|Lone Pine (1975)|
The Fifth Louis D. Statham Masters-Plus Tournament was held at Lone Pine, California from April 13-24, 1975. Everybody was grateful for this, since that provided an excuse to call it simply "Lone Pine" instead of the official name.
The first four events had been mostly American affairs, but when six GMs showed up in 1974 Statham got curious as to how many the tournament could draw if he really tried. After due consideration, he doubled the prize fund and offered any GM in the world free travel and lodging.
That did the trick. Even with the non-response of the Soviet Union, 22 Grandmasters and eleven IMs showed up among the 44 players for what was the strongest Swiss-System tournament held up to that time.
Surprises began early when Larry Evans was beaten in the first round by the #2 woman in the world, Alla Kushnir. At least, if stories floating around can be believed, it was a surprise to Bobby Fischer, who supposedly called Pal Benko to ask how Evans explained what happened. Of course, Lone Pine veterans could remember back to 1971 when Evans won the initial tournament with six straight wins after a first round loss, and talk of the "Evans Swiss Gambit" resurfaced.
Be that as it may, Evans promptly reeled off four wins in a row, and by the two-day break following round five he was tied for first place with Miguel Quinteros and Gudmundur Sigurjonsson, with Walter Browne and Vladimir Liberzon a half-point behind. A huge group of eighteen players followed at 3-2, and would have something to say about matters before the finish.
Round six saw Quinteros drop back with a loss to Liberzon, who joined Evans, Sigurjonsson, and Browne in the top group at 4.5. Moving up to join Quinteros at 4.0 were Biyiasas, Gheorghiu, Panno, and Shamkovich.
Browne took the sole lead after round 7, defeating Sigurjonsson while Evans and Liberzon drew. Round 8 saw Evans defeat Browne to go past him to 6.5, where he was joined by Liberzon after a defeat of the fading Sigurjonsson. A half-point behind were Browne, Quinteros and Shamkovich.
Since Evans and Liberzon had already played each other as well as Browne, they were paired against Quinteros and Shamkovich. Evans had to resort to a perpetual for a draw, but Liberzon slowly outplayed Shamkovich to take the sole lead with a round to go. That proved to be a good time to do so; when Evans couldn't get anything going with Black against Gheorghiu in the last round (after a bitter dispute about the pairings), Liberzon was happy to take a draw with White against Gligoric to clinch first place..
This version of the crosstable allows a player's color in a game to be determined. If the result (W, L, D) comes first, the player had White. If the result follows the opponent's number, the player had Black. For example, Liberzon's first three results are draw with White vs. #36, win with Black vs. #38, win with White vs. #34.
GM norm: Norman Weinstein. IM Norms: Kim Commons, Alla Kushnir.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
01 Liberzon D36 38W W34 7 D 3 D W 6 2 D W10 11W D 8 7.5
02 Evans 21L W37 W23 16W W 9 10D D 1 W 3 6 D 4 D 7.0
03 Browne W23 13W D 9 6 D D 1 14W W10 2 L L 4 17W 6.5
04 Gheorghiu W22 19D D 5 18D D14 20W D11 9 D 3 W D 2 6.5
05 Weinstein W11 D 6 4 D D25 12D D26 22D 13W W18 9 D 6.5
06 Quinteros W42 5 D W41 D 3 29W 1 L D 7 24W D 2 11D 6.5
07 Panno 40W D18 25W D 1 10L W16 6 D L11 W20 15W 6.5
08 Gligoric 20W D14 10L W41 18D D 9 D23 19W W16 1 D 6.5
09 Benko 37W W21 3 D D29 2 L 8 D W13 D 4 12D D 5 6.0
10 Sigurjonsson D39 36W W 8 13D W 7 D 2 3 L 1 L W24 D12 6.0
11 Shamkovich 5 L W42 30D W34 19D W22 4 D 7 W L 1 D 6 6.0
12 Torre D30 15W D13 20D D 5 19D D18 23W D 9 10D 6.0
13 Biyiasas 32W L 3 12D D10 21W W29 9 L L 5 33W W25 6.0
14 Tarjan 44W 8 D D18 D19 4 D L 3 15D D22 34W D16 5.5
15 Denker 27D L12 D35 17L 34W W25 D14 31W W23 L 7 5.5
16 Suttles 35W L29 44W L 2 W30 7 L W41 W26 8 L 14D 5.5
17 Forintos D38 41L 39D W15 L22 30W W37 20D W21 L 3 5.5
18 Robatsch W33 7 D 14D D 4 D 8 24D 12D D21 5 L D19 5.0
19 Yanofsky W24 D 4 29D 14D D11 D12 26D L 8 27D 18D 5.0
20 Commons L 8 33W W31 D12 26D L 4 29W D17 7 L 24D 5.0
21 Kushnir W 2 9 L D26 24D L13 35W W27 18D 17L D22 5.0
22 Martz 4 L 24D D28 W39 17W 11L D 5 14D D26 21D 5.0
23 Pilnik 3 L W32 2 L D44 36W W28 8 D L12 15L W35 5.0
24 Csom 19L D22 38W D21 25W D18 31W L 6 10L D20 5.0
25 Damjanovic D34 28W L 7 5 D L24 15L 39W 38W W29 13L 5.0
26 Reshevsky 41D D30 21D W40 D20 5 D D19 16L 22D D27 5.0
27 Bilek D15 34L W36 30D D31 41D 21L W28 D19 26D 5.0
28 Tisdall W43 L25 22D L37 40W 23L D34 27L W41 32W 5.0
29 Schmid W31 16W D19 9 D L 6 13L L20 36W 25L D33 4.5
30 Ghizdavu 12D 26D D11 D27 16L L17 35L 43D W40 W36 4.5
31 Rossetto 29L W39 20L W35 27D 37W L24 L15 32L W34 4.5
32 Barnes L13 23L 42D W38 41L 34L W44 37W W31 L28 4.5
33 Berry 18L L20 37L 43D W42 W44 D36 41W L13 29D 4.5
34 Ervin 25D W27 1 L 11L L15 W32 28D W35 L14 31L 4.0
35 Silman L16 D40 15D 31L 39W L21 W30 34L W37 23L 4.0
36 Dake 1 D L10 27L 42W L23 W40 33D L29 D43 30L 3.5
37 Day L 9 2 L W33 28W 44W L31 17L L32 35L 43D 3.5
38 Karklins 17D L 1 L24 32L D43 42W 40D L25 44L W41 3.5
39 Levy 10D 31L D17 22L L35 43W L25 L40 42D W44 3.5
40 Vranesic L 7 35D W43 26L L28 36L D38 39W 30L D42 3.5
41 Parr D26 W17 6 L 8 L W32 D27 16L L33 28L 38L 3.0
42 Waterman 6 L 11L D32 L36 33L L38 D43 44W D39 40D 3.0
43 Grefe 28L L44 40L D33 38D L39 42D D30 36D D37 3.0
44 Rohde L14 43W L16 23D L37 33L 32L L42 W38 39L 2.5
In addition, brilliancy prizes were awarded in each round:
1st - Liberzon: $4000
2nd - Evans: $2500
3rd-8th - Browne, Gheorghiu, Weinstein, Quinteros, Panno, Gligoric: $650
9th-13th - Benko, Sigurjonsson, Shamkovich, Torre, Biyiasas: $120
Source: Grandmaster chess: the book of the Louis D. Statham Lone Pine Masters Plus Tournament, 1975 / by Grandmaster Isaac Kashdan and the staff of the California Chess Reporter (Jude Frazer Acers, Alan Benson, Robert Burger, Dennis Fritzinger, Guthrie McClain). San Francisco, CA: The California State Chess Federation, 1975.
Round 1: A Kushnir vs Larry Evans, 1975
Round 2: J A Grefe vs Rohde, 1975
Round 3: I Bilek vs Dake, 1975
Round 4: L Shamkovich vs R Ervin, 1975
Round 5: D Berry vs D Waterman, 1975
Round 6: L Shamkovich vs W Martz, 1975
Round 7: A Kushnir vs I Bilek, 1975
Round 8: Csom vs Quinteros, 1975
Round 9: D Berry vs P Biyiasas, 1975
Round 10: P Biyiasas vs M Damjanovic, 1975
PREVIOUS: Lone Pine (1974).
NEXT: Lone Pine (1976).
Original collection: Game Collection: Lone Pine 1975, by User: Phony Benoni.
| page 1 of 9; games 1-25 of 220
|1. L Schmid vs H Rossetto
|| ||1-0||30||1975||Lone Pine||A29 English, Four Knights, Kingside Fianchetto|
|2. K Commons vs Gligoric
|| ||0-1||28||1975||Lone Pine||E97 King's Indian|
|3. Silman vs Suttles
||0-1||34||1975||Lone Pine||B06 Robatsch|
|4. V Liberzon vs Dake
|| ||½-½||63||1975||Lone Pine||C84 Ruy Lopez, Closed|
|5. Browne vs Pilnik
|| ||1-0||55||1975||Lone Pine||C42 Petrov Defense|
|6. M Damjanovic vs R Ervin
|| ||½-½||53||1975||Lone Pine||B08 Pirc, Classical|
|7. L Day vs Benko
||0-1||58||1975||Lone Pine||B81 Sicilian, Scheveningen, Keres Attack|
|8. G Forintos vs A Karklins
|| ||½-½||26||1975||Lone Pine||E33 Nimzo-Indian, Classical|
|9. Gheorghiu vs W Martz
|| ||1-0||29||1975||Lone Pine||A16 English|
|10. A Kushnir vs Larry Evans
||1-0||36||1975||Lone Pine||A61 Benoni|
|11. D Parr vs Reshevsky
||½-½||30||1975||Lone Pine||C69 Ruy Lopez, Exchange, Gligoric Variation|
|12. C N Barnes vs P Biyiasas
|| ||0-1||43||1975||Lone Pine||B06 Robatsch|
|13. Rohde vs Tarjan
|| ||0-1||28||1975||Lone Pine||B25 Sicilian, Closed|
|14. Z Vranesic vs Panno
|| ||0-1||66||1975||Lone Pine||A56 Benoni Defense|
|15. N Weinstein vs L Shamkovich
|| ||1-0||33||1975||Lone Pine||B56 Sicilian|
|16. Robatsch vs D Berry
||1-0||39||1975||Lone Pine||D37 Queen's Gambit Declined|
|17. J D Tisdall vs J A Grefe
||1-0||55||1975||Lone Pine||B81 Sicilian, Scheveningen, Keres Attack|
|18. G Sigurjonsson vs D Levy
|| ||½-½||29||1975||Lone Pine||B70 Sicilian, Dragon Variation|
|19. Yanofsky vs Csom
|| ||1-0||72||1975||Lone Pine||B62 Sicilian, Richter-Rauzer|
|20. I Bilek vs Denker
||½-½||22||1975||Lone Pine||A20 English|
|21. Quinteros vs D Waterman
|| ||1-0||56||1975||Lone Pine||A07 King's Indian Attack|
|22. E Torre vs Ghizdavu
||½-½||44||1975||Lone Pine||A07 King's Indian Attack|
|23. Denker vs E Torre
||0-1||57||1975||Lone Pine||E62 King's Indian, Fianchetto|
|24. J A Grefe vs Rohde
||0-1||30||1975||Lone Pine||B08 Pirc, Classical|
|25. Gligoric vs Tarjan
|| ||½-½||45||1975||Lone Pine||D87 Grunfeld, Exchange|
| page 1 of 9; games 1-25 of 220
|Jan-14-15|| ||zanzibar: <Phony> has done the <Lone Pine (1975)> tournament here:|
Lone Pine (1975)
which presumably was promoted to here.
This tournament is also discussed elsewhere:
<"The 1975 Lone Pine Tournament had several small incidents - and one large one when grandmaster Larry Evans bitterly protested an unusual pairing given him in the last round by director Kashdan. Using his syndicated column (and) his regular feature in the national chess magazine, a pungent style and a capacity for enduring enmity, Evans has pounded the drum furiously and ceaselessly for eight months about Kashdan's iniquity. Joining Evans in this controversy has been Jude Acers, who writes the chess column for the new City of San Francisco magazine Acers reports that he and Evans will sue the editors of the book for having omitted the letter of protest that Evans wrote about that last-round pairing. They claim than [sic] Evans had furnished notes for the book without charge in exchange for the promise by the editors to include his steaming letter." - Don Thackrey, The Ann Arbor News.>
Sounds a bit juicy, but I must have missed any reference to it in the writeup above.
|Jan-15-15|| ||Phony Benoni: <zanzibar> I did the Lone Pine collections in a hurry, and for this one pretty much stuck to the tournament book. I didn't have that source at the time. By the way, I knew Don Thackrey and can vouch for his reliability..|
Last round pairing disputes generally prove little besides that there's a reason why Grandmasters rarely direct Swiss System tournaments. Still, this does seemed to have become enough of an incident to at least mention.
First, I'd like to get the basic facts together and see what was going on. Here are the top players going into the final round:
Liberzon 7.0 W (color due for)
Evans 6.5 B
Gligoric 6.0 B
Gheorghiu 6.0 W
Quinteros 6.0 B
Weinstein 6.0 B
[I think the 6.0s are in correct rating order.]
Liberzon and Evans have played, so both must meet 6.0s. As I understand the pairing rules (on which I am admittedly rusty, and I sure for heck don't know what they were in 1975), they get the highest-ranked players they have not yet met. Gigoric--Liberzon is fine. Cheoghiu--Evans works. That leaves Quinteros against Weinstein--oops, they have already played.
Now, I'll need to see Evans' side of the story, but I imagine this is where the conflict came in. Kashdan chose to drop Quinteros and Weinstein down to opponents in the 5.5 group. Evans probably argued that a different pairing should have been made within the 6.0 group to keep it together. Since he had already played Quinteros, that would leave Weinstein--Evans and Gheorghiu--Quinteros, all legal.
I think Kashdan was justified by the rules as I remember them, but it's certainly arguable. Though it would seem Evans had a bit of self-interest in mind--certainly he would prefer playing Weinstein instead of Gheorghiu.
|Jan-15-15|| ||Caissanist: <Phony Benoni> Yes, that was it exactly, there was a long back-and-forth in Chess Life & Review about it. Evans never played at Lone Pine again.|
|Jan-15-15|| ||zanzibar: Thanks both <phony> and <caissanist> for the info.|
<Evans never played at Lone Pine again.>
That fact alone means the controversy merits mention.
|Jan-21-15|| ||Howard: Oh, yes, the ol' 1975 Lone Pine last-round pairing dispute...|
Didn't Kashdan himself write an article in Chess Life & Review, defending his pairing decision ? I'm fairly sure that he did.
For the record, I still remember the magazine making the comment that the evening before the last round "Weinstein was practically the most popular person in town--everyone wanted to play him (in the last round)."
Translated, that meant that Weinstein was the lowest rated player among the leaders. That meant whoever was paired against him in the last round would probably have good winning chances. As it turned out, Weinstein drew with Evans.
|Jan-21-15|| ||Howard: Oops !!! Weinstein drew with BENKO, in the last round---not Evans.|
|Jan-21-15|| ||Phony Benoni: Evans' protest and Kashdan's reply can be found in "Chess Life & Review", September 1975, p.607-608. (Yes, the page numbers are correct. That year of the magazine had 900 pages. Those were the days.) This is a brief summary.|
Again, here is the situation:
1 Liberzon 7.0 (due for W; has played Evans, Quinteros)
2 Evans 6.5 (B; Liberzon, Quinteros)
8 Gligoric 6.0 (B)
4 Gheorghiu 6.0 (W; Weinstein)
6 Quinteros 6.0 (B; Liberzon, Evans, Weinstein)
5 weinstein 6.0 (B; Gheorghiu, Quinteros)
Melding the two accounts, the fun began the previous evening during the adjournment session when Evans asked Kashdan if the pairings were ready for the last round. When Kashdan replied that they would be posted the next morning at 10:00 AM as usual, Evans pressed him for just the top boards. Kashdan replied that it looked like:
<A) Liberzon-Weinstein, Gheorghiu-Evens, Quinteros-Gligoic>
Evans exploded, insisting that the only other possible pairing::
<B) Liberzon-Gligoric, Evans-Weinstein, Gheorghiu-Quinteros>
was "...clearly preferable since Liberzon, dropping a full point, should be required to meet the strongest rated player in that group. Every authority on the scene agreed." (quoted from Evans)
Evans' protest continued for some time. Eventually when all the adjourned games were finished, Kashdan returned to h is room and got to work.
First of all, he noted that two other sets of pairings were possible:
<C) Gheorghiu-Liberzon, Evans-Weinstein, Quinteros-Gligoric>
<D) Liberzon-Weinstein, Evans-Gligoric, Gheroghiu-Quinteros>
An important quote from Kashdan: "Since the top two had already played, <my normal system is to drop both to the next group, and then that as a six-player group.>" This produced Pairing C), which however Kashdan disliked because all three games were forced to have wrong colors. Since four players were due for Black and only two for White it was impossible to equalize colors in more than two of the games, and the pairing that does this and best keeps the players in natural order is Kashdan's original thought, pairing A).
Now, here is where Kashdan showed a sense of fairness, or perhaps a sense of humor: "<had Evans no objected I might have stopped here, and perhaps that is what I should have done. However, he did have a point. This was a very unusual situation. The leader was a full point ahead of any possible opponent. Perhaps he should play the stro9ngest man available.">
So Kashdan went back to work, and tried pairing Liberzon with the strongest opponent available, Gligoric. Then, since Evans was also dropping down to the next score group, it seemed only logical to also pair him with the strongest opponent available, Gheorghiu. That left a group of two (Quinteros and Weinstein) who had already played, so they too were dropped to the next highest group and the same procedure followed.
Now, reading everything, it looks like the pairings may not have been strictly correct at the time, but Kashdan felt they were the fairest available. And I do like the way he threw Evans in his face.
|Jan-21-15|| ||PhilFeeley: I'm sure I should know this, but what ever happened to Lone Pine? Did the sponsor run out of money? Why hasn't it continued to today?|
|Jan-21-15|| ||Olavi: It's explained on the last page: Lone Pine (1981)|
|Jan-26-15|| ||Caissanist: It turns out I was wrong about Evans never playing at Lone Pine again; he did play in 1978, tying for sixth.|
Spot an error? Please suggest your correction and help us eliminate database mistakes!
NOTE: You need to pick a username and password to post a reply.
Getting your account takes less than a minute, is totally anonymous, and 100% free—plus, it
entitles you to features otherwise unavailable.
Pick your username now and join the chessgames community!
If you already have an account, you should
Please observe our posting guidelines:
- No obscene, racist, sexist, profane, raunchy, or disgusting language.
- No spamming, advertising, duplicate or nonsense posts.
- No malicious personal attacks, including cyber stalking, systematic antagonism, or gratuitous name-calling of any gratuitous name-calling
of any members—including Admin and Owners—or any of their family, friends, associates, or business interests.
- Nothing in violation of United States law.
- No malicious posting of or linking to personal, private, and/or negative information (aka "doxing" or "doxxing") about any member, (including all Admin and Owners) or any of their family, friends, associates, or business interests. This includes all media: text, images, video, audio, or otherwise. Such actions will result in severe sanctions for any violators.
- NO TROLLING. Admin and Owners know it when they see it, and sanctions for any trolls will be significant.
- Any off-topic posts which distract from the primary topic of discussion are subject to removal.
- The use of "sock puppet" accounts to circumvent disciplinary action taken by Moderators is expressly prohibited.
- The use of "sock puppet" accounts in an attempt to undermine any side of a debate—or to create a false impression of consensus or support—is prohibited.
- All decisions with respect to deleting posts, and any subsequent discipline, are final, and occur at the sole discretion of the Moderators, Admin, and Owners.
- Please try to maintain a semblance of civility at all times.
NOTE: Keep all discussion on the topic of this page.
This forum is for this specific tournament and nothing else. If you want to discuss chess in general, or
this site, visit the Kibitzer's Café.
Messages posted by Chessgames members do not necessarily represent the views of Chessgames.com, its employees, or sponsors. All Moderator actions taken are at the sole discretion of the Admin and Owners—who will strive to act fairly and consistently at all times.
your profile |
Premium Membership |
Kibitzer's Café |
Biographer's Bistro |
new kibitzing |
Tournament Index |
Player Directory |
Notable Games |
World Chess Championships |
Opening Explorer |
Guess the Move |
Game Collections |
ChessBookie Game |
Chessgames Challenge |
privacy notice |
Copyright 2001-2019, Chessgames Services LLC