nc3 Bb4 4. Qc2 d5 5. e3 c5 6. a3 Qa5 7. Bd2 cxd4 8. exd4 Nc6 9. Nf3 O-O 10. Rc1 Bxc3 11. Bxc3 Qd8 12. Bd3 dxc4 13. Bxc4 b6 14. Bb5 Bb7 15. Qa4 Qd5 16. O-O a6 17. Be2 b5 18. Qc2 Rac8 19. Qd2 Ne4 20. Qf4 f5 21. Rfd1 g5 22. Nxg5 Nxc3 23. Bf3 Ne2+ 24. Bxe2 Nxd4 0-1

http://periodika.lv/periodika2-view...

http://periodika.lv/periodika2-view...

Sep-26-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  hemy: <Riga 1935-1936 (20 October 1935-23 February 1936) Riga Championship.>

One more game of T. Melngailis from this tournament, against Fricis Apšenieks.

It was published in "Krustamīkla. Šahs. Bridžs" magazine, December 7 , 1935, p. 12 as a game played in round 4 of Riga chess championship. However the game was played in round 5 on October 7th, 1935 ("Rīts", November 8, 1935, p. 7).

In round 4 T. Melngailis played against K. Ozols and Apšenieks against M. Brakmanis ("Rīts", November 4, 1935, p. 4).

In winning position T. Melngailis made big mistake on his last move and the game ended with a draw.

[Event "Riga championship"]
[Site "Riga"]
[Date "1935.11.07"]
[Round "5"]
[White "Melngailis, Tenis"]
[Black "Apsenieks, Fr."]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[ECO "E01"]
[PlyCount "71"]
[Source "'Krustamīkla. Šahs. Bridžs', December 7 , 1935, p. 12"]

1. c4 e6 2. Nf3 d5 3. b3 Nf6 4. Bb2
Nbd7 5. g3 Bd6 6. Bg2 c6 7. O-O O-O 8. d4 Qe7 9. Ne5 Rd8 10. Nxd7 Bxd7 11. Nd2 c5 12. cxd5 exd5 13. Rc1 Bg4 14. Re1 Rac8 15. Nf3 c4 16. Ne5 Be6 17. bxc4 dxc4 18. Qa4 Bb4 19. Red1 c3 20. Ba1 c2 21. Rd3 Bf5 22. e4 Nxe4 23. g4 b5 24. Qxb5 Ba3 25. Bb2 Nc3 26. Rxc3 Rxc3 27. gxf5 Rxd4 28. Bf3 h6 29. f6 Qxf6 30. Rxc2 Bxb2 31. Qxb2 Rxc2 32. Qxd4 Rxa2 33. Bd5 Qg5+ 34. Kf1 Rd2 35. Bxf7+ Kh8 36. Qxd2 1/2-1/2

http://periodika.lv/periodika2-view...

Sep-28-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

From <hemy>:

<Riga 1935-1936 (20 October 1935-23 February 1936) Riga Championship. <Petrovs finished 1st> over F. Apsenieks, M. Feigins, T. Bergs and others. Di Felice, "Chess Results 1936-1940" p.8;
'Krustamīkla. Šahs. Bridžs', November 23, 1935, p.12; "Rīts", November 19, 1935, p.7.

Both Emils Melngailis and Tenis Melngailis participated in this event.>

Vladimir Petrov (kibitz #771)

Sep-28-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<chesshistoryinterest> Awesome research thank you so much!

On the periodika web links, my ability to "read" those pages is zero. I can't even decipher many of the letters and numbers, let alone the words. Could be a problem with my brain/eyes. Hopefully a Latvian speaker can post the cited information from those linked pages in English?

Sep-28-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<chesshistoryinterest>

This is interesting: <Quarterfinal of USSR Championship, Yaroslavl, 1948: Rusbase under "Championships of USSR" chapter.

http://al20102007.narod.ru/ch_urs/1... >

On the actual crosstable page it is named <Tournament of candidates to masters- Yaroslavl 1948>.

I wonder what that means, exactly? Could it mean that all of the participants were Candidate Masters, or either Candidate Masters or Masters? If so, that would mean that T. Melngailis had a Soviet Candidate Master title at the time of this event.

Sep-28-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  hemy: <JFQ>
<Tournament of candidates to masters> means that all of the participants were Candidate Masters.

The master title was possible to get only in tournaments where at least 3 masters participated.

For the best Candidate Masters the Soviet chess federation could arrange match with master. To get master title CM had to win a match against master or to made a draw in 2 such a matches.

In 1967, when in I played in USSR team championship ("Spartakiad") in Moscow I was approached by Chess federation officials and offered to played in match-tournament of 7 young (20 years old) Candidates Masters against 7 Masters in my home town Vilnius. Because of my exams in University in Kaunas city I couldn't accept this offer.

In this tournament each CM played with each Master 2 games. To get master title CM had to make 7.5/14 or more.

I remember that in this tournament Evgeny Sveshnikov was crushing masters and finished with 12/14. Seiran Chechelian from Armenia came with his father and Genrikh Kasparyan, one of the greatest composers of chess endgame studies. Kasparian was helping him with analysis of adjourned games. I was told by Isakas Vistaneckis that Chechelian's father was helping his son with generous offers to masters.

My goal was to finish University and emigrate to Israel, so I didn'y played in tournaments.

I received the master title later, in Israel.

Sep-28-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  jessicafischerqueen:

<hemy> Thank you, and especially for more anecdotes from your chess career!

From your earlier translation, we know that <T. Melngailis> indeed held the Candidate Master title at this time:

<Riga 1946> (5 May-30 June) Latvian Soviet Republic Team Candidates Tournament. http://al20102007.narod.ru/nat_tour... <Melngailis shared 1st with J. Vatnikov, scoring +9-4=2.> Melngailis was awarded the Candidate Master title after this event. [https://lv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenis... ]

Sep-29-18  mifralu: He also played in a Training tournament (Riga 1936) for the Munich Olympiad.

http://periodika.lv/periodika2-view...

The candidates were divided into two groups,
A and B, each playing a tournament. In the A group Mezgailis won with 3.5 points; 2. < Indriķis Kalnins > 2,5 Arvids Kalnins (kibitz #1) 3rd 4th Brakmanis and < T. Melngailis each 1.5; > 5th Ozols 1.

In the B-group won:
1.-2. Dreibergs and Friede each 5
3-5. Giese, A. Kalnins and Taube each 4 points.
Based on these results Mezgailis and < Indriķis Kalnins > are added to the team ...

The three last of the A group with the
three first of the B group playing off a new tournament...

New tournament, 8 players:
From Group A: Brakmanis, < T. Melngailis >, Ozols

From Group B: Dreibergs, Friede, Giese,
and Endzelins - Riga and Elson - Walka
were allowed. The result of this fight:
1. Ozols 5; 2nd < T. Melngailis 4,5 >; 3. L. Endzelins 4 points.

By decision of the Latvian Chess Federation
the Latvian representation Team for Munich: Petrov, Apscheneek., <Edgars Roberts Krūmiņš> Alfred J Krumins (kibitz #2) Feigins, Hasenfuss, Mezgailis, <Indriķis Kalnins>, Ozols, <T. Melngailis >and Endzelins. ______________________________

Please also have a look at Arvids Kalnins (kibitz #1) and Alfred J Krumins (kibitz #2). Hope I got it right. :)

Sep-29-18  chesshistoryinterest: <Hemy>, thanks for answering <jessicafischerqueen's> question about <Tournament of candidates to masters>. I didn't have much idea. Just wondering why the term "masters" is mentioned if that Title wasn't on offer in this event. Or is "Tournament of candidates to masters" a mistranslation, and should read "Tournament of candidate masters"?

I certainly second <jessicafischerqueen's> comment that anecdotes from your chess career are very welcome, as is any information on how the USSR chess system worked.

<Jessicafischerqueen>, I too, wondered why the crosstable had a different heading than the expected <Quarterfinal of USSR Championship> (and it's the same for all the 1948 events listed <"Quarterfinal of USSR Championship" in the Rusbase index). I'm presuming the tournament was both. Gaige in "Checklist" calls it "Master Candidates", while Di Felice calls it "Quarterfinal 17th USSR ch" [that's the 1949 USSR ch, not the 1948 one]. Di Felice's source is "Shakhmaty v SSSR 1948, p. 262". And, indeed, the winner, Cherepkov, is in the USSR Semifinal at Tbilisi, 25 April - May 1949, while the second placegetter, Solmanis, was in the USSR Semifinal at Moscow, 25 May - 22 June 1949. So it certainly looks like it was a USSR Ch. Quarterfinal as well.

I think Rusbase is an awesome website. Has a tremendous amount of information that would otherwise be very hard to get. Olimpbase is another hugely helpful website. These guys deserve a huge amount of gratitude from the chess world.

Sep-29-18  chesshistoryinterest: <mifralu>
Funnily enough, I've been looking at this very stuff the last couple of nights trying to sort it out. :)

I think you've got the Kalnins and Krumins stuff right. This item ("Rits", 10 August 1936, page 4):

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

shows what I think are the correct names, and are what you give. I also agree that it was Edgars Krumins (not Alfreds) who played in the 1935 Warsaw Olympiad.

Funny how I've just praised Olimpbase and here we are discussing errors in it. In my experience, such errors on this very excellent website are extremely rare indeed.

Di Felice's version also has errors. He correctly has Edgars Krumins; but wrongly has Arvids Kalnins instead of Indrikis; and wrongly has Emilis Melngailis instead of Tenis.

Re the tournaments in preparation for the 1936 Munich Olympiad: My assessment would be that these are Qualification tournaments, not a Training tournament. The actual Training tournament was held shortly afterwards, 27 July - 3 August 1936, Riga, where Edgars Krumins, Feigins, and Paul List from Berlin tied for first. Paul Schmidt from Estonia was 4th, half a point behind.

I think you've deceiphered these probably Qualification tournaments very well. Slight corrections I have are: "Giese" would be the player Gize.
"Elson" is Eklons from Valga [Walka is the German name for Valga]. He was the "Pride of the North" [he drew a match with Mikenas 2.5 - 2.5 in Valga, 16-18 November 1930]. In Group B, I get Gize, A. Kalnins and Taube getting 4.5 points, not 4. Gize got into the final tournament because Taube declined to take part in the playoff; Gize then won a game from A. Kalnins after which A. Kalnins declined to play further. The "A. Kalnins" is Arnold Kalnins as opposed to Arvids, this established by "Rits", 10 July 1936, Page 4.

Sep-30-18  mifralu: < chesshistoryinterest > < Slight corrections I have are: "Giese" would be the player Gize.>

Ernests Gize, son of August Giese
https://lv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ernes...

Augusts Gize

< "Elson" is Eklons from Valga >

Two different players, see
https://lv.wikipedia.org/wiki/1935....

Alfrēds Eklons
https://lv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alfr%...

"Elson" might be < Nils Elisons >(3rd place in Latvian Championship 1935).

Sep-30-18  chesshistoryinterest: <mifralu>

Gize/Giese: I think the version of this depends on the language of the article. Gize is Latvian, Giese is probably German.

Eklons/Elisons: That Gothic is hard to read. I'm pretty sure the second letter is a 'k' (I've come across this before). Anyway, here is another item on this event, in Latvian this time ("Jaunakas Zinas", 22 July 1936, Page 10):

http://www.periodika.lv/periodika2-...

It clearly reads "Eklons" and "Gize".

Also, this player was given as from Valga. Eklons was the only significant player to come from there. I'm pretty sure Elisons was from Riga.

[The Wikipedia article has the Eklons-Mikenas match as being in 1932. But contemporary newspaper articles on the match are in 1930. <Encyclopedia of Latvian Chessplayers> has the same error.]

Nov-02-18  chesshistoryinterest: On the <G. Melngailis vs Paul Keres game> page, <hemy> has made the correction that the "G. Melngailis" is in fact Tenis Melngailis:

<Sep-28-18
Premium Chessgames Member hemy: Paul Keres played against Tenis Melngailis, not <G. Melngailis>. Match "Kalev" (Estonia)- Daugava (Latvia), Tallinn, 1947.

1st board:
round 1: P. Keres - T. Melngailis 1:0
round 2: P. Keres - A. Aleksandrov 1:0

https://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9...

G Melngailis vs Keres, 1947

To me, this is confirmed by the fact that a couple of days earlier, Tenis was playing for the Latvian team in the Latvian SSR - Estonian SSR match, 15-18 June 1947, Tallinn (draw, then a win vs. Kondratjev) [Sources: Rusbase; and "Male Eestis", page 165].

In the "Kalev" - Daugava match (won by "Kalev" 10.5-5.5), Tenis Melngailis would have played a different opponent in Round 2, but I don't know whom, or the result. The event is not on Rusbase or in Di Felice and doesn't seem to be mentioned on periodika.lv either. It is mentioned on page 165 in "Male Eestis", but not with enough detail to determine this.

Nov-02-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  hemy: <chesshistoryinterest>

The search in Latvian periodicals of 1947 returning snippets, but not opening the actual pages. I used different 'keywords', taken from the each snippet to get the next one and so on.

I was able to compile the text of some articles. It didn't help too much for information about 'Kalev' - 'Daugava' match.

"Cīņa", June 22, 1947, p. ??:

"... Sport Club "Daugava" team remained in Tallinn to play a match with "Kalev" chess players. In the first round, Keres won Melngailis, Solmanis-Renter, Turn-Zdanov, Randvirs - Bleks and Kruzkop - Kalde.
Games Bāiiņš - Kondratjev and Zvirbulis - Kibermann ended with a draw. Aleksandrov - Arulaid game adjourned - Aleksandrov in a slightly better position. The result is currently 4: 3 at in the favor of 'Kalev'."

Result and table of the <Match Estonia-Latvia 12:11- Tallinn 14-15.6.1947>: http://al20102007.narod.ru/matches/...

"Cīņa", June 18, 1947: "... match between Latvian and Estonian chess teams, June 15 to June 19, Tallinn ...".

Nov-03-18  chesshistoryinterest: <hemy> Nice find with that "Cina", 22 June 1947 item. I tried combining it with what is on page 165 of "Male Eestis". That states: <Veelgi kindlamini - 10.5:5.5 - voitis "Kalev" - "Daugava". Individuaalselt toid kalevlastele punkte: Keres, Randviir ja Turn 2, Arulaid ja Kibbermann 1.5, Kondratjev ja Rich. Prunn kumbki 0.5, Renter 0.5 ja Kalde 0. Latlasi esindasid Aleksandrov, Melngailis, Solmanis, Blek, Zdanov, Kruskop, Balin ja Zvirbulis.> I take it that "kumbki" in this means that Kondratjev and Rich. Prunn each played only one game.

So we have that in the first round, Aleksandrov played Arulaid and in the second, Keres. It is possible that Keres and Arulaid swapped opponents for Round 2, which would mean that Tenis Melngailis played Arulaid in Round 2. Unfortunately, we don't know Arulaid's result in Round 1, so cannot determine how he did against Tenis Melngailis in Round 2 (if he played him). Perhaps we should advise the compiler of Rusbase of this information, and he might be able to find more in Soviet sources.

As for the table of the match <Estonian SSR - Latvian SSR, 1947> on Rusbase, there is something wrong with it, because although it says the score was 12:11 in the heading, at the bottom it gives the score as 12.5:11.5 The table in "Male Eestis", page 165, plus a comment, plus the final score of 12:11 there, indicates that the second Malksoo-Balin game was not played. There are also a couple of other conflicts between the two tables: Rusbase gives the Prunn that played as Richard, while "Male Eestis" gives the Prunn as Rudolf. Item snippets on periodika.lv support the "Male Eestis" version. Rusbase also has the wrong initial for Aleksandrov. Also the last 4 board orders are different. Rusbase gives Board 9 as Kalde-Straume; Board 10 as Kibbermann-Kruskop; Board 11 as Heinra-Zvirbulis; Board 12 as Pruun-Blek, whereas "Male Eestis" gives Board 9 as Pruun-Blek; Board 10 as Kalde-Straume; Board 11 as Kibbermann-Kruskop; Board 12 as Heinra-Zvirbulis. Also dates differ. Rusbase gives the dates as 14-15 June 1947, while "Male Eestis" gives the dates as 15-18 June 1947. "Paul Keres: Photographs and Games" says Keres played his two games on 16 and 17 June 1947, which supports the "Male Eestis" version. All in all, I believe the "Male Eestis" version.

[In the "Kalev"-"Daugava" match, "Paul Keres: Photographs and Games" says Keres played Melngailis in 19 June 1947, and Aleksandrov on 20 June 1947.]

Nov-03-18
Premium Chessgames Member
  hemy: <chesshistoryinterest> <As for the table of the match <Estonian SSR - Latvian SSR, 1947> on Rusbase, there is something wrong with it>

"Cīņa", June 18, 1947:

Tallinn, June 15-June 18, 1947.

Estonia-Latvia
Round 1:
1. Keres - Koblenc 1-0
2. Renter - Solmanis 0-1
3. Arulaid - Aleksandrov
4. Randvir - Mežgailis 0.5-0.5
5. Kondratiev - T. Melngailis 0.5-0.5
6. Tiurn - Šiliņš
7. Villard - Zdanov
8. Melks - Balinš
9. Kalde - Straume
10. Rich. Prūn - Kruzkop 0.5-0.5
11. Heinre - Zvirbulis 0.5-0.5
12. Rud. Prun - Bleks 0-1

The current score is 4:3 in favor of the Latvian SSR.

"Padomju Jaunatne", June 19, 1947:
The Latvian-Estonian chess match adjourned games continued to play on June 18. 3. Arulaid - Aleksandrov 0.5-0.5
6. Tirn - Šiliņš 0.5-0.5
7. Villard - Zdanov 0.5-0.5

"Cīņa", June 22, 1947:

Estonia-Latvia
Round 2:
1. Keres - Koblenc 1-0
2. Renter - Solmanis 0.5-0.5
3. Arulaid - Aleksandrov 1-0
4. Randvir - Mežgailis 0.5-0.5
5. Kondratiev - T. Melngailis 0-1
6. Tirn - Šiliņš 0-1
7. Villard - Zdanov 0-1
8. Melks - Balinš
9. Kalde - Straume
10. Kibermann - Kruzkop 1-0
11. Heinre - Zvirbulis
12. Rud. Prun - Bleks 0.5-0.5

Round 1 game Melks - Balinš ended in draw after 13 hours of game. (Round 1: 8. Melks - Balinš 0.5-0.5).

Due to lack of time, it was not possible to complete the Balinš - Melks second-round game, where Balinš have a great chance to win.
The game will be sent to arbitration in Moscow for evaluation. The score is currently 12:11 in favor of the Estonian SSR.

"Fiziskā Kultūra", July 1, 1947:

... Keress 1 1 - Koblencs 0 0
Renters 0 0.5 - Solmanis 1 0.5
Arulaid - Aleksandrov 0.5 1 - 0.5 0
... Kalde - Straume 1 1 - 0 0
... Heinre - Zvirbulis 0.5 0.5 - 0.5 0.5

************
Round 1:
1. Keres - Koblenc 1-0
2. Renter - Solmanis 0-1
3. Arulaid - Aleksandrov 0.5-0.5
4. Randvir - Mežgailis 0.5-0.5
5. Kondratiev - T. Melngailis 0.5-0.5
6. Tirn - Šiliņš 0.5-0.5
7. Villard - Zdanov 0.5-0.5
8. Melks - Balinš 0.5-0.5
9. Kalde - Straume 1-0
10. Rich. Prūn - Kruzkop 0.5-0.5
11. Heinre - Zvirbulis 0.5-0.5
12. Rud. Prun - Bleks 0-1

Estonia - Latvia 6:6

Round 2:
1. Keres - Koblenc 1-0
2. Renter - Solmanis 0.5-0.5
3. Arulaid - Aleksandrov 1-0
4. Randvir - Mežgailis 0.5-0.5
5. Kondratiev - T. Melngailis 0-1
6. Tirn - Šiliņš 0-1
7. Villard - Zdanov 0-1
8. Melks - Balinš
9. Kalde - Straume 1-0
10. Kibermann - Kruzkop 1-0
11. Heinre - Zvirbulis 0.5-0.5
12. Rud. Prun - Bleks 0.5-0.5

Estonia - Latvia 6:5

Nov-03-18  chesshistoryinterest: Really good finds, <hemy>.

If a result came back from arbitration in Moscow for the second Malksoo-Balins game, it must have been adjudicated as a draw. I'm not too convinced that a result ever came back. "Male Eestis" was published in 1965, so that is ample time for such a result to have come back. Given that publication was for Estonian events, and given the critical nature of the result, the Estonians must have been very interested in it and would surely have known about it if one had came back. Plus Rusbase had 12:11 in their heading; and given the number of errors they have for this item, this "draw" result looks a bit untrustworthy. Certainly I think an unimpeachable source for such a result would need to be seen for it to be accepted. Something else (in addition to "Kalev"-"Daugava") for Rusbase [a very good site in general] to look at.

So in Round 1, Richard Pruun, not Kibbermann, plays Kruzkop! That means BOTH published tables were wrong (though the Rusbase one remains much more wrong than the one in "Male Eestis"). Amazing how many errors show up in later publications when original sources are drilled down to.

search thread:   
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·  Later Kibitzing>
NOTE: You need to pick a username and password to post a reply. Getting your account takes less than a minute, totally anonymous, and 100% free--plus, it entitles you to features otherwise unavailable. Pick your username now and join the chessgames community!
If you already have an account, you should login now.
Please observe our posting guidelines:
  1. No obscene, racist, sexist, or profane language.
  2. No spamming, advertising, or duplicating posts.
  3. No personal attacks against other members.
  4. Nothing in violation of United States law.
  5. No posting personal information of members.
Blow the Whistle See something that violates our rules? Blow the whistle and inform an administrator.


NOTE: Keep all discussion on the topic of this page. This forum is for this specific player and nothing else. If you want to discuss chess in general, or this site, you might try the Kibitzer's Café.
Messages posted by Chessgames members do not necessarily represent the views of Chessgames.com, its employees, or sponsors.
Spot an error? Please suggest your correction and help us eliminate database mistakes!


home | about | login | logout | F.A.Q. | your profile | preferences | Premium Membership | Kibitzer's Café | Biographer's Bistro | new kibitzing | chessforums | Tournament Index | Player Directory | Notable Games | World Chess Championships | Opening Explorer | Guess the Move | Game Collections | ChessBookie Game | Chessgames Challenge | Store | privacy notice | contact us
Copyright 2001-2018, Chessgames Services LLC