< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 9 OF 9 ·
|Apr-19-16|| ||Solomon2003: there are many games study everyday but this is the best game to study because there is nothing to study|
|Jul-05-16|| ||dernier loup de T: Very intelligent and amusing "Reti's parrot-comment", Solomon2003; half joking but I am fairly tired to see comments like this one...|
|Jul-20-16|| ||The Kings Domain: Brilliant game by Anderssen. Truly an Evergreen; there's just something refreshing about playing and admiring the marvelous combination the great professor seamlessly executes here.|
|Jan-08-17|| ||thegoodanarchist: Look at how quickly these ancient masters developed their pieces! By move 14, ALL pieces except Black's king rook have been developed. |
Of course, White's queen's rook was developed only by connection, but still....
|Jul-06-17|| ||Cheapo by the Dozen: I hope that this is from time to time GoTD in December with the caption "O Tannenbaum!".|
|Aug-22-17|| ||DraganChase: Hey... I have a question, on move 22, why did king black go e8,and not c6 instead?|
|Aug-22-17|| ||tpstar: If 22 ... Kc6 then 23. Bd7#:
click for larger view
A great way to learn and improve is by reading each game's kibitzing from the top. This is a flawed brilliancy, primarily due to 19 ... Qh3.
<COMPUTER ANNOTATED SCORE> Nice enhancement.
|Aug-28-17|| ||DraganChase: Oh, wow... Didn't see that one. Thanks.
That 19. ... Qh3 was the fatal misstep.
|Aug-28-17|| ||Big Pawn: I loaded this game up and let stockfish 8 have a look at it. At depth = 48, it gives as the best line:|
20. cxd4 Qxf3
and it's a dead draw at 0.00. (Komodo 10 and Fritz 15 give 19...Qh3 20. Bf1 Qf5 as a dead draw too at 0.00.)
21. Be4 Rxg2+
22. Kh1 Rxh2+
23. Kxh2 Qxf2+
24. Kh1 Qh4+
25. Kg1 Qg3+
And it is a perpetual check.
|Aug-28-17|| ||Big Pawn: In light of the 19...Bd4! best defense, which ends with a perpetual, the best move for white is not 19. Rad1, but 19.Be4!|
Stockfish 8 (depth = 46) plus Komodo and Fritz all give 19. Be4 as best with a slight advantage to white of around +0.35.
19. Be4 Qh3
20. g3 Rxg3+
21. hg Qxg3+
22. Kh1 Bxf2
23. Bxe7 Qh3+
24. Nh2 Bxe1
and it's white's slight advantage at about ⩲ 0.39
The line continues
26. Qd1 Nxe7
27. Bxb7 Qxf6
White has a small plus, but it's not so clear he can win with only two pawns left.
And there's still plenty of interesting game left to play.
|Oct-16-17|| ||Phony Benoni: There's a silly question attached to this game. Here's the position after <22.Bf5+>:|
click for larger view
Now after 22...Ke8 23.Bd7+, what was Black's final move, 23...Kd8 or 23...Kf8? Both moves allow 24.Bse7#, of course, but which one was it?
Some decades ago, when I had a large book collection, I looked this up. I found the game in no fewer than 45 books or magazines. Of these, 22 had 23...Kd8, and 22 had 23...Kf8. The tie-breaking source was Emanuel's Lasker's 'Manual of Chess" -- which gave 22...Kc6 23.Bd7# in the diagrammed position.
And there's always the possibility that Anderssen announced the mate or that Dufresne resigned, in which cases the move was never played at all!
Yes, it's a silly point. But GOTD's with eight pages of kibitzing rarely stir more interest, so it's something.
|Oct-16-17|| ||eykca: <"You can see the hand of a master".>|
A borrowed line from when Leibniz challenged his contemporaries to solve a difficult math problem. Legend has it, Newton came home from his farm one day to find the problem in his mailbox. He solved it that evening and submitted it anonymously. Upon viewing the only solution submitted, Leibniz famously said "I recognize the lion by its paw."
|Oct-16-17|| ||Taidanii: 17. Nf6+ is a pretty terrible blunder. It appears to be the 2nd worst blunder of the game by analysis. Play should continue 17. Ng3 Qh6. 18 Rad1 O-O 19 Bc1 and the black queens days are numbered.|
Stockfish gives a 7 point swing because of 17. Nf6+. It simply equalizes for black. Unfortunately, this is far from a brilliancy and appears to be a club level game by today's standards. Still, great for the time and instructive as always is Anderssen
|Oct-16-17|| ||offramp: A very good pun!
<FrÍne> is the French word for the Fir tree, the archetypal evergreen.
In Old French this was Fresne, and the tree gave its name to the town of <Le Fresne-sur-Loire> in France.
It was from that town that DuFresne's family originated, although the family later moved to Germany.
Kudos to the punster! As Game of the Day it's my Lock of the Week for Pun of the Year!
|Oct-16-17|| ||kevin86: A great game by Anderssen- the attack is unsprung quickly!|
|Oct-16-17|| ||chessgames.com: For the next few weeks going to be running games features from our Thematic Challenge Voting Page to create discussion and interest in our new team-chess game starting on November 1st.|
About the Evergreen, we've done a very thorough analysis of this game: Anderssen vs Dufresne, 1852 [analysis]
Stockfish agreed with Taidanii's statement that White could have easily won with <17.Ng3 Qh6 18.Rad1 O-O 19.Bc1 Qe6 20.Ng5 Qh6 21.Bxh7+ +- +6.87 (37 ply)> but instead 17.Nf6+? gxf6 <⩲ +0.57 (36 ply)>. Furthermore Black ultimately lost because he "took the bait" with 19...Qxf3? whereas <19...Qh3 20.Bf1 Qf5 21.Kh1 Qxf6 22.Bxe7 Nxe7 23.Rxd7 Kf8 = 0.00 (48 ply)> in which case the attack fizzles out and we doubtfully would be talking about it today.
It's been said that the best way to appreciate a masterpiece is not to dissect it; Anderssen was amazingly creative and pulled off his trickery in brilliant style. I'm not so sure modern GMs would find defenses like Stockfish prattles off so easily. Hats off to Anderssen and this gem.
|Oct-16-17|| ||bachiller: Good point <offramp>, but I think you have chosen the wrong tree: frŤne (fresne) in french corresponds to "ash" in english, latin "fraxinus" and spanish "fresno". The town in California named Fresno, presumably ows its name to the presence of those trees.|
|Feb-09-18|| ||kishore4u: The evergreen party|
|Feb-09-18|| ||morfishine: Surely, if Black wastes a tempo with 7...d3, then the capture <7...dxc3> is at least as good, possibly better|
|Sep-28-18|| ||sallyx: According to the book Common sense in chess by Emanuel Lasker, move 12. was Bxb5 and move 22. ... Kc6 23. Sd7#|
|Sep-28-18|| ||keypusher: <sallyx > Scroll to phony benoniís post from 2017. No one is ever going to know precisely what moves were played in this game, and Lasker writing 40+ years after the fact seems like a decidedly unreliable source.|
|Dec-09-18|| ||MDKnight: Since Black is threatening mate, why not the Black King dodge the rook? 20...Kd8 21. Rd7 Kc8|
|Dec-25-18|| ||HarryP: So 19. Rad1 is not White's best move? Great Mariah. Lasker said 19. Rad1 was "one of the most subtle and profound moves on record."|
|Apr-23-19|| ||Chessmusings: A forest of complications deeply analyzed here: https://chessmusings.wordpress.com/...|
|Apr-23-19|| ||keypusher: <MDKnight: Since Black is threatening mate, why not the Black King dodge the rook? 20...Kd8 21. Rd7 Kc8>|
a) 22....Rxd8 23.gxf3
b) 22...Nxd8 23.Qd7+ Kxd7 24.Bf5+ Kc6 25.Bd7#
c) 22....Kxd8 23.Bf5+ Ke8 24.Bd6+ Kd8 25.Bxc6+ Qxd1+ 26.Qxd1+ Kc8 27.Qd7#
< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 9 OF 9 ·