chessgames.com
Members · Prefs · Laboratory · Collections · Openings · Endgames · Sacrifices · History · Search Kibitzing · Kibitzer's Café · Chessforums · Tournament Index · Players · Kibitzing

🏆 Manila Interzonal (1990)

  PARTICIPANTS (sorted by highest achieved rating; click on name to see player's games)
Viswanathan Anand, Vasyl Ivanchuk, Boris Gelfand, Gata Kamsky, Michael Adams, Alexey Shirov, Valery Salov, Nigel Short, Aleksey Dreev, Mikhail Tal, Alexander Khalifman, Kiril Georgiev, Viktor Korchnoi, Mikhail Gurevich, Joel Lautier, Predrag Nikolic, Tony Miles, Rafael Vaganian, Yasser Seirawan, Lajos Portisch, Ljubomir Ljubojevic, Leonid Yudasin, Andrei Sokolov, Boris Gulko, Jaan Ehlvest, Johann Hjartarson, Miguel Illescas, Smbat Lputian, Robert Huebner, Simen Agdestein, Nick de Firmian, Kevin Spraggett, Sergey Dolmatov, Eric Lobron, Branko Damljanovic, Vasily Smyslov, Lubomir Ftacnik, Ian Rogers, Mihail Marin, Gyula Sax, Vasil Spasov, Murray Chandler, Roman Dzindzichashvili, Alonso Zapata, Walter Arencibia Rodriguez, Igor Stohl, Petar Popovic, Eugenio Torre, Jaime Sunye Neto, Margeir Petursson, Rongguang Ye, Gad Rechlis, Bozidar Ivanovic, Praveen Mahadeo Thipsay, Goran Cabrilo, Fouad El Taher, Stuart Rachels, Rico Mascarinas, Herman van Riemsdijk, Carlos Armando Juarez Flores, Leon Piasetski, Ta Lin, Assem Afifi, Slaheddine Hmadi

Chessgames.com Chess Event Description
Manila Interzonal (1990)

Eleven players from this Interzonal, which formed part of the 1990-93 World Championship cycle, would qualify for a series of Candidates matches to determine a challenger for the winner of the Kasparov - Karpov World Championship Match (1990) (who was Garry Kasparov). In recent years, the Interzonal had swelled from a single event to two, then three parallel tournaments. Such expansion had caused headaches for organizers, not least in securing the participation of the world's best players who had their commitments and preferences, but also in attempting to avoid clashes with other events and obtain suitable venues and prize funds. It was considered that one Swiss format tournament was a better solution. The GMA (Grandmasters Association, founded in 1987 by Kasparov) had planned to take the Interzonal over and run it in Murcia, Spain, where Kasparov was spending part of the summer. FIDE stepped in with a declaration that it would be held in Baguio City, Philippines. This was later changed to a split venue arrangement (Baguio and Manila) and then finally, a determination was made that Manila, Philippines would be the sole venue. Sixty-four participants played in a Swiss-format tournament of 13 rounds from June 29 until July 14 in the Ninoy Aquino Stadium. (1) Chief arbiter was Kok Ann Lim. (2)

Qualifying from the zonal tournaments were Chandler and Adams from Blackpool (1990), Illescas from Los Yebenes (1990), Lautier from Lyon (1990), Rechlis and Lobron from Bern (1990), Ftacnik and Georgiev from Stara Zagora A (1990), Marin and Stohl from Stara Zagora B (1990), Dreev, Yudasin, Lputian, Shirov and Khalifman from Lvov (1990), Damljanovic, Popovic, Cabrilo and Ivanovic from Mati (1990), Dzindzichashvili, Rachels, DeFirmian and Miles from US Championship (1989), Piasetski from Canadian Championship (1989), Zapata, Juarez and Arencibia from Cali (1990), Sunye and van Riemsdijk from Sao Paulo (1989), Anand and Thipsay from Doha (1990), Rongguang Ye, Ta Lin and Rogers from Shah Alam (1990), and Agdestein and Petursson from Espoo (1989) (= 36 players). (3) Short, Hjartarson, Spraggett and Portisch qualified by having reached the Candidates quarterfinals in the previous cycle. Ivanchuk, Salov, Korchnoi, Gurevich, Gulko, Ljubojevic, Ehlvest, Sokolov, Nikolic, Hübner, Tal, Dolmatov, Seirawan and Gelfand qualified by rating (based on a weighted average of the 1989 January and July rating lists). The latter three were rating reserves for Alexander Beliavsky, Zoltan Ribli and Ulf Andersson, who declined to participate. Spasov qualified as World Junior Champion. Torre and Mascarinas were nominees from the home country. Wildcard nominations from FIDE officials and chosen regional delegates resulted in the additional selection of Vaganian and Sax (who also had been rating reserves), plus Smyslov, Kamsky, Hmadi, Afifi and El Taher. (4)

It was uncertain who would play in Manila. Would Andersson participate? Beliavsky and Ribli declared that they would not. John Nunn could have claimed a place when they dropped out, but he was dissuaded by the constant changing of venue and other niggles. There was news that Beliavsky was replacing Iossif Dorfman as one of Kasparov's seconds, and this might have explained his surprising withdrawal. (5) The East Mediterranean zonal had concluded just ten days earlier, leaving players from that part of the world little time to prepare or rest. A number of players arrived early, in order to acclimatise to the tropical summer conditions. The Soviets chose Malaysia, with its similar climate, to prepare with their seconds. Representing the BCF, Nigel Short was accompanied by his assistant Lubomir Kavalek, and Adams and Chandler shared the services of William Watson. The rules stipulated that world ranking would be used to establish the Round 1 pairings. Using the not yet published July 1990 rating list, there were several changes at the top, and Gelfand emerged as the number one seed, pushing Ivanchuk down to number two. There followed Ehlvest, Salov, Kamsky, Gurevich, Seirawan, etc. (1) Games were played in a basketball stadium and at times it resembled an aviary, as birds could be seen flying low over the tables. It did, however, provide ample space for the hundreds of daily spectators. (5)

The Elo favorites Gelfand and Ivanchuk secured the first two places with nine points. The next six highest rated players did not qualify. Anand and Short tied for third, half a point behind the winners. Another half a point back, in the seven-way tie for fifth place, the remaining qualifiers were Sax, Korchnoi, Hübner, Nikolic, Yudasin, Dolmatov and Dreev. A "tragic" case was Gurevich. After eleven rounds he shared the first place with Gelfand and Ivanchuk, but then he lost both the remaining games and only managed to share twelfth place. Another tragedy happened in the final round between Damljanovic and Ljubojevic: the winner would qualify, but the game ended drawn. (6) In the last round, Short "had to win in order to reach the charmed circle of the eleven qualifiers for the Candidates matches. His opponent, on the other hand, required just a draw to guarantee his own qualification." (7) Using "techniques reminiscent of Emanuel Lasker, Nigel rose magnificently to the occasion and won a game which most grandmasters would have abandoned as drawn" (M Gurevich vs Short, 1990). (7) The game was the beginning of a winning streak that would lead Short all the way to the Kasparov - Short PCA World Championship Match (1993). Anand entered the WC cycle for the first time. He was later knocked out in the quarterfinal (by Anatoly Karpov). The 16-year-old Kamsky had moved to the USA in 1989 and had achieved a sensational 2650 rating, but the competition was too strong this time. The event could be described as a success for the Soviet camp, since five of their players qualified.

As the players awaited their return flight, an earthquake struck the Philippines (on 16 July). The island of Luzon and, in particular, Baguio City were among the worst affected areas. The Terraces Hotel, used for the Karpov - Korchnoi World Championship Match (1978) was the scene of considerable structural damage and loss of life. (8) The English contingent had been scheduled to stay in one of the Baguio hotels damaged in the earthquake, but the last minute switch to Manila had averted a potential disaster. (5) There was also a wave of political unrest in Manila at the time of the tournament. A bomb exploded in the car park of the hotel in which the players were staying. The principal casualty was Torre's Toyota Corolla. (8) Another upsetting incident involved Gelfand's second Albert Kapengut, who was robbed in Kuala Lumpur during a transfer of flights. (9)

Ninoy Aquino Stadium, Manila, Philippines, 29 June - 14 July 1990

Age Elo* 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 Pts 1 GM Gelfand 22 2680 =26 +42 +03 =14 +29 =05 =02 =11 +08 =12 =06 =09 +16 9 2 GM Ivanchuk 21 2680 -54 +41 +43 +21 +08 +48 =01 =06 =12 =10 =05 +17 =03 9 3 GM Anand 20 2610 =32 +44 -01 +49 -13 =54 +47 =18 =14 +29 +37 +12 =02 8.5 4 GM Short 25 2610 +20 -21 -13 =46 +33 +24 +07 -08 +30 +18 =11 =06 +12 8.5 5 GM Sax 39 2600 =22 +64 +51 +08 =48 =01 =12 =09 =13 =11 =02 =10 =07 8 6 GM Korchnoi 59 2630 =31 +33 =07 =15 +28 =30 +29 =02 =11 =13 =01 =04 =10 8 7 GM Hübner 41 2585 =38 +62 =06 =16 =17 =18 -04 +19 +48 +21 =10 =11 =05 8 8 GM Nikolic 29 2600 +13 +58 +12 -05 -02 =19 +40 +04 -01 =17 =21 =14 +25 8 9 GM Yudasin 30 2615 =45 +49 -29 +55 +25 =14 +48 =05 -21 +16 =12 =01 =11 8 10 GM Dolmatov 31 2615 =24 =23 +27 =11 +39 =29 +30 -12 +15 =02 =07 =05 =06 8 11 GM Dreev 21 2615 =44 =32 +22 =10 =21 +13 +14 =01 =06 =05 =04 =07 =09 8 12 GM Gurevich 31 2640 +43 +36 -08 +37 =14 +34 =05 +10 =02 =01 =09 -03 -04 7.5 13 GM Damljanovic 29 2515 -08 +53 +04 =51 +03 -11 +34 +16 =05 =06 -17 =19 =15 7.5 14 GM Georgiev 24 2580 +57 =16 +17 =01 =12 =09 -11 =31 =03 =15 +28 =08 =20 7.5 15 GM Ljubojevic 29 2600 +40 =29 =16 =06 =18 =17 =21 +22 -10 =14 +36 =25 =13 7.5 16 GM Ehlvest 27 2655 +56 =14 =15 =07 =30 =23 +19 -13 +31 -09 +22 +21 -01 7.5 17 GM Khalifman 24 2615 =33 +31 -14 +24 =07 =15 +23 =21 =29 =08 +13 -02 =19 7.5 18 GM Seirawan 30 2635 =42 =26 =30 +56 =15 =07 =31 =03 +40 -04 =27 =24 +22 7.5 19 GM Shirov 17 2580 =55 =35 =23 =33 +42 =08 -16 -07 +32 +50 +29 =13 =17 7.5 20 GM Hjartarson 27 2520 -04 +61 -37 -40 +38 -36 +45 =47 +54 =39 +42 +34 =14 7.5 21 GM DeFirmian 32 2560 +61 +04 =48 -02 =11 +37 =15 =17 +09 -07 =08 -16 =28 7 22 GM Rechlis 23 2505 =05 =28 -11 +27 =47 =25 +46 -15 +41 +48 -16 +37 -18 7 23 IM Spasov 19 2495 =34 =10 =19 +36 =51 =16 -17 =44 -39 +43 =35 =26 +49 7 24 IM Stohl 25 2525 =10 -34 +45 -17 +58 -04 +43 +39 =50 -37 +44 =18 =27 7 25 GM Adams 18 2590 +46 =63 +50 -29 -09 =22 =39 =49 +44 =27 +30 =15 -08 7 26 GM Dzindzichashvili 46 2560 =01 =18 +38 -30 =31 =46 =63 =34 =36 =42 =39 =23 +41 7 27 GM Ftacnik 32 2550 -51 +59 -10 -22 +64 =32 +57 =37 +34 =25 =18 =36 =24 7 28 GM Gulko 43 2600 =64 =22 =32 +58 -06 =47 =41 =36 =33 +31 -14 +45 =21 7 29 GM Lautier 17 2570 +60 =15 +09 +25 -01 =10 -06 +50 =17 -03 -19 =39 =35 6.5 30 GM Lputian 32 2575 +59 =51 =18 +26 =16 =06 -10 =48 -04 +33 -25 =41 =36 6.5 31 GM Illescas Cordoba 24 2535 =06 -17 =64 +38 =26 +51 =18 =14 -16 -28 =32 +44 =37 6.5 32 GM Ivanovic 40 2520 =03 =11 =28 -50 =36 =27 =53 =54 -19 +55 =31 =48 +56 6.5 33 GM Torre 38 2530 =17 -06 +62 =19 -04 =49 =42 +46 =28 -30 -45 +51 +48 6.5 34 GM Agdestein 23 2600 =23 +24 +63 -48 +50 -12 -13 =26 -27 +52 +40 -20 =39 6.5 35 IM Marin 25 2485 =37 =19 =36 -39 =49 =42 -56 +55 +47 =40 =23 =50 =29 6.5 36 GM Tal 53 2580 +52 -12 =35 -23 =32 +20 =37 =28 =26 +56 -15 =27 =30 6.5 37 GM Miles 35 2595 =35 =55 +20 -12 +43 -21 =36 =27 +49 +24 -03 -22 =31 6.5 38 GM Sunye Neto 33 2465 =07 =39 -26 -31 -20 =60 =59 +58 =53 +47 =48 =42 +50 6.5 39 GM Sokolov 27 2570 =62 =38 =54 +35 -10 =41 =25 -24 +23 =20 =26 =29 =34 6.5 40 GM Popovic 31 2520 -15 =60 =42 +20 +63 =50 -08 +56 -18 =35 -34 =49 =45 6 41 IM Cabrilo 32 2485 -48 -02 =59 +60 +56 =39 =28 =42 -22 +49 =50 =30 -26 6 42 GM Spraggett 35 2540 =18 -01 =40 +64 -19 =35 =33 =41 +51 =26 -20 =38 =46 6 43 GM Zapata 31 2545 -12 +52 -02 +53 -37 =57 -24 -51 +61 -23 +58 =54 +55 6 44 GM Rongguang Ye 26 2525 =11 -03 -49 +62 -55 +58 +51 =23 -25 +57 -24 -31 +54 6 45 GM Lobron 30 2535 =09 -50 -24 =59 +52 -56 -20 =57 +60 +54 +33 -28 =40 6 46 IM Rachels 20 2475 -25 +47 =58 =04 =54 =26 -22 -33 -57 +62 =56 +52 =42 6 47 GM Petursson 30 2550 -63 -46 +57 +52 =22 =28 -03 =20 -35 -38 +60 =56 +59 6 48 GM Portisch 53 2590 +41 +54 =21 +34 =05 -02 -09 =30 -07 -22 =38 =32 -33 5.5 49 GM Rogers 30 2535 =50 -09 +44 -03 =35 =33 +55 =25 -37 -41 +53 =40 -23 5.5 50 GM Vaganian 38 2630 =49 +45 -25 +32 -34 =40 +54 -29 =24 -19 =41 =35 -38 5.5 51 Kamsky 16 2650 +27 =30 -05 =13 =23 -31 -44 +43 -42 =53 =52 -33 +60 5.5 52 IM Ta Lin 27 2435 -36 -43 +61 -47 -45 +64 +62 =53 =56 -34 =51 -46 +58 5.5 53 GM Smyslov 69 2570 -58 -13 +60 -43 -57 +59 =32 =52 =38 =51 -49 =62 +61 5.5 54 GM Chandler 30 2560 +02 -48 =39 =63 =46 =03 -50 =32 -20 -45 +61 =43 -44 5 55 IM Mascarinas 37 2465 =19 =37 =56 -09 +44 -63 -49 -35 +59 -32 +62 =61 -43 5 56 IM Arencibia 22 2555 -16 +57 =55 -18 -41 +45 +35 -40 =52 -36 =46 =47 -32 5 57 IM van Riemsdijk 41 2440 -14 -56 -47 +61 +53 =43 -27 =45 +46 -44 =59 -60 =62 5 58 IM El Taher 25 2375 +53 -08 =46 -28 -24 -44 =60 -38 =62 =61 -43 +59 -52 4 59 IM Juarez Flores 24 2425 -30 -27 =41 =45 =62 -53 =38 =61 -55 +60 =57 -58 -47 4 60 IM Piasetski 38 2410 -29 =40 -53 -41 =61 =38 =58 =62 -45 -59 -47 +57 -51 3.5 61 IM Hmadi 2335 -21 -20 -52 -57 =60 =62 +64 =59 -43 =58 -54 =55 -53 3.5 62 IM Afifi 43 2400 =39 -07 -33 -44 =59 =61 -52 =60 =58 -46 -55 =53 =57 3.5 63 GM Salov 26 2655 +47 =25 -34 =54 -40 +55 =26 3.5 64 IM Thipsay 30 2490 =28 -05 =31 -42 -27 -52 -61 1

Salov and Thipsay retired due to illness after seven rounds. (8) The brilliancy prize went to DeFirmian for Miles vs de Firmian, 1990. (10)

A playoff was not necessary: the top eleven finishers (with 8 or more points) joined Jan Timman, Artur Yusupov and Jonathan Speelman (who were Candidates quarterfinal winners in the previous cycle) for the seven 1/8-final matches in 1991. The pairings for these matches were announced soon after the tournament: (11)

Yusupov - Dolmatov Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)
Ivanchuk - Yudasin Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)
Short - Speelman Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)
Timman - Huebner Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)
Gelfand - Nikolic Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)
Korchnoi - Sax Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)
Anand - Dreev Candidates Eighthfinal (1991)

The seven winners of these matches were in turn joined by Anatoly Karpov (the Candidates final winner in the previous cycle) for the quarterfinal matches: Timman - Korchnoi Candidates Quarterfinal (1991), Yusupov - Ivanchuk Candidates Quarterfinal (1991), Short - Gelfand Candidates Quarterfinal (1991) and Karpov - Anand Candidates Quarterfinal (1991) (all four in Brussels in August). Next followed the Timman - Yusupov Candidates Semifinal (1992) and Short - Karpov Candidates Semifinal (1992), and finally the Short - Timman Candidates Final (1993). Then in February 1993, Kasparov and Short announced the creation of the PCA (Professional Chess Association) and refused to play the Kasparov - Short PCA World Championship Match (1993) under the jurisdiction of FIDE. Kasparov was stripped of his FIDE title in March 1993, whereas Karpov and Timman agreed to play the Karpov - Timman FIDE World Championship Match (1993). (12)

Tournament book: MANILA izt 1990 by Lubomir Ftacnik & Igor Stohl (Prager Schachagentur, 1990. 159 pp.). Source not seen: Manila 1990 Interzonal - Fighting for the world championship swiss style by Yevgeniy Vladimirov (New in Chess no. 6, 1990, pp. 8 ff.).

*FIDE Rating List July 1990 (https://web.archive.org/web/2022100...).

Notes

(1) British Chess Magazine, August 1990, pp. 342-344.
(2) Lim Kok Ann's autobiography at http://limkokann.blogspot.no/2009/0...
(3) Mark Weeks at http://www.mark-weeks.com/chess/zon...
(4) Sahovski Informator, vol. 48, 1989, p. 466.
(5) William Watson in CHESS, October 1990, pp. 24-29.
(6) MANILA izt 1990 by Ftacnik and Stohl (1990).
(7) Raymond Keene in The Spectator, 20 July 1990, p. 44.
(8) British Chess Magazine, September 1990, pp. 370-377.
(9) A chess coach who brought up three grandmasters, by Abram Gelfand in Mishpoha, no. 21 (http://mishpoha.org/n21/21a31.php).
(10) Nick de Firmian in Kingpin, 19 September 2013 (http://www.kingpinchess.net/2013/09...).
(11) Tidskrift för Schack, October 1990, p. 339.
(12) Mark Weeks at http://www.mark-weeks.com/chess/wcc...

The original game collection by User: thomastonk has been deleted. The introduction was made with contributions from User: zanzibar, User: Chessical, User: OhioChessFan, User: Retireborn, User: Annie K., User: crawfb5, User: Tabanus and User: Paint My Dragon.

 page 1 of 17; games 1-25 of 410  PGN Download
Game  ResultMoves YearEvent/LocaleOpening
1. Adams vs S Rachels  1-0311990Manila InterzonalB63 Sicilian, Richter-Rauzer Attack
2. B Ivanovic vs Anand  ½-½331990Manila InterzonalC50 Giuoco Piano
3. S Hmadi vs de Firmian  0-1521990Manila InterzonalB22 Sicilian, Alapin
4. R Ye vs Dreev  ½-½931990Manila InterzonalA48 King's Indian
5. Gelfand vs Dzindzichashvili ½-½321990Manila InterzonalE12 Queen's Indian
6. Khalifman vs E Torre  ½-½251990Manila InterzonalE97 King's Indian
7. Kamsky vs Ftacnik 1-0371990Manila InterzonalD02 Queen's Pawn Game
8. P Thipsay vs Gulko  ½-½301990Manila InterzonalC02 French, Advance
9. Korchnoi vs M Illescas  ½-½611990Manila InterzonalD34 Queen's Gambit Declined, Tarrasch
10. Chandler vs Ivanchuk 1-0491990Manila InterzonalC19 French, Winawer, Advance
11. P Popovic vs Ljubojevic  0-1331990Manila InterzonalB81 Sicilian, Scheveningen, Keres Attack
12. Miles vs M Marin ½-½471990Manila InterzonalB25 Sicilian, Closed
13. Petursson vs Salov  0-1491990Manila InterzonalE32 Nimzo-Indian, Classical
14. G Cabrilo vs Portisch  0-1351990Manila InterzonalC65 Ruy Lopez, Berlin Defense
15. I Rogers vs Vaganian ½-½411990Manila InterzonalC10 French
16. Shirov vs R Mascarinas ½-½541990Manila InterzonalD17 Queen's Gambit Declined Slav
17. Short vs Hjartarson 1-0621990Manila InterzonalB12 Caro-Kann Defense
18. Smyslov vs F El Taher 0-1251990Manila InterzonalA22 English
19. Seirawan vs K Spraggett  ½-½131990Manila InterzonalE73 King's Indian
20. Dolmatov vs I Stohl ½-½621990Manila InterzonalB84 Sicilian, Scheveningen
21. Tal vs Ta Lin 1-0621990Manila InterzonalA34 English, Symmetrical
22. P Nikolic vs Damljanovic  1-0421990Manila InterzonalA42 Modern Defense, Averbakh System
23. H van Riemsdijk vs K Georgiev 0-1781990Manila InterzonalB76 Sicilian, Dragon, Yugoslav Attack
24. A Zapata vs M Gurevich  0-1401990Manila InterzonalB06 Robatsch
25. J Sunye Neto vs Huebner  ½-½351990Manila InterzonalA29 English, Four Knights, Kingside Fianchetto
 page 1 of 17; games 1-25 of 410  PGN Download
  REFINE SEARCH:   White wins (1-0) | Black wins (0-1) | Draws (1/2-1/2)  

Kibitzer's Corner
Nov-21-15  Fiona Macleod: <There was also a wave of political unrest in Manila at the time of the tournament. A bomb exploded in the car park of the hotel in which the players were staying. The principal casualty was Torre's Toyota Corolla.>

I wonder if the car was repaired?

Dec-08-15  Sularus: First time I've heard of this tournament (or maybe I just forgot). Never knew these great players were here at the same time.
Dec-08-15  Howard: This was actually the first time that the interzonal was held in the form of a Swiss. It was done to save money, as opposed to having three round-robins, like in 1982, 1985, and 1987.

Inside Chess magazine had a nice writeup on the event, as I recall.

Dec-08-15
Premium Chessgames Member
  offramp: <Fiona Macleod: <There was also a wave of political unrest in Manila at the time of the tournament. A bomb exploded in the car park of the hotel in which the players were staying. The principal casualty was Torre's Toyota Corolla.> I wonder if the car was repaired?>

Yes. The car was repaired and is now in the collection of a Mr Jerome Seinfeld of New York, who paid $275,226.19₵ for it.

Dec-08-15
Premium Chessgames Member
  Fusilli: <offramp> I don't get the joke. Clarify?
Dec-08-15
Premium Chessgames Member
  offramp: Jerry Seinfeld is a collector of vintage and expensive cars. But he would not normally be interested in a 1989 Toyota Corolla.
Dec-09-15
Premium Chessgames Member
  Fusilli: <offramp> Ah, okay, thanks!
Dec-09-15  MyCoachingDreams: <offramp: Jerry Seinfeld is a collector of vintage and expensive cars. But he would not normally be interested in a 1989 Toyota Corolla.>

But that would be a prized possession for a struggling GM like Torre in a poor country like the Philippines. <Fiona Macleod> should know. He/she's a struggling lawyer who owns a beat-up car just like Torre.

Feb-12-16  DirkMcCallahan: Does anyone know the tiebreak rules for this tourney? Dominic Lawson claims that Gurevich only needed a draw against Short to qualify, but had their game been drawn, wouldn't both of them have ended up with 8 points?
Feb-12-16  Howard: According to the now-defunct magazine Inside Chess, any players who tied for the last spot(s), would have the tie broken by averaging together the ratings of the top-12 players whom they had played against. In other words, the lowest-rated opponent, out of the 13 in total, would be thrown out--his rating would not count.

As it turned out, tiebreaks weren't necessary in this event---but in the 1993 Interzonal, in Biel, it was a very different story.

As far as Lawson's claim, he was probably assuming that if Gurevich had finished with eight points--by drawing against Short--he almost certainly would have had favorable tiebreaks, and thus qualified.

The reason is because Gurevich at one point in the event was at an excellent score of +4. Then he lost to Anand in Round 12, and then to Short in Round 13. With a +4 score after 11 rounds, he would almost certainly have had a high "average rating of opposition" score.

Look up the chart on various websites, which gives the rating of each participate, if you like. See for yourself what Gurevich's tiebreak would have translated to.

Feb-12-16  Howard: On second thought, look at the ABOVE chart. Just noticed...the ratings are given there.
Feb-23-24
Premium Chessgames Member
  marcusantoinerome: <DirkMcCallahan> and <Howard>

I have the tournament book by Lubomir Ftacnik and Igor Stohl. It has the cross table and the ARO (average of rated opponents). Gurevich was 2608 and Short was 2570. Of the seven who finished with 8 points, the highest was Sax with 2598. So if Short and Gurevich drew their last round game — and all other results were the same — then Gurevich would have been the 4th qualifier into the Candidates, not Short.

Feb-24-24
Premium Chessgames Member
  perfidious: Regrettably, <Howard> will not be responding to anyone; he took his leave in summer 2020.

There were so many variables entering the last round; Ehlvest played for a win vs Gelfand because his tiebreaks were unfavourable, in a situation where one would expect Gelfand to sign an early peace treaty in normal circumstances; Nikolic entered a known drawing line as Black against Adams, who had a chance at qualifying with a win, but let slip--the list goes on.

Feb-24-24
Premium Chessgames Member
  marcusantoinerome: <perfidious> Thanks for letting us know about <Howard>. That’s sad news.

NOTE: Create an account today to post replies and access other powerful features which are available only to registered users. Becoming a member is free, anonymous, and takes less than 1 minute! If you already have a username, then simply login login under your username now to join the discussion.

Please observe our posting guidelines:

  1. No obscene, racist, sexist, or profane language.
  2. No spamming, advertising, duplicate, or gibberish posts.
  3. No vitriolic or systematic personal attacks against other members.
  4. Nothing in violation of United States law.
  5. No cyberstalking or malicious posting of negative or private information (doxing/doxxing) of members.
  6. No trolling.
  7. The use of "sock puppet" accounts to circumvent disciplinary action taken by moderators, create a false impression of consensus or support, or stage conversations, is prohibited.
  8. Do not degrade Chessgames or any of it's staff/volunteers.

Please try to maintain a semblance of civility at all times.

Blow the Whistle

See something that violates our rules? Blow the whistle and inform a moderator.


NOTE: Please keep all discussion on-topic. This forum is for this specific tournament only. To discuss chess or this site in general, visit the Kibitzer's Café.

Messages posted by Chessgames members do not necessarily represent the views of Chessgames.com, its employees, or sponsors.
All moderator actions taken are ultimately at the sole discretion of the administration.

Spot an error? Please suggest your correction and help us eliminate database mistakes!

Copyright 2001-2025, Chessgames Services LLC