Members · Prefs · Laboratory · Collections · Openings · Endgames · Sacrifices · History · Search Kibitzing · Kibitzer's Café · Chessforums · Tournament Index · Players · Kibitzing

(If you register a free account you won't see all these ads!)
Evgeny Najer vs Ilya Yulyevich Smirin
European Individual Championship (2014), Yerevan ARM, rd 4, Mar-06
Sicilian Defense: Richter-Rauzer. Neo-Modern Variation (B67)  ·  1-0


explore this opening
find similar games 2 more E Najer/Smirin games
sac: 33.Bxa4 PGN: download | view | print Help: general | java-troubleshooting

TIP: You can get computer analysis by clicking the "ENGINE" button below the game.

PGN Viewer:  What is this?
For help with this chess viewer, please see the Olga Chess Viewer Quickstart Guide.

Kibitzer's Corner
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·  Later Kibitzing>
Premium Chessgames Member
  hoodrobin: Moreover, I did not read the notation...

Today it is Sunday, isn't it?


Premium Chessgames Member
  morfishine: <41...Kf6>

Interesting spoiler


Premium Chessgames Member
  diagonalley: 43 .... K-K2 is simply out of this world! ... i'm gobsmacked
Premium Chessgames Member
  Once: An astonishing position. I managed to find part of the main line, but nowhere near enough to claim a solution.

It's clear that black isn't going to do any world-breaking with knight and bishop, so the story has to be about the f pawn.

It's a puzzle, so that means an unusual hard-to-see move, so that usually means a sacrifice. Interesting that a hard-to-see move becomes an easy-to-see move when we are in puzzle land, hm?

That means 41...f4 becomes our prime candidate. Not because it looks like a good move, not because we know whether or how it works. Simply because it's the puzzle move in the position.

What is white going to do? At first I thought 42. Rxc5 f3 43. Rf5 Bb7. But that just looks yucky for black because his king is trapped in the Nordic corner (that's the NE for those whose maps aren't centred on the UK)

So that means we are forced into our second puzzle move of the day. After 42. Rxc5 we need to play 42...Kf6 getting his Scandinavian majesty out of jail and intending Kf5 to protect the passed pawn.

The nuance I missed was 43. Rxc6 Ke7! Black has to stop the white rook from attacking the passed f pawn. But he has to do this from a high position, the seventh and six ranks. If he tries to run towards the pawn, white simply exchanges rook for pawn. This would leave him with a trivial win thanks to his queenside pawn plus.

An instructive position. The fact that we are in puzzle mode makes it much easier than it would have been in real life. I'm really glad not to have to face it OTB with the tock clicking.

Mar-09-14  paulofx2071: If 41...f4!! 42.Rxc5 Kf6! 43.Rc6+ Ke7 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Ra5 Ke6 then 46. a4, f2 47. b4 f1Q 48 a5
And rock and 3 pions united y passed versus queen. ¿Is lost?
Premium Chessgames Member
  FSR: As <Jamboree> already pointed out, after 41...f4!!, if White tries to avoid a draw with 42.Rf5, Black wins with the shocking 42...Nd3!!, e.g. 43.b3 (43.a4 Bc4!) 43...Bc8 44.Rd5 Nf2 45.Rd4 Nh3 46.Rc4 f3 47.Rc7+ Kf6 48.Rxc8 f2 49.Rf8+ Ke5 50.Rf3 Ke4 51.Rxf2 Nxf2 .

The normal (and inferior) 42... Ne6? is sufficient to draw, but even that is quite interesting. After 43. Kc1!, Black has a choice of:

43...Nd4 44.Rd5 f3 45.Rd7+ Kg8 46.Rd8+ Kg7 (46...Kf7?? 47.Rxd4 ) 47.Rd7+! Kf6!? [Black draws by repetition after 47...Kg8 48.Rd8+ or the trappy 47...Kh8 48. Rd8+!= (not 48.Rf7?? Kg8! )] 48.Rxd4 Kg5 49.Rd2 Kxh5=; and

43...Bc4 44.Kd2 (44. b3? Nd4! ) 44...Bxa2!? (shades of Spassky-Fischer Game 1; the sane 44...Bf1 45.Ke1 Bg2 46. Kf2 Bc6 is also equal) 45.b3 Bb1=. Houdini 3, not I, found all of this.

Premium Chessgames Member
  FSR: <paulofx2071: If 41...f4!! 42.Rxc5 Kf6! 43.Rc6+ Ke7 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Ra5 Ke6 then 46. a4, f2 47. b4 f1Q 48 a5 And rock and 3 pions united y passed versus queen. ¿Is lost?>

47.b4 is illegal because Black still has a pawn on b4. 47.b4 es ilegal porque Negro aún tiene un peón en b4.

Premium Chessgames Member
  patzer2: The drawing line is more complex than I thought.

After 41... f4! 42. Rxc5 (not 42. Rf5? Nd3!! ) 42...Kf6 43. Rc6+ Ke7 44. Rxa6 f3 45. Ra7+ Ke6 46. Ra6+ (position below),

click for larger view

only 42...Ke7!! holds the draw.

If 42...Ke5?, then 43. Ra8! gaining access to f8 for the Rook wins for White.

If 42...Kf7?, then 43. Rd3! gaining access to d1 for the Rook wins for white.

If 42...Kf5?, then 43. Rd3 or 43. Ra8 wins.

If 42...Kd5?? or 42...Kd7??, then of course 43. Rf6 is sufficient.

Premium Chessgames Member
  tamar: The number of nightmares associated with this position for Smirin depends on how much time he gave in considering 41...f4.

For example, I imagine he saw up to 41...f4 42 Rf5 Nd3 43 b3.

If at this point he gave up, as I did, with a mental shrug "nice idea, but Black's pieces are all tied down-the knight protects the pawn, the bishop must stay on the knight to avoid cxd3, and the King has no good moves", then he will have many sleepless nights wondering why he didn't consider 43...Bc8!

Having it occur after the time pressure, when he had time to find everything makes it worse trauma wise.

Premium Chessgames Member
  Jimfromprovidence: There's also the bishop interference angle.

We see this after 41...f4 42 Rxc5 Kf6 43 Rd5!?

click for larger view

If white tries to win by 44 Rd8 (seeing 45 Rf8+) black plays 44...Bc4!

click for larger view

If white tries to win by 44 Rd2 (seeing 45 Rf2) black plays 44...Be2!

click for larger view

Mar-09-14  Patriot: Black has 2 pieces for a rook and pawn--slight material edge to black. White threatens Rxc5 and Rxf5.

If there is a chance to win, I think black must give up a piece in order to get the pawns moving.


42.Rxc5 Kg5 followed by 43.Be2.

42.Rd6+ Kg5 doesn't help.

41...Kf6 is probably black's only hope.


So 41...f4 is the key. I'm wondering if 42.Rf5 Nd3 43.Ka1 Bc8 is the way. I'll check this out with Houdini.

Mar-09-14  Patriot: It turns out there are only two ways to really draw this: 41...f4 and 41...Kf6. Everything else is in white's favor.

My line, 42.Rxc5 Kg5 actually loses. Here, 42...f4! is needed. Curiously, 43.Rc6+ Ke7! is the only way to draw. 44.Rxa6 f3. It's funny that instead of the king escorting the pawn to promotion, it is instead used to make sure the rook never gets in position to capture it.

And I was right about 41...f4 42.Rf5 Nd3!. On 43.Ka1!?, 43...Bc8!.

Anyway, it's a very interesting problem and something to learn from.

Mar-09-14  Cheapo by the Dozen: Absent something clever on Black's part, his situation looks dreary. The f-pawn goes while he's saving his knight, he has to be careful not to avoid piece loss, and b-pawn is hard to defend as well.

So any winning chances seem to depend upon saving and pushing the f-pawn, even at the cost of the knight -- i.e. 41 ... f4 or 41 ... Kf6. But I don't think the simplest such line works (Black's 41 and 42 can be transposed), in that:

41 ... Kf6
42 Rxc5 f4
43 Rc6+ Kf7
44 Rxa6 f3
45 Ra5 Kf6
46 Ra8 Kf7

looks like a draw, not a Black win.

Also not successful is:

41 ...f4
42 Rxc5 Be2
43 Rf5 f3

and Black can never get his king into the act.

Hmm ...

Mar-09-14  Patriot: <Cheapo by the Dozen> Good job on today's puzzle! You certainly had all the right ideas, like guarding the attack squares rather than try to escort the pawn with the king.

43...Kf7 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Rd6 f2 46.Rd1 . This is why 43...Ke7! is the only way. And in the case of 43...Ke7 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Rg6 f2, white is lost.

Premium Chessgames Member
  chrisowen: I gave for one pawn f5 push in f4 looks about right, rook wheeled dutifuls in effect sine wave d5 creed,

to fly in duffed free down a flight in cad cuffed cap f4 off if ive got this correct wins having question of a fashion clean black knight comes to d3 after fed f4 rook f5 behind pawn to quoff at flies in the face of reason that black actually,

wins a feed f5 down ok I accept he could call the,

tune frog march a line for comparison under the,

table dirty handed trick would baffle most I guess a6 enacts a go getter king steps to the fore front and game is a drawn plug c5 the gap increases once f5 thinks to jet off black knight skim palm cone on d3 fans the flame chain gang cycle a6 raid as c8,

ersatz hi-light doesnt come a moment too soon " a fetch a find a ok " at the off load in every knight it is e4 delicate in delivery safe passaged home f1 boots too forever being moaps one for have off in botch a kind job f5 bone of contention f5 laps up query of being dipoff rook delve pander to plod up behind f5 looses the doors effective fee dress and bathe in f4 scurries to finger f1 true delight in dares a raid f5 ie classic case knight did come first in common good chip in 42...Nd3 43.b3 amicable wire bus in bed knight pawn bow to his demands a babel tower gets trapped in fifth rank to have and to hold it took in d3 as difficult for light to extricate himself c8 bishop and in ar good black knight in f2 oil the cogs team f5 down black is won by a margin sieve in blew away the remaining steps to f1 pawn takes knight splits a feint rook f5,

Sine d5 wave length in fat chance good to do the math I'm afraid check now ledge off re you have up ride a lion in e4 doesnt cut the mustard it ardent in aim again koinus agreed choose a wave in dangled knight see energy rates encircled in e4 on the scene a donkey of course should rook capture time cases the joint heading over now a f5 really duress

Ive fed f4 being comes in the shape of d3 dead in the water as put kind a duffed rook inceed jangled side in d3 engaged recent times tell a tap up pet in plain to see f5 wins by a neck back to the grind rook stone ape in a6 bishop across I c8 whose to say f4 cant promote again a pad feel the limp f5 soon gathers momentum and bides time seeking baggy,

trousers king for a day just back in the hood d5 bemoans lack of room in aka head it now in looks,

like at a 12.g4 as the baghop I new a move like that could disrupt he check in hurry it book in by a slots la bind f5 a gold boot d5 came about engage muscled the dark knight check et tu d3 brutes have up clean,

bill of health among one for to think cutoff dangle,

a mind alive duel to the end believe it is down in,

dig my covenant to single search among the ruins a feel f5 at wash away d5 a path being beaten a door down f5 as tender curious right affable mission select success springs eternal the band heads I against churlish maneovre in e4 I like ace in the pack c5 stays put in f4 log a complaint reverse the trend I agree more amiables a bath in d5 river sticks out head f5 down a harangues stable dip in bad call d5 I bag mission ie rib eye f4 all f5 take down choose allowed rubbered duck f5 wash over batch im liking g7 a nearer feed c5 in e4 manages to upset the applecart rook in wheel duffed a sacrifice as tender he big f4 hutoff queen in the making hope at heading ground for dig in motor que wrench to spin off f4 why I be proof for plum in clue like a thief in the knight back banters safe effect rook in d5 liven proceed knight line chubb have at segregate a king up ply in dipoff eggings whisk in c5 dark knight would better sense fluid in e4 well in ponder cageing he e4 toil a draw in gone at check off into choose again at bed horse duffed a dutifuls to bind every queens right a lane f5 descent off at glean am beady to believe g7 at able f6 comes to his rescue draw by repeat change I shall lots d5 port of call we stipulate a bet of freeze dryoff aim f4 arm in a tours hmm in fob a ne4...

Premium Chessgames Member
  chrisowen: Edge else where bus in e4 wave at bullseye quench a rib at stake defiant diligent rook d5 a kind of deed I think fluffs a cobble path in f4 epi-centre elects to fish instead beck and call c5 in e4 I care for baffled as to why not the lift gives aged in buffed try adds a focus again fluffs the climb knight back in ledge off re be edifice ogle c5 metered justice rook swipe off f5 he definately,

looking a method in the drive rag one delve rook at
dangles son slide away in light woah f5 at raceing

evermore batch am panging lights a feigning at enter peg f4 raw position gg to back hive spark our energy rates encircled get footholds to do f5 good game comes to a draw I 41...Ne4 instead provoke a mistake and go for find a ground champion took a 41...f4 42.Rxc5 Kf6 43.Rc6 Ke7 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Ra5 Ke6 = it your honour in hope case for alive no more be a flog success a feel ha 42.Rxf5 Nf6 43.Kc1 bag a net tell ie in way long live knights at in boots f6 an dangle kind squabble over h5 at door clock in face off 43.Rf4 b3 44.cxb3 Nxh5 45.Rd4 Nf6 46.a4 (1.95) 1 point ahead maybe ive,

cuffed chances a bet in fable give too for free a6 came length in on he big bed head north gate try 43...Be2 44.Kd2 Bxh5 45.Rb5 Ne4+ black could choose,

game in chow down free the bishop a foilable mission hood gang safe elegy in a bishop regale elephant chomp in b4 all clean ends well bowls 45...Bg4 46.Rxb4 1 point ahead (1.44) shunts eg a4 station in a8 wins for light

Mar-09-14  Cheapo by the Dozen: The next piece-sacrifice idea to try is

41 ... Ne6
42 Rd6 Kf6
43 Rxa6 f4
44 Rd6 f3
45 Rd1


But starting a pawn race at Move 44 doesn't work for White, as Black queens with check, then can keep checking until the advanced pawn is forked.

Bad news: I haven't found anything that works yet.
Good news: I may be coming up only one move short.

Mar-09-14  BOSTER: Because in the POTD pos.white best result is only draw (theoretically ) , he should reach this before with sacr. the rook.

click for larger view

After 37. Rxd5 is draw.a
White to play 37.

Mar-09-14  chupawan: ok i saw it on chessbase under under the nickname of astonishing endgame so... after all i do not think it is so obvious even kramnik or carslen will be in trouble to find it
Premium Chessgames Member
  agb2002: Black has a bishop and a knight for a rook and a pawn.

White threatens 42.Rxc5 and 42.Rxf5.

I've tried to reach winning positions like

click for larger view

but I couldn't find forced lines to achieve them.


Another idea was trying to corner the white rook as in a study by Wotawa (see for example Yusupov's "Chess Lessons", page 17):

click for larger view

White looks lost but has an incredible resource, 1.e4 fxe4 2.Kg7 Rh5 3.Kg6 Re5 4.Kf6 Re8 5.Kf7, draw.

This suggests 41... f4:

A) 42.Rxc5 Kf6 43.Re6+ Ke7 (43... Ke5 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Ra8 f2 46.Rf8 + -) 44.Rxa6 f3 45.Ra5 Ke6 46.Ra8 Ke7, etc.

B) 42.Rf5 Nd3

B.1) 43.cxd3 Bxd3+ 44.Kc1 Bxf5 - +.

B.2) 43.Ka1 Bc8 44.Rd5 Ne1, unclear but Black looks better.

B.3) 43.a3 bxa3 44.bxa3 Bc8 with a similar conclusion as B.2.


I don't think there is a forced winning line for Black.

Premium Chessgames Member
  Jimfromprovidence: I missed a step on my first post so I'll just redo it.

Besides 41...Rf4 42 Rxc5 Kf6 43 Rc6+, white can also try 43 Rd5!? The idea is for white to either get to Rf2 after 44 Rd2 or Rf8+ after 44 Rd8.

I believe black has to respond with 43…f3, below.

click for larger view

Now black's perfectly place bishop handles either threat.

If 44 Rd2 then 44…Be2.

click for larger view

If 44 Rd8 then 44…Bc4.

click for larger view

Mar-09-14  hedgeh0g: I'd seen this beautiful variation on the ChessBase website when it was published a few days back, so I didn't have the pleasure of solving this one myself.
Premium Chessgames Member
  patzer2: Correction to my last post here:

I meant to post "only 46...Ke7!! holds the draw," as all other King moves(46...Ke5?, 46...Kf5, 46...Kf7?, 46...Kd5??, 46...Kd7??) lose.

P.S.: Got the move number wrong in posting <42...Ke7>.

Mar-11-14  Overgod: I am gonna put it this way: I got the first two moves correct (f4!! and Kf6!!). It was educated/thoughtful guessing, rather than brute calculation. Houdini, the monster, saw it immediately. It took me at least half an hour of concentrated thought to find them.

Do I pretend to have fully understood this position whilst coming up with those moves? Nope. But I'll take the glory anyway.

Apr-03-17  Rafaelvleite: That could have been Smirov's immortal if he played f4 and also won!!!
search thread:   
< Earlier Kibitzing  · PAGE 2 OF 2 ·  Later Kibitzing>
NOTE: You need to pick a username and password to post a reply. Getting your account takes less than a minute, totally anonymous, and 100% free--plus, it entitles you to features otherwise unavailable. Pick your username now and join the chessgames community!
If you already have an account, you should login now.
Please observe our posting guidelines:
  1. No obscene, racist, sexist, or profane language.
  2. No spamming, advertising, or duplicating posts.
  3. No personal attacks against other members.
  4. Nothing in violation of United States law.
  5. No posting personal information of members.
Blow the Whistle See something that violates our rules? Blow the whistle and inform an administrator.

NOTE: Keep all discussion on the topic of this page. This forum is for this specific game and nothing else. If you want to discuss chess in general, or this site, you might try the Kibitzer's Café.
Messages posted by Chessgames members do not necessarily represent the views of, its employees, or sponsors.
Spot an error? Please submit a correction slip and help us eliminate database mistakes!
This game is type: CLASSICAL (Disagree? Please submit a correction slip.)

Featured in the Following Game Collections [what is this?]
Sunday; March 9th, 2014. (BTM, 41... '?')
from "Chess-Games" >Problem of The Day< (2014) by LIFE Master AJ
Sicilian Richter-Rauzer. Neo-Modern(B67) 1-0Interesting spoiler
from 7 Come 11 Makes About 187 by fredthebear
41... f4!!=
from 46c_R:B+N by whiteshark
Sicilian Richter-Rauzer. Neo-Modern(B67) 1-0Interesting spoiler
from Kolty's Single, Double, & TRIPLE KP Attack by fredthebear
41...? (Sunday, March 9)
from Puzzle of the Day 2014 by Phony Benoni
Incredible missed drawn masterpiece.
from Retarf's favorite games by Retarf
41...? (March 9, 2014)
from Sunday Puzzles, 2011-2017 by Phony Benoni
Omnia mea mecum porto.
by hanwubai
41. ...?
from Favorite problems of the day (2) by Gambit86
Sunday; March 9th, 2014. (BTM, 41... '?')
from "Chess-Games" >Problem of The Day< (2014) by Jaredfchess
The brilliant defensive resource on ending...that could've been
from Draws!: Stories of awe, bizarre and ingenuity by syracrophy

home | about | login | logout | F.A.Q. | your profile | preferences | Premium Membership | Kibitzer's Café | Biographer's Bistro | new kibitzing | chessforums | Tournament Index | Player Directory | Notable Games | World Chess Championships | Opening Explorer | Guess the Move | Game Collections | ChessBookie Game | Chessgames Challenge | Store | privacy notice | contact us
Copyright 2001-2018, Chessgames Services LLC