|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 616 OF 914 ·
Later Kibitzing> |
| Sep-20-14 | | Jim Bartle: Espn guy has made a list of the best seasons by a pitcher in the last fifty years, really wonky. Pedro Martinez got the best two seasons, followed by Gooden and Koufax. Gibson 1968 came in 7th, Kershaw this year 15th. Clemens 1986 was not on the list. Also missing entirely were Marichal, McLain, Verlander, and Hershiser 1988. http://espn.go.com/mlb/story/_/id/1... |
|
Sep-20-14
 | | WannaBe: Already have 2 upsets, Miss St. & Indiana, will Clemson be next?? |
|
Sep-20-14
 | | WannaBe: Jerome Williams became a part of history today, he was the winning pitcher for Phillies vs A's. (He was the starter for Philadelphia) Well, he also won on July 25, as a member of the Texas Rangers, (starter) and April 26 as a member of the Houston Astros (in relieve, got the win and also blown save) And of course, mass confusion in the Detroit/Kansas City game, is the play reviewable or not? If not, why was the call reversed??? |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | Phony Benoni: Okay, we've given Yasiel Puig a hard time around here. This is his good side: http://m.mlb.com/video/v36436641/mu... That may have been the best catch of the day, but it wasn't the best throw: http://m.mlb.com/video/v36434023/la... |
|
| Sep-21-14 | | Jim Bartle: <And of course, mass confusion in the Detroit/Kansas City game, is the play reviewable or not? If not, why was the call reversed???> Really dumb play by KC.
But umpires should be watching for things like players tagging up. The dugouts sure are. Part of the confusion, in the video I saw, was that the actual appeal to third was not shown at the time, only after the out ruling. |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | Phony Benoni: Dumb play all around. The Tigers' shortstop, Suarez, is a rookie who has been filling in adequately most of the year but is now beginning to show his lack of experience. If the Tiger's get into the playoffs, you won't see much of him. The base-running mistake was only noticed by one of the Tigers' September call-ups, Hernan Perez. Kid can't hit for anything, but he certainly earned a few brownie points. The Tigers appealed, and the third base umpire called the runner was called safe. When Tigers' manager Ausmus asked for a review. The umpire wasn't 100% sure whether the play was reviewable; it was in a gray area. So, he probably did the right thing by consulting the replay officials, who told him the play could not be reviewed and gave no other information. Meanwhile, the replay had been shown at the stadium, and 40,000 fans groaned. It was that obvious. The above is from statements made to the press later. Nobody said this part, but I'm sure the umpires had to know what the correct call was. The problem was that they received the information from unauthorized sources. So I think the long consultation was a matter of finding a means to justify "getting it right". In the end, they resorted to a vague statement about agreeing on the call, which they stuck to when Royals' manager Ned Yost asked specifically which umpire saw the call. After all, on the third base umpire would have had a chance of seeing it, and he had already ruled "safe". It's really a fascinating case. The umpires "got the call right", but technically they probably used an illegal procedure to do so. Should they have stuck strictly to the manual and gotten the call wrong? That would be tough simply because they would have admitted some measure of incompetence. So both sides were right. Several players make big mistakes, the umpires get the blame, but all the while the biggest blunder was that of the fans. If they would have just kept their big traps shut... |
|
| Sep-21-14 | | Jim Bartle: Hard to believe a professional umpiring crew didn't check if a runner touched a base. That's elementary. But at least the proper procedure was followed (appeal, ump's call at third). Not clear at all on the mlb.com video. Ausmus had no reason to argue until after the appeal. The runner on third had no baseball sense. First thing you do on a caught fly is to go back to your base. |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | WannaBe: Dewey Win! Dewey Win!!
http://espn.go.com/college-football... |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | WannaBe: Let's get the games started!! |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | WannaBe: Atlanta's collapse is now complete, they have been eliminated from wild card. |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | WannaBe: From watching the replay, I thought the hit on Foles was clean... Shoulder hit. |
|
| Sep-21-14 | | Jim Bartle: The hit was clean, but the play was over. |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | WannaBe: <JB> I went back and watched it again, 5 times, it looks to me to be simultaneous... How did you reach the conclusion that the play was over? Runner went down the same time as the hit. |
|
| Sep-21-14 | | Jim Bartle: But the play was clearly over, the guy was clearly being tackled, Foles had nothing to do with the play. Super cheat shot, an old time Raiders shot. |
|
Sep-21-14
 | | perfidious: <WannaBe: Atlanta's collapse is now complete, they have been eliminated from wild card.> Always rough when a good team loses four-fifths of their starting rotation. |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | WannaBe: According to SB Nation's web site, 49ers/Cardinals fan got into a pretty bloody/ugly brawl in the stands, and also a bunch of Eagles fans started a brawl with fellow Eagles fans... Who they think they are? Raiders fans?? |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | Phony Benoni: More proof that Eagles' fans don't like anybody. |
|
| Sep-22-14 | | Jim Bartle: What did the 49ers fans do? Smash the Cardinals fans with their wine glasses? |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | WannaBe: For the weekly pool, I need Bears to win, and total pts be 41 or under... |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | Phony Benoni: If you're predicting more than 41 in the Bears game, don't pick them to win! (Sorry, Travis. Still feeling a bit giddy after beating Green Bay yesterday. Should be over it in a week.) |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | perfidious: After Jets' abysmal start, they have pulled it together and game is looking like a stone cold over at 17-13, even with the actual number of 45. |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | WannaBe: Maybe both teams can pull a "49ers" and not score in the second half... |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | WannaBe: Wow, that whistle just cost New York 7 pts... Clear fumble, runner headed for the end zone, and whistle blew... |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | WannaBe: 24-16 Chicago, C'mon defense!! Both sides!!! |
|
Sep-22-14
 | | WannaBe: Stupid field goal... |
|
 |
 |
|
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 616 OF 914 ·
Later Kibitzing> |