jessicafischerqueen: No, <Travis>= Love you= hate the song. The tragedy is terrible- but it has nothing to do with the quality of the song.
I can't stand "saccharine-style" mainstream singing- and melodies-
It's just taste <Travis>-- I hate that kind of music. And that song in particular, because yes- I don't like the idea that the audience has to like a song because it's based on a tragedy.
That Country Western star that made a "Hit" with a truly awful quality song about <9-11>--
<South Park> made vicious fun of him. And it was hilarious, because nobody was going to say anything about how CRAP the song was because of the extent of the tragedy.
Impassioned know- it - all rhetoric about art in particular, <Travis>, is just my style.
I exagerrate the quality of the music I love- "Best ever" etc...
And I exagerrate the quality of the music I hate- "Worst ever" etc.
That's mainly just rhetoric. I knew a guy in Montreal who only ever gave two reviews about a song-
If he liked it, he would nod his head.
If he didn't, he'd just say AWFUL!
But he'd say it really loud and pronounce it "AWWWWW FULL"
And he wouldn't budge from it. Ithought he was hilarious- particularly when he disagreed with me. That' just how I roll.
So one last time- <Ebony and Ivory> is written and performed by two of the greatest singer/songwriters in history. Both are nice guys. The subject-- racial harmony in the world-- is super important.
But the song itself- that paricular song - is UTTER CRAP.
People make fun of it on a daily basis because of how saccharine the song is.
I don't like crappy mainstream songs that cover important topics- personal tragedy, major tragedy, serious problems in world history- and cover these topics with a STYLE of music I despise.
I don't despise <Eric Clapton, Alan Jackson, Stevie Wonder, or Paul McCartney>.
And I certainly don't despise YOU.
I know you.
I don't know those other guys.
And I love you too- you are similar to me in your passion. Which is why you are yelling at me.
<Travis> if you look back at our posting history, I have never said anything remotely mean or even negative about you- not even after you put me on ignore.
So please bear that in mind.
Also, everything I"ve just said is really true--
When that <Eric Clapton> song comes on the radio- or <Ebony and Ivory> for that matter, and a thousand other CRAP SONGS, I "dislike" them so much I actually have to leave the location I'm at.
That's not a "normal state of affairs". Most people don't love or hate particular kinds of pop music like that. And they are able to tune it out. I can't. Every CRAP NOTE and CRAP FAKE EMOTION in their voice is like a dagger to my heart.
That's me- take it or leave it <Travis>.