< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 3 OF 3 ·
Later Kibitzing> 
Aug1706
  Pawn and Two: <Honza Cervenka: no doubt black is on the edge of defeat, but one improvement for black, in your last line would be 35...Rd8 instead of 35...Qe6. 

Aug1706
  Honza Cervenka: <Pawn and Two><one improvement for black, in your last line would be 35...Rd8 instead of 35...Qe6> That's correct. But black's position is almost in zugwang state after quiet 36.Kg1 which eliminates eventual ePawn push. For example, 36...Rd7 37.Bc3 (threatening Ne5+) 37...Ke6 38.Qh8 and the finish is not far away, for example 38...Nb6 39.Rxd7 Nxd7 40.Qc8 (Qc6+ and Ne5 is in the air) 40...Bf6 41.Qc6+ Ke7 42.Qd6+ Ke8 (42...Kd8 43.Ba5+ Ke8 44.Qe6+ and black loses the Knight or Queen) 43.Qe6+ Kf8 44.Ne5 Nxe5 45.Bxe5 Kg7 46.Qe7+ Qf7 47.Bxf6+ and black can resign being a piece down. 36...Bf6 is not much better as absence of possibility to play Qe6 allows 37.Qb3 with terrible effect to come. Of course, 36...Ke6 37.Qb3 is bad as well. And white is also threatening to play 37.Bc7 attacking the Rook and freeing e5 for K+Q fork. So what to do now?:) 

Aug1706
  Pawn and Two: <Honza Cervenka & InspiredByMorphy> InspiredByMorphy, you have proposed an interesting variation starting with 27...Nxd5 28.Rb5 Rc5 29.Rxc5 bxc5 30.Be5 Be7 31.Qh5+ Ke6 32.Qxh7 Qe8 33.Qh3 Qg6. Certainly black has an inferior position, but the question is, if the positions arising after 27...Nxd5 offer drawing chances for black, or if it is a clear win for white. Honza Cervenka, at this point you proposed the moves 34.Rf2 Kf7 35.Rd2. Then I suggested the move 35...Rd8, and Honza replied with 36.Kg1 for white. I agree the variations arising after 36.Kg1 Rd7 are all lost for black. But my computer still thinks there is some life in black's position after 36.Kg1. So I propose a reply to 36.Kg1: 36...e3 and if 37.Rd3 then 37...Qg4. 

Aug1706   InspiredByMorphy: <Honza & Pawn and two> Your last posts turn into a complex and full of life position after 34.Rf2 Kf7 35.Rd2 Rd8 36.Kg1 e3 37.Rd3 Qg4
click for larger viewThere are two variations here to consider
a.) 38. Qxg4 fxg4 39. Nxe3 Nxe3 40. Rxe3 Rd2 41. Rc3 Bh4 42. g3 Be7 click for larger viewblacks advanced c pawn and whites restricted king look like it may be compensation for being a pawn down, and perhaps may accomplish a draw. b.) 38. Qh7+ Ke6 39. Qh6+ Nf6 and now if 40.Rxe3 Rd1+ 41.Kf2 Kd5 42.Bxf6 Kxc4
click for larger viewDue to the mobility of the pieces and safety of blacks king compared to the potential threats against whites king, It seems as though black has achieved compensation for the pawn with an attacking position. Instead ... 40. Rxd8 Bxd8 41. Nxe3 Qe2 42. Nf1 c4 43. Bxf6 Bxf6 44. Qg6 Qe4 click for larger viewTo me this position looks slightly better for white than the previous variation but black has a few factors in favor; the bishop in an open position, a more centered king, and the advanced c pawn. The position seems equal to me. Am I just biased or logically evaluating this? 

Aug1806
  Honza Cervenka: <Pawn and Two> <So I propose a reply to 36.Kg1: 36...e3 and if 37.Rd3 then 37...Qg4> Yes, that looks like a reasonable option. White has probably nothing better here than trading of Queens. But after 38.Qxg4 fxg4 39.f5 (taking e6 and g6 off the black King) white's ending is still clearly better (too many weak Pawns and bound pieces on black's side) and probably won by force. 

Aug1806
  Honza Cervenka: <InspiredByMorphy> In your line a), i.e. after trading of Queens white has no need to go hastily for ePawn. It can't escape. 39.f5 keeping black King back with intention Kf1e2 looks much better. Black has still significant tactical troubles with his bound pieces. For example, 39....Bg5 is bad for 40.Nd6+ and white wins. 

Aug1906
  Pawn and Two: <Honza Cervenka> After 38.Qxg4 fxg4 39.f5; it looks like black's best may be 39...Bh4. How do suggest white should continue? 

Aug2006
  Honza Cervenka: <Pawn and Two> <After 38.Qxg4 fxg4 39.f5; it looks like black's best may be 39...Bh4. How do suggest white should continue?> Maybe 40.Kf1. 

Aug2006
  Honza Cervenka: And if 40...Bf6 to prevent 41.Ke2 (41.Ke2?? Bxe5 42.Nxe5 Nf4+ ), then 41.g3. 

Aug2006
  Pawn and Two: <Honza Cervenka> The position is looking more favorable to white. After 41...Rd7 42.Ke2 Nb6 43.Rxd7+ Nxd7 44.Bf4 Bd4 45.Bxe3 Kf6 46.Bxd4+ cxd4, the knight endgame appears to be winning for white. So instead I will choose 41...Bxe5 and if 42.Nxe5+ then 42...Kf6. 

Aug2006
  Honza Cervenka: <Pawn and Two> 41...Bxe5 42.Nxe5+ Kf6 43.Nxg4 Kg5 44.h3 c4 45.Rd4 c3 46.Ke2 c2 47.Rc4 Kxf5 48.Nxe3+ Nxe3 49.Kxe3 Rb8 50.Rc5+ Kf6 51.Rxc2 Rb3+ 52.Kf4 Rxa3 53.Rc6+ is the best outcome for black which I am able to find and this Rook endgame looks still quite comfortably won for white though he should be still a little bit careful. 

Aug2006
  Pawn and Two: <Honza Cervenka> Very good. I think we have found the truth to the variation starting with <InspiredByMorphy's> suggestion of 27...Nxd5. In your latest analysis, after 53.Rc6+, I cannot find a way for Black to hold the position. However, the whole variation starting with 27...Nxd5, resulted in Black having some surprisingly good resources. It was much closer than what I expected when I first reviewed the position after 27...Nxd5. In fact, even after 53.Rc6+, the position is very close to a well known position from Fine's, "Basic Chess Endings": click for larger view In this position White to play wins and Black to play draws. In the position we reached after 53.Rc6+, note the similarities to Fine's position. However, I was unable to find a way to reach Fine's position with Black on the move. click for larger view. Here is a 3rd position from the game BernsteinCukiermann 1929: click for larger view There followed: 1...Ra1 2.Ra7+ Kg8 3.g6?? (3.h6! wins) 3...a2 4.Kg2 (threatening 5.h6) Rb1 5.Rxa2 Rb5 6.Ra8+ Kg7 7.Ra7+ Kg8 8.Rh7 Rg5?? (Rb3! draws) 9.Kh3 and wins. And a 4th position from the famous 1893 Tarrasch  Chigorin match: click for larger view In this game Chigorin selected the wrong plan and lost after 1...Ra2? 2.Kg4 Ra1 3.Ra6+. Tarrasch's notes to this game state that he believed the game was won even if Black played 1...a2. However, Chigorin later pointed out the correct defense: 1...a2! 2.h5+ Kf6 3.Kh4 Rh2+ 4.Kg4 Rb2 5.Ra6+ Kf7 6.Kg5 Rb5+! (Black dare not allow his King to be driven to the back rank) 7.Kh4 Rb2 8.g4 Rc2 (not 8...Kg7? 9.h6+ and 10.Kh5 winning) 9.h6 Rc6! and draws. Certainly not as easy ending even for some of the masters. 

Aug2106
  Pawn and Two: Beginning at move 28, Anderssen made a series of less than best moves, turning his winning position into one where he actually was at a disadvantage. At move 28, 28.Rh3 was better than 28.Bf6+.
At move 29, 29.Rh3 was better than 29.Qb2+.
At move 30, 30.Qd4 was better than 30.Rh3.
At move 31, 31.Ne5+ was better than 31.Qd4.
At this point, White's advantage had been reduced to a minimum. Black could now continue (.13) (18 ply) (Fritz 9) with 31...Bc5 32.Ne5+ Kg8 33.Qd2 Qd6 or he could continue as he actually played; (.16) (19 ply) with 31...Kg8. Fritz indicates the best continuation after 31...Kg8, is 32.Nxd6 Qxd6 33.Rh5 Qg6. Morphy chose 31...Kg8, and then Anderssen played 32.Rh6, instead of the stronger 32.Nxd6. Anderssen was now at a small disadvantage (.45) (18 ply) 32...Bf8. Fritz gives the following line as the best continuation: 33.d6 Qb5 34.Ne3 Rd7 35.Rh5 Rxd6 37.Rg5+ Rg6 37.a4 Qc5. Morphy's choice of 33...Rf7 put the game back to an equal basis (.00) (18 ply). Fritz indicates the best continuation is 34.Rh3 Qa4 35.Rg3+ Bg7. The game continued 34.Rh3 Qa4. Then Anderssen again made a choice not recommended as best by Fritz, for his 35th move. I will review the game's final 8 moves later. After 34 moves, the game was equal. The final 8 moves were filled with comments and controversy. 

Aug2106
  tamar: One of the troubles Anderssen had in this game is too many winning moves. Then he seemed to suffer a depression after mixing up the order. Beginning at move 27, Bxf6 starts figuring in on every move. Karsten Mueller on the Morphy CD gives 27 Bxf6 as an alternative to 27 Nc4 which has the practical defect of inviting the mind numbing complications of "27...Nxd5 28 Rb5!" (BTW this 1 move line is the extent to which they analyse a critical juncture, and I have to ask, why do chess authors such as Knaak and Mueller give such abbreviated lines, when they have all the space in the world. The lines are not in the least obvious, and could have made their CD immensely more valuable.) Those interested in how this line goes, see the fine analysis further up the page, as these unplayed moves make this the most interesting AnderssenMorphy encounter I have seen. 

Aug2106
  Pawn and Two: The game was equal after move 34.
On Anderssen's 35th move he could have taken a draw by 35.Rg3+ Bg7 36.Rxg7+ Rxg7 37.Qd5+ Kh8 38.Ne5 Rf8 39.d7 Rd8 40.Qe6 Rg7xd7 41.Nxd7 Qxd7 42.Qf6+. Instead, Anderssen played 35.Rc1?. This move gave Morphy a great opportunity by playing 35...h6! 36.Rg3+ Bg7 37.h3 Kh7 38.Qd5 Qd7 39.Rc2 Rc5 40.Qd1 Qe6 41.Rd2 Rd7. After 35.Rc1?, Fritz evaluated the position as (.90) (20 ply), but Black's advantage increases during this variation. I believe it is a winning line for Black. Morphy on his move then played 35...Rc5. Sergeant comments, <This stops the threat Qd5  Qe6.> However, Fritz rates 35...Rb5 as equal (.00) (18 ply), Morphy had just missed his winning opportunity. Fritz supplies the following continuation: 35...Rc5 36.Rg3+ Bg7 37.h3 h6 38.Qd2 Kh7 39.Ne5 Qa5 40.Rgc3 Bxe5 41.fxe5 f4 42.Qd4 with a draw. Also possible was 35...Rc5 36.Rg3+ Bg7 37.h3 h5 38.Kh2 Kh7 39.Qd2 Bh6 40.Rgc3 Qe8 41.Qf2. At the end of this variation Fritz finds the position almost equal, just slightly in favor of Black (.27) (16 ply). In the game continuation, after 35...Rc5 36.Rg3+ Bg7 37.h3, Morphy now goes wrong, playing 37...Kh8? As pointed out by Sergeant, Anderssen now had the opportunity of playing 38.Qd2! Instead, Anderssen played 38.Rxg7?. Sergeant remarked, <A sacrifice for which there was no necessity, since Qd2 left him with the superior game still in every variation.> Sergeant is correct. After 37...Kh8 38.Qd2, White has a strong advantage after every plausible defense by Black: 38...Rc4; 38...Qe8; 38...Qc6 or 38...Qd7. Anderssen has just missed his last winning opportunity for this game. After 37...Kh8 38.Rxg7, it is an equal position (.00) (19 ply) 38...Rxg7 39.Rc3 e3 40.Qf6 Rxc4 41.Qf8+ and the game would be a draw. Later Steinitz erroneously condemned Morphy's move 39...e3. Actually, 39...e3 was the only move that draws for Black, but Steinitz claimed a win for Black with 39...Rc8. However, after 39...Rc8, White has a clear win by playing 40.Qf6 Qe8 41.d7 Qxd7 42.Ne5 Rxc3 43.Nxd7. 40.Rxe3 was a tragic blunder. 40.Qf6 was a clear draw. Anderssen may have missed that his f4 pawn could be taken with check on move 42. A most interesting game, despite all the missed opportunities. 

Aug2206
  Honza Cervenka: <A most interesting game, despite all the missed opportunities.> Absolutely true. It was very intense and extremely complex fight with myriad of possibilities on both sides in almost every critical moment. I think that very few modern GMs would be able to handle similar positions avoiding all inaccuracies. Blunder like Anderssen's 40.Rxe3 is a mishap which can sometimes occur to anyone and it doesn't spoil the general deep impression of the game too much. Of course, 40.Qf6 and draw would have suited to this game a little bit better... 

Aug2206
  Pawn and Two: Here are a few variations at move 38, where I indicated Anderssen missed his last chance for a win. 37...Kh8?; 38.Qd2! Qc6 (1.72) (18 ply) 39.Rd1 Qd7 40.Ne5 Rxc5 41.Rxg7 Re8 42.Rxf7 Qxf7 43.Qc3+. Now the evaluation is at (2.70) (18 ply) and the suggested continuation is 43...Qg7 44.Qc4 Qd7 45.Qd4+ Qg7 46.Qd5 Rg8 47.g4. 37...Kh8?; 38.Qd2! Qe8 (2.26) (18 ply) 39.Ne5 Bxe5 40.fxe5 Qe6 41.Rxc5 bxc5 42.Qb2 Rf8 43.Rb3 a6 44.Rb7 e3 45.Re7 Qd5. Or if 40...f4 41.Rxc5 bxc5 42.e6 fxg3 43.exf7 Qxf7 44.Qc3+ Kg8 45.Qxg3+ Kf8 46.Qe5 Qd7 47.Qh8+ Kf7 48.Qxh7+ 37...Kh8?; 38.Qd2! Rxc4 (2.38) (18 ply) 39.Rxc4 Qxc4 40.d7 Rf8 41.d8(Q) Rxd8 42.Qxd8+ Qxg8 43.Qd7 Qf8 44.Qxa7 Qf6. 37...Kh8?; 38.Qd2! Qd7 (2.52) (19 ply) 39.Ne5 Bxe5 40.fxe5 Qe6 41.Rxc5 bxc5 42.Qb2 Rf8 43.Rb3. Certainly not easy, but in each of these variations, White attains a winning position. 

Sep1006   Alekhine Kid: I found an interesting idea for Morhpy on move 17... Nc6!? 18.Nxd6 Qxb3 19.Rxb3 cxd6 20.Rxb7 Rab8 21.Rd7 Rd8 22.Rxd8+ Nxd8 And Black's pieces are more active than white's in the endgame. I think it is good enough for a draw. 

Sep1006   Alekhine Kid: After 17...Nc6!? 18.Qa4! Black has to defend a difficult position with Nd8. 

Nov0206   tonsillolith: Why 11 ... g5 and not 11 ... Nc6? 

Nov1507
  nimh: Rybka 2.4 mp, AMD X2 2.01GHz, 10 min per move, threshold 0.33. Anderssen 5 mistakes:
29.Qb2+ 0.37 (29.Rh3 2.31)
35.Rc1 0.39 (35.Rg3+ 0.00)
38.Rxg7 0.00 (38.Qd2 1.26)
40.Rxe3 5.59 (40.Qf6 0.00)
41.Qf6 #4 (41.Qe5 5.75)
Morphy 4 mistakes:
11...g5 0.28 (11...Qh4+ 0.13)
27...Ke7 2.52 (27...Rg6 0.54)
35...Rc5 0.14 (35...h6 0.39)
37...Kh8 1.26 (37...h5 0.15) 

Jan1809   WhiteRook48: Another odd Anderssen opening. 

Aug1009   birthtimes: After 27...Ke7, Lasker cites 28. Be5 Bxe5 29. fxe5 Nxd5 30. Nd6 Rcf8 31. Rh3 Rg7 32. Rh6 and "White wins easily by systematic attack on the weak Black pawns. After 31...Kd8, White would occupy the c and d files." Lasker also writes, "Anderssen, who in seeking combinations merely follows his instincts, does not guide himself by the form and nature of weaknesses and therefore does not discover the strongest line of play. Obviously, the hfile is a Black weakness, also, the second and third [Black] ranks. On the other hand, the position of the White knight, queen, and f1 rook on the same diagonal would invite Qb5, if only the rook on b3 were away, for the knight on c4 is insecurely posted, the d5 pawn is weak. Therefore, not 28. Rh3 as indicated by a wellknown book on Morphy, but first evaluation of the knight on c4." Lasker's Manual of Chess, 1960, pp. 221222. 

Feb2311   Llawdogg: Game Six of the Match. Morphy had just won the last three in a row. Anderssen may have been broken already at this point. Morphy simply would not allow Anderssen to attack. Anderssen's only win up to this point was the long, drawn out first game. Morphy was winning all the games and winning them much more quickly. It was now clear who the better player was. 

Jul2413
  Check It Out: This game looks like it could have been played by two GMs today. 


< Earlier Kibitzing · PAGE 3 OF 3 ·
Later Kibitzing> 